You’re standing in line at your favorite local coffee shop, ready to tap that shiny premium rewards card to earn your 3x travel points. But then you see a sign: "We no longer accept Visa Infinite or Mastercard World Elite cards." It sounds like a weird fever dream, right? Honestly, it’s closer to reality than you think.
The visa mastercard interchange settlement news has taken a massive turn in early 2026. After a judge basically nuked a previous $30 billion deal in mid-2024, a new, even bigger amended settlement was proposed in November 2025. This latest version is currently sitting on the desk of U.S. District Judge Brian Cogan in Brooklyn. We're talking about a deal that could save merchants over $200 billion over its lifetime.
But it’s not just about the money. It’s about the rules of the game changing for every single person who carries plastic.
The $200 Billion Question: What’s Actually Happening?
For twenty years, merchants have been screaming about "swipe fees"—the roughly 2% to 4% cut that banks and networks take every time you buy something. It's their second-biggest cost after labor. The networks, Visa and Mastercard, have long enforced something called the "Honor All Cards" rule. Basically, if a shop takes one Visa, they have to take them all—even the super-expensive premium ones that cost the merchant way more in fees.
This new settlement, if it sticks, cracks that rule wide open.
👉 See also: E-commerce Meaning: It Is Way More Than Just Buying Stuff on Amazon
Under the proposed terms, merchants won’t be forced into that all-or-nothing choice anymore. They could choose to accept standard consumer cards but reject the high-cost "Premium" or "Commercial" cards. Imagine a world where your local mom-and-pop shop says "Yes" to a basic Visa but "No" to your high-end rewards card because that specific swipe would eat their entire profit margin on a latte.
The Nitty-Gritty Details
- Rate Caps: Standard consumer credit rates would be capped at 1.25% (125 basis points) for eight years.
- Immediate Reductions: A 10-basis-point (0.10%) reduction in the average effective rate for five years.
- Surcharge Freedom: Merchants could add a surcharge of up to 3% on certain cards without being penalized by the networks.
- Visual IDs: Within 90 days of approval, new cards would have to clearly show if they are "Premium" or "Commercial" so cashiers know what they’re looking at.
Why the First Deal Failed and Why This One Is Different
Remember that $30 billion settlement everyone talked about in early 2024? Judge Margo Brodie threw it out in June of that year. She basically called the relief "paltry." She was worried that large retailers like Walmart and Target were getting a raw deal while being forced to give up their right to sue in the future.
The 2024 deal was criticized for being "window dressing."
This new 2025/2026 version is significantly more aggressive. It moves the needle from a $30 billion impact to an estimated $200 billion in merchant savings. Visa and Mastercard just filed a 47-page rebuttal on January 14, 2026, defending the deal against retailers who still think it doesn't go far enough. The networks are essentially telling the courts: "Look, we’ve given up a ton of ground here. If we go to trial, nobody knows what will happen."
✨ Don't miss: Shangri-La Asia Interim Report 2024 PDF: What Most People Get Wrong
The Political Wildcard: Enter the Credit Card Competition Act
While the lawyers are fighting in New York, Washington is on fire. Just last week, on January 13, 2026, President Trump threw his weight behind the Credit Card Competition Act (CCCA). This bipartisan bill, led by Senators Dick Durbin and Roger Marshall, would require big banks to offer at least two different networks for routing transactions.
The goal? Force Visa and Mastercard to actually compete with other networks like Discover or NYCE.
If the CCCA passes, it would be like a nuclear bomb dropped on the current system. Banks are terrified. They say it will kill rewards programs and weaken fraud protection. Merchants say it's the only way to stop the "swipe fee ripoff." This political pressure is likely why Visa and Mastercard are so eager to get this current settlement approved—they want to settle the legal drama before Congress forces even bigger changes on them.
Will Your Rewards Actually Disappear?
This is the part that keeps cardholders awake at night. Rewards programs—your airline miles, your cash back, your hotel points—are funded by those interchange fees. If the fees drop, the funding for the points dries up.
🔗 Read more: Private Credit News Today: Why the Golden Age is Getting a Reality Check
It’s a balancing act.
Banks might start cutting back on those "too good to be true" sign-up bonuses. We might see higher annual fees to make up for the lost swipe revenue. Or, more likely, we’ll see a "tiered" checkout experience. You might get a 2% discount for using a debit card, pay the sticker price for a standard credit card, and face a 2.5% "premium card fee" if you insist on using your high-end rewards card.
Real Talk for Small Business Owners
If you're running a shop, this settlement (once approved) means you finally get some leverage. You won't be flying blind anymore.
- Check your statements: See which card types are costing you the most.
- Evaluate surcharging: Decide if a 2-3% fee on premium cards is worth the potential customer annoyance.
- Wait for the "Visual ID": Once the settlement is final, cards will have to be marked. This makes it much easier to train your staff on which cards carry higher fees.
What Happens Next?
Don't expect things to change tomorrow morning. The court still needs to grant "preliminary approval," which is expected soon in early 2026. After that, there’s a long period where millions of merchants are notified, and then a "final approval" hearing. Most experts think we won't see the actual changes at the cash register until late 2026 or even 2027.
Walmart is still trying to opt out of the class so they can sue on their own. The Merchant Payments Coalition is still calling the deal "flawed." It’s a mess, frankly. But for the first time in twenty years, the "Honor All Cards" rule is on life support.
Practical Steps to Take Now
- For Merchants: Keep an eye on the official Payment Card Settlement website. If you accepted Visa or Mastercard between 2004 and 2019, the deadline for the separate $5.5 billion monetary settlement was February 2025, but this new settlement is about future rules and doesn't require a claim form yet.
- For Consumers: Start diversifying your wallet. If you only carry one high-end premium card, it might be time to grab a "no-frills" standard card or a debit card just in case your favorite local spot starts getting picky at checkout.
- Watch the CCCA: The progress of the Credit Card Competition Act in the Senate over the next few months will tell us if the 1.25% cap is just the beginning or the final word on fees.