If you’ve spent any time lately falling down a rabbit hole of 2000s-style sitcoms or the ever-expanding lore of Five Nights at Freddy’s, you’ve probably hit a wall of confusion regarding one specific name. Vanessa Shelly.
The name itself sounds like a classic TV protagonist. You might be thinking of the cop with the dark past. Or maybe you're mixing her up with the messy cast shakeups on a certain Kevin James sitcom. Honestly, the internet has a weird way of blending these things together. Let’s set the record straight: Elizabeth Lail is the actress who brought Vanessa Shelly to life on the big screen.
Why the Name Vanessa Shelly Rings a Bell
You've probably seen Elizabeth Lail before. She didn't just appear out of thin air for the 2023 Five Nights at Freddy’s movie. Most people actually recognize her as Guinevere Beck from the first season of YOU on Netflix. You know, the one who unfortunately caught the eye of Joe Goldberg.
In the FNAF universe, her character is a local police officer. She’s got this sunny disposition that feels just a little bit "off" from the start. As the movie unfolds, you realize she knows way more about Freddy Fazbear’s Pizza than a random beat cop should. She's the daughter of the big bad, William Afton. It’s a heavy role, and Lail plays it with this sort of repressed, "eternal little girl" energy that makes the third-act twists actually land.
Some fans get confused because the name "Shelly" wasn't always the plan. Early scripts and production leaks had her listed as Vanessa Monroe. They changed it last minute to Shelly, likely to keep the "Afton" reveal a bigger surprise for the casual audience.
📖 Related: Gwendoline Butler Dead in a Row: Why This 1957 Mystery Still Packs a Punch
The Confusion with Vanessa Cellucci
Here is where it gets kinda messy. If you search for "who played Vanessa" in the context of a sitcom, you aren't looking for Elizabeth Lail. You’re looking for Leah Remini.
On the show Kevin Can Wait, Leah Remini played a character named Vanessa Cellucci. It’s an easy mistake to make—Vanessa Shelly, Vanessa Cellucci. Both are tough-talking women associated with law enforcement (Cellucci was Kevin’s former partner on the force).
The drama behind Remini’s Vanessa is actually way more famous than the character itself.
- Season 1 of the show featured Erinn Hayes as Kevin’s wife, Donna.
- The ratings were... okay. But then Leah Remini guest-starred.
- The chemistry between her and Kevin James was so nostalgic for King of Queens fans that the producers did something pretty cutthroat.
- They killed off the wife between seasons. Literally just "Donna died."
- Leah Remini’s Vanessa was promoted to a series regular to take her place.
It was a wild move that sparked a lot of "justice for Erinn Hayes" hashtags back in the day. So, if you're arguing with a friend about a Vanessa who ruined/saved a sitcom, you're talking about Leah Remini. If you're talking about the one fighting animatronics, that’s Elizabeth Lail.
👉 See also: Why ASAP Rocky F kin Problems Still Runs the Club Over a Decade Later
A Look at Elizabeth Lail’s Performance
People had mixed feelings about the movie version of Vanessa Shelly. Some Reddit threads are basically war zones. One camp thinks Lail’s acting was "robotic." The other camp—which seems to be winning the debate—argues that the "robotic" vibe was 100% intentional.
Think about it. Vanessa Shelly grew up under the thumb of a serial killer. She’s traumatized, compartmentalized, and probably terrified 24/7. Lail plays her with a stiff posture and a forced smile that feels like a mask. It’s a psychological choice. She isn't just a plot device; she’s a victim who is finally trying to grow a spine.
Notable Roles by Elizabeth Lail:
- Guinevere Beck in YOU: The breakout role that made her a household name.
- Princess Anna in Once Upon a Time: She did a live-action Frozen arc that was surprisingly spot-on.
- Quinn Harris in Countdown: A horror flick about an app that tells you when you're going to die.
- Mack in Mack & Rita: A quirky comedy where she plays a 30-year-old who transforms into an 70-year-old (Diane Keaton).
What’s Next for the Character?
If you liked what Lail did with Vanessa Shelly, you’re in luck. There’s a sequel in the works. The first movie ended with Vanessa in a coma after being stabbed by her father, William Afton (played by the legendary Matthew Lillard).
The prevailing theory among the hardcore fans? Vanessa is going to wake up and potentially take on a darker persona. In the games, there’s a character named "Vanny" who wears a rabbit mask and carries out Afton’s dirty work. Whether the movie goes that route or keeps her as a hero remains to be seen. But Elizabeth Lail has basically confirmed she’s down for the ride.
✨ Don't miss: Ashley My 600 Pound Life Now: What Really Happened to the Show’s Most Memorable Ashleys
Practical Takeaways for Fans
If you're trying to keep your trivia straight, here’s the "too long; didn't read" version. Vanessa Shelly is the cop from the Five Nights at Freddy's movie. She is played by Elizabeth Lail.
Don't confuse her with:
- Vanessa Cellucci (Leah Remini in Kevin Can Wait)
- Vanessa Marano (Bay Kennish in Switched at Birth)
- Vanessa Williams (The icon from Ugly Betty)
If you want to see more of Lail's range, go back and watch the first season of YOU. The contrast between the bubbly, doomed Beck and the guarded, haunted Officer Shelly is actually pretty impressive. It shows she’s not just a "scream queen"—she’s got some serious dramatic chops.
Keep an eye out for the FNAF 2 casting news. Rumors are flying about new animatronics, but the core human cast, specifically Lail and Josh Hutcherson, are the glue holding that weird, pizza-filled world together.
Next Steps: You should check out Elizabeth Lail's guest appearance in The Blacklist or her starring role in the series Ordinary Joe to see how she handles non-horror roles. If you're more interested in the sitcom side of the "Vanessa" confusion, look up the interviews Erinn Hayes gave after being let go from Kevin Can Wait—it’s a fascinating look at the brutal side of the TV business.