Most people actually think "Valerie" is an Amy Winehouse original. It isn't. Not even close. It was originally a scuzzy, indie-rock tune by a Liverpool band called The Zutons, released just a year before Amy and Mark Ronson turned it into a global soul juggernaut.
Honestly, the valerie amy winehouse songtext feels so personal to her that it’s hard to believe she didn't write it in a smoky North London pub. But the story behind the lyrics is actually about a real person—a celebrity makeup artist in New York named Valerie Star. She was dating the Zutons' frontman, Dave McCabe, and the song was basically a musical postcard. He wrote it in about 20 minutes while sitting in the back of a taxi on the way to his mum’s house.
The Mystery Woman in the Lyrics
Who is Valerie? For years, fans speculated. Was she a metaphor? A long-lost sister? In 2019, Valerie Star herself sat down with VICE to clear things up. She explained that she and Dave McCabe had a "fateful fling" while he was touring. The line about having a "good lawyer"? That wasn't just creative flair. Star was actually facing some serious legal trouble in the States—specifically involving driving offenses—which meant she couldn't fly over to the UK to be with him.
"Why don't you come on over, Valerie?"
💡 You might also like: Ashley My 600 Pound Life Now: What Really Happened to the Show’s Most Memorable Ashleys
It was a literal plea. The ginger hair mentioned in the song? That was hers too. When Amy Winehouse got a hold of the track for Mark Ronson’s Version album, she kept every word. She didn't change the pronouns. She didn't flip the perspective. She just sang it with that heavy, heart-wrenching soul that made you feel like she was the one waiting at the window.
Three Very Different Versions
If you’ve only heard the upbeat, Motown-inspired version that plays at every wedding, you’re missing out. There are actually three distinct ways Amy recorded this.
- The Mark Ronson Version (2007): This is the "big" one. It’s snappy. It’s got those 60s girl-group horns. It hit number 2 on the UK charts and stayed in the Top 20 for 19 weeks.
- The '68 Version: This one is slower, moodier, and feels more like a jazz standard. It appeared on the Lioness: Hidden Treasures compilation after she passed away. Mark Ronson has said this was the version Amy actually liked the most.
- The BBC Live/Acoustic Version: Often found on the Back to Black deluxe edition. It’s stripped back. No bells and whistles. Just her voice and a guitar, proving she didn't need a wall of sound to make the lyrics sting.
What the Songtext Really Means
When you look at the valerie amy winehouse songtext, it’s a song about stagnation and distance. The narrator’s body is "a mess," they’ve "sold the house," and they’re basically just waiting for someone to fix their life.
📖 Related: Album Hopes and Fears: Why We Obsess Over Music That Doesn't Exist Yet
"Well sometimes I go out by myself / And I look across the water"
It’s an image of total isolation. Dave McCabe wrote it about a girl in New York while he was in Liverpool, separated by the Atlantic. Amy, however, brought a different kind of weight to it. By 2007, she was already deep in her own struggles. When she sang about her body being a mess, the public knew she wasn't just kidding around. It turned a quirky indie song into a haunting soul anthem.
Why It Survived the 2000s
Indie covers usually die out after a few years. Not this one. The Zutons have even called Amy's version a "gift from God" because the royalties kept the band financially stable while they were on hiatus. It’s a rare case where the cover completely eclipsed the original without erasing its soul.
👉 See also: The Name of This Band Is Talking Heads: Why This Live Album Still Beats the Studio Records
The song works because it’s simple. It’s a list of questions. Are you okay? Are you still dressing weird? Do you need help? It’s the kind of thing you’d text an ex at 2:00 AM if you still had their number and a few too many drinks in you.
Actionable Next Steps
To truly appreciate the depth of this track beyond the radio edit, you should:
- Listen to The Zutons' original version from their 2006 album Tired of Hanging Around. It’s much more "garage rock" and gives you a sense of where the DNA of the song started.
- Compare the '68 Version to the Ronson Version. You’ll notice how Amy’s phrasing changes when the tempo slows down; she lingers on the word "Valerie" in a way that feels much more desperate.
- Check out the 2011 Glastonbury performance if you can find the footage. It’s widely considered one of the most poignant live captures of her singing the track before her death later that year.