When the bus pulled up to the Prudential Center in Newark this past December, the air felt a little different. It wasn't just the standard humidity of a New Jersey winter. It was the return of Kevin Willard. For twelve years, Willard was the heartbeat of Seton Hall basketball. Now, he's wearing the navy and white of the enemy.
Honestly, the Villanova vs Seton Hall matchup has always been a gritty, floor-burn-heavy affair, but the 2025-2026 season added a layer of soap opera drama we haven't seen in the Big East for a while. If you missed the December 23 clash, you missed a masterclass in "old school" basketball. No 120-point shootouts here. Just two teams beating the living daylights out of each other for 40 minutes.
Villanova walked out with a 64-56 win, but the score tells maybe half the story.
The Willard Factor and the Emotional Homecoming
You've gotta feel for the fans in South Orange. Willard didn't just coach there; he raised his family there. Seeing him on the opposing sideline after his stint at Maryland—and now leading the Wildcats—is a tough pill to swallow. He admitted it was emotional. His kids grew up in those stands.
But once the whistle blew? Sentimentality went out the window.
✨ Don't miss: The Division 2 National Championship Game: How Ferris State Just Redrew the Record Books
Villanova's defense was suffocating. They held the Pirates to a dismal 33.3% from the field. That’s not just "bad shooting"—that’s a defensive scheme designed to make every single dribble feel like a chore. Seton Hall only managed three triples the entire night. In a modern game that usually revolves around the arc, that’s basically playing with one hand tied behind your back.
The New Blood: Acaden Lewis and the Youth Movement
While the coaches were the headline, a freshman stole the show. Acaden Lewis is that guy. He dropped 16 points and looked completely unfazed by the Newark crowd. It’s rare to see a kid step into a hostile Big East environment and demand the ball like that.
- Lewis finished with 16 points, 5 boards, and 3 steals.
- Bryce Lindsay chipped in 15, showing that Nova's backcourt is finally finding its rhythm after the post-Jay Wright transition years.
- Matt Hodge added 12 points, proving the Wildcats have multiple ways to hurt you if you over-commit to the perimeter.
The Pirates, led by Shaheen Holloway, didn't go down without a fight. They're "nasty," as the coaches like to say. Elijah Fisher was a bright spot, putting up 13 points, but they just couldn't find a second consistent option when the Wildcats clamped down on the Merrittmack transfer, Budd Clark. Clark got into early foul trouble—two whistles in the opening minutes—and the Pirates' offensive flow never really recovered.
Why This Rivalry is Different Now
For a few years there, it felt like Villanova was on a different planet than the rest of the Big East. Two national titles will do that. But things have leveled out. The "Kyle Neptune era" had its ups and downs (mostly downs, if we're being blunt), and Seton Hall has clawed its way back into being a "Quad 1" nightmare for anyone who visits "The Rock."
🔗 Read more: Por qué los partidos de Primera B de Chile son más entretenidos que la división de honor
This isn't a rivalry built on hatred, necessarily. It's built on proximity and shared DNA. You have kids from Jersey and Philly who grew up playing against each other in AAU. They know each other's games. They know each other's families.
A Quick Look at the History
If you look at the all-time record, Villanova has a massive lead. We’re talking 88 wins for Nova to 44 for Seton Hall. That’s a 2-to-1 ratio that usually suggests a lopsided affair, but the last decade has been a total coin flip.
In fact, the Pirates have pulled off some of the most gut-wrenching upsets in the Finneran Pavilion's history. Remember the 1-point win on New Year's Day 2025? Or the 2016 Big East Championship where Seton Hall shocked the world? This is a series where the "underdog" tag doesn't mean much once the ball is tipped.
Key Takeaways for the Rest of the 2026 Season
If you're looking at Villanova vs Seton Hall as a barometer for the Big East, here is what the data actually tells us.
💡 You might also like: South Carolina women's basketball schedule: What Most People Get Wrong
- Defense is back. Both teams are currently ranked in the top 40 of KenPom’s defensive efficiency. If you're betting the over on these games, you’re probably losing money.
- Villanova’s Identity Crisis is Over. Under Willard, they’ve returned to that "Blue Blood" mentality of protecting the paint and taking smart shots. They aren't just chucking threes anymore; they're working the shot clock.
- The Pirates are Portal Kings. Holloway has a knack for finding mid-major transfers who play with a massive chip on their shoulder. They might not have the 5-star recruits Nova has, but they will out-rebound you ten times out of ten.
The turnover battle in the December game was wild—Villanova actually turned it over 18 times to Seton Hall's 9. Normally, if you double your opponent's turnovers, you lose. But Nova's shooting (48.9%) was so much more efficient that it didn't matter. That’s a fluke you shouldn't count on happening in the rematch.
What to Watch for in the Rematch
The next time these two meet, expect a much more aggressive Budd Clark. He’s the engine for the Pirates, and he was sidelined by the refs early in the last one. If he stays on the floor, Seton Hall has enough transition speed to give Nova’s bigs like Duke Brennan fits.
Also, keep an eye on the "NET" rankings. Both of these teams are hovering around the bubble for the NCAA Tournament. In the 2026 landscape, a loss to a conference rival isn't just a blow to the ego; it's a potential season-killer.
Actionable Insights for Fans and Bettors
- Watch the Foul Count: Seton Hall relies on aggressive, physical defense. If the refs are calling it tight early, the Pirates' depth gets tested immediately.
- Bet the Under: Until one of these teams proves they can score 80 consistently against a high-level defense, the "Under" remains the safest play in this specific matchup.
- Home Court Advantage is Real: The Prudential Center is a house of horrors for Villanova. Even in their win this year, the crowd was a factor in those 18 turnovers.
The Big East is currently a "one-team league" at the top with UConn, but the battle for second place is wide open. Whether it’s the tactical brilliance of Willard or the "North Jersey grit" of Holloway, this rivalry is the soul of the conference right now.
To stay ahead of the curve, keep a close watch on the injury reports for the Wildcats' backcourt. Their efficiency drops significantly when Lewis isn't the primary ball-handler. On the flip side, if Seton Hall can find a consistent third scoring option to support Fisher and Clark, they are a lock for a deep run in March.
The story of the 2026 Big East will likely be written by how these two teams handle the grind of the February schedule. Don't look at the rankings—look at the box score. The team that wins the "dirty work" stats like offensive rebounds and points in the paint is almost always the one that walks off the floor with the "W" in this series.