Wait, is Tarte Shape Tape Cloud Coverage Actually Better Than the Original?

Wait, is Tarte Shape Tape Cloud Coverage Actually Better Than the Original?

Makeup trends move fast. One second everyone wants to look like a glazed donut, and the next, we're all hunting for that "cloud skin" finish that looks soft but not flat. If you've spent any time in a Sephora or scrolled through beauty TikTok lately, you've definitely seen the buzz around Shape Tape Cloud Coverage. It’s basically Tarte’s attempt at taking their most famous, high-intensity concealer and turning it into a breathable, everyday foundation.

But here is the thing.

The original Shape Tape is iconic for a reason—it hides everything from dark circles to bad decisions—but it's heavy. It’s a lot. Shape Tape Cloud Coverage exists because most of us don't actually want to wear a mask every single day. We want skin that looks like skin, just... better. After testing it in different lighting and seeing how it holds up through an actual work day, I’ve realized it’s not just a lighter version of the concealer. It’s a completely different beast.

What is Shape Tape Cloud Coverage anyway?

Technically, it's a medium-coverage foundation with an SPF 15 kicker. Tarte calls it "dreamy" and "light-as-air," which sounds like marketing fluff, but the texture actually backs it up. It has this bouncy, mousse-like consistency. It’s weirdly satisfying to touch. Unlike traditional liquid foundations that run down the back of your hand, this stays put until you blend it out.

The formula relies heavily on what they call "cloud 9 complex." Basically, that’s a fancy way of saying it’s packed with hyaluronic acid, squalane, and snow mushroom. If you track skincare ingredients, you know these are the heavy hitters for hydration. Squalane is particularly great because it mimics your skin's natural oils, which helps the product melt in rather than sitting on top of your pores like a layer of paint.

Most people get confused about where this fits in their routine. Is it a tinted moisturizer? No. It has way more pigment than that. Is it a full-coverage foundation? Honestly, no. If you have active cystic acne or very dark hyperpigmentation, you’re still going to need a spot concealer. But for evening out redness or hiding a bit of dullness? It’s perfect.

The "Cloud Skin" finish vs. The matte trap

For years, the industry was obsessed with "matte." Then it swung wildly toward "dewy." Shape Tape Cloud Coverage occupies that middle ground we call "natural matte" or "blurred."

📖 Related: Popeyes Louisiana Kitchen Menu: Why You’re Probably Ordering Wrong

When you first apply it, it feels wet and cool. As it sets, it transforms. It doesn't get crunchy or dry like the original Shape Tape concealer can. Instead, it creates this soft-focus effect. Think of it like a permanent Instagram filter from 2014, but without the weird yellow tint. It blurs the edges of your pores.

One thing you'll notice immediately: it’s incredibly forgiving.

If you have fine lines—especially around the mouth or eyes—heavy foundations tend to settle in and scream "I'M WEARING MAKEUP!" This stuff doesn't do that as much. Because it’s so airy, it moves with your face. You can smile, eat a sandwich, or laugh at a joke without your face cracking into a thousand tiny tectonic plates.

Why the SPF 15 is a bit of a lie

Let's be real for a second. The bottle says SPF 15. That is great for marketing, but in practice, it’s almost useless. To get the actual SPF 15 protection listed on the label, you would have to apply a massive amount of foundation—way more than anyone actually wears.

You should still be wearing a dedicated sunscreen underneath. Think of the SPF in the foundation as a tiny insurance policy, not the whole plan. Dermatologists like Dr. Shereene Idriss have talked about this for ages—makeup with SPF is a supplement, not a substitute. If you're relying on Shape Tape Cloud Coverage to protect you during a beach day, you’re going to get burned. Literally.

How to actually apply it (The sponge vs. Brush debate)

I've tried applying this with my fingers, a dense buffing brush, and a damp beauty sponge. The results were surprisingly different each time.

👉 See also: 100 Biggest Cities in the US: Why the Map You Know is Wrong

  1. The Fingers: Honestly, this is the way to go if you're in a rush. The heat from your hands helps the squalane in the formula melt. It gives the most natural, "no-makeup" look.
  2. The Brush: This provides the most coverage. If you want to look "done," use a dense brush. Just be careful, because if you overwork it, the mousse texture can start to pill, especially if your moisturizer underneath hasn't fully dried.
  3. The Damp Sponge: This is the gold standard for that "cloud" effect. It shears it out just enough to let your freckles peek through while still hiding redness.

Pro tip: Don't use a primer that is super silicone-heavy. Shape Tape Cloud Coverage is water and glycerin-based. If you put a thick silicone primer under it, the foundation might slide right off your nose by lunchtime. Stick to a water-based moisturizer or a gripping primer like Power Grip or Milk’s Hydro Grip.

Real talk on longevity and skin types

If you have extremely oily skin, you might struggle with this after the 6-hour mark. Even though it's called "matte," those hydrating ingredients like snow mushroom mean it stays "juicy." By 3:00 PM, your T-zone might look a little more "greasy" than "cloud-like." A quick dust of translucent powder fixes it, but it's something to keep in mind.

Dry-skinned people? This is your holy grail.

Finding a foundation that doesn't cling to dry patches is like finding a needle in a haystack. This formula is so emollient that it actually feels like it’s helping your skin throughout the day. It’s comfortable. It’s light. You don’t get that desperate urge to wash your face the second you get home.

Breaking down the "Tarte" controversy

Tarte has had some rocky moments with shade ranges in the past (the Shape Tape Foundation launch of 2018 was a disaster, let's be honest). They've clearly tried to learn from that. The Shape Tape Cloud Coverage range is much better, with a decent spread of undertones. They’ve moved away from the "fifty shades of beige" problem, though there is always room for more deep-cool and deep-neutral tones.

When picking your shade, remember that it does oxidize slightly. Not a lot—you won't turn into an Oompa Loompa—but it warms up as it hits the air. If you're between two shades, I usually recommend going for the lighter one.

✨ Don't miss: Cooper City FL Zip Codes: What Moving Here Is Actually Like

Is it worth the price tag?

It's not cheap. You're looking at around $40 for a tube. Compared to drugstore options like the Maybelline Fit Me or L’Oreal True Match, that’s a jump.

However, a little goes a long way. Because the pigment load is higher than a skin tint, you only need about a pea-sized amount for your whole face. If you use it every day, a tube will easily last you three to four months.

Actionable steps for the best results

To get the most out of your Shape Tape Cloud Coverage, skip the complicated 10-step prep.

Start with a clean, well-moisturized face. Let your skincare sink in for at least five minutes—this is the step everyone skips, and it’s why makeup peels. Apply one small dot to your forehead, cheeks, and chin. Blend from the center of your face outward. If you have a blemish that's still peeking through, don't add another layer of foundation. That’s how you get cakey. Instead, take a tiny dab of the original Shape Tape concealer and spot-treat just that area.

Set your T-zone with a very fine powder, but leave your cheekbones bare. This preserves that "cloud" glow where the light naturally hits. If you find the coverage is too much for a casual Sunday, mix it with a drop of your favorite facial oil. It turns into a gorgeous, sheer skin tint instantly.

Ultimately, this product isn't for the person who wants to look like a porcelain doll. It’s for the person who wants to look like they slept 10 hours and drank a gallon of water. It’s a "your skin but better" product that actually delivers on the "better" part.

Check your current moisturizer's ingredient list before buying; if "dimethicone" is the second or third ingredient, you might want to switch to a more water-based prep to ensure the cloud formula doesn't slide. Grab a sample at the store first if you can—swatching on your jawline in natural sunlight is the only way to be 100% sure about the undertone.