If you’ve been watching the NWSL lately, you know that the gap between the "rebuilding" teams and the "powerhouses" is getting smaller by the minute. Nowhere was that more obvious than the recent tug-of-war between Utah Royals FC vs Orlando Pride. On paper, it looks like a classic mismatch. You’ve got Orlando, the 2024 Shield winners and a team basically built around the terrifying efficiency of Barbra Banda. Then you have Utah, a club still finding its feet after returning to the league, trying to turn flashes of brilliance into consistent results.
Honestly, the most recent 1-1 draw in Orlando back in August 2025 told a much bigger story than the single point each team took home. It wasn’t just a game; it was a statement from Utah that they aren't here to be anyone’s easy three points. And for Orlando? It was a wake-up call that even a lineup stacked with internationals can get bogged down by a disciplined, gritty defense.
The Barbra Banda Factor and How Utah Managed It
You can't talk about Orlando without talking about Barbra Banda. Earlier in the 2025 season, specifically that May 23rd matchup in Sandy, she absolutely dismantled the Royals. She netted the first hat trick in Orlando Pride history—all in the first half. It was surgical. She scored in the 6th, 37th, and 38th minutes. It felt like every time Utah’s backline blinked, the ball was already in the back of the net.
But fast forward to their August meeting at Inter&Co Stadium. Things were different.
Utah’s coach, Jimmy Coenraets, clearly did his homework. The Royals shifted their approach. Instead of letting Banda run into open space, they condensed the middle. Kaleigh Riehl and Kate Del Fava played like their lives depended on it. They weren't just defending; they were physically disrupting the service to Banda. Sure, she still had her chances—she’s too good not to—but the Royals forced her into tight angles and low-percentage shots.
👉 See also: Why the 2025 NFL Draft Class is a Total Headache for Scouts
Key Stats from the Recent 1-1 Draw:
- Possession: Orlando held 55%, Utah had 45%.
- Total Shots: 14 for Orlando, 8 for Utah.
- Shots on Goal: 6 for Orlando, 5 for Utah (Royals were way more efficient).
- Fouls: Utah committed 20 to Orlando's 10. They played heavy and didn't apologize for it.
Mina Tanaka and the Royals' Quick Strike
One thing about this Utah squad? They don't wait around. In that August draw, Mina Tanaka silenced the Orlando crowd just four minutes in. It was a beautiful left-footed strike that caught Anna Moorhouse slightly off her line. Tanaka has been a revelation for the Royals, bringing that veteran international experience (shoutout to Japan's Nadeshiko) that a young team desperately needs.
It’s actually kinda crazy—Utah has scored in the first 15 minutes five times in the 2025 season. They start like they've been shot out of a cannon. The problem has always been holding that lead.
Orlando eventually found their equalizer in the 73rd minute through Prisca Chilufya, but only after some massive subs from Seb Hines. Simone Jackson came on and looked electric, eventually providing the assist. It’s that depth that makes Orlando so hard to beat over 90 minutes. They have starters who can wear you down and subs who can finish you off.
Why This Rivalry is Getting Spicy
There is a weird, burgeoning tension between these two. Maybe it’s the contrast in styles. Orlando plays this expansive, high-octane attacking football. Utah is becoming the league’s "tough out"—a team that will foul you, block your shots (shoutout to Nuria Rábano’s goal-line clearance in May), and wait for that one counter-attack to ruin your night.
✨ Don't miss: Liverpool FC Chelsea FC: Why This Grudge Match Still Hits Different
Also, we have to talk about the goalkeeping. Mandy McGlynn and Mia Justus have both had massive games against the Pride. In the August match, Justus was a wall in stoppage time. She punched out corners and made a fingertip save that kept the draw intact. When your keeper is playing like that, the rest of the team starts to believe they’re invincible.
The Tactical Battle: Seb Hines vs. Jimmy Coenraets
Hines is a "stick to the principles" kind of coach. He wants his team to dominate the ball and create high-quality chances. Coenraets, on the other hand, is a tinkerer. He’s shown he’s willing to change his defensive shape specifically to nullify a single threat like Banda. Watching them move pieces on the board is half the fun.
What's Next for Both Clubs?
As we look toward the 2026 season, the rosters are shifting. Utah has already made some big decisions, keeping 17 players including Tanaka, Mozingo, and the defensive core of Del Fava and Riehl. They are clearly building for stability. They've also been linked to some big free-agent moves to help bolster a midfield that sometimes loses its grip in the second half.
Orlando is in "win now" mode. They've locked down Barbra Banda through 2027, which is a terrifying prospect for the rest of the NWSL. With players like Marta and Emily Sams also under contract for 2026, the Pride aren't going anywhere. They are the benchmark.
🔗 Read more: NFL Football Teams in Order: Why Most Fans Get the Hierarchy Wrong
Actionable Insights for Fans and Analysts:
- Watch the First 15: If you're betting on or just watching Utah, pay attention to the opening whistle. If they don't score early, they struggle to find rhythm later.
- Track the Foul Count: Utah uses "tactical fouls" more than almost anyone else when facing elite strikers. If they get into early yellow card trouble (like Claudia Zornoza often does), their defense collapses.
- Depth is the Decider: In their last three meetings, the team with the more impactful bench (usually Orlando) has dominated the final 20 minutes. Keep an eye on Simone Jackson; she’s becoming a "super-sub" nightmare.
The Utah Royals FC vs Orlando Pride matchup isn't just another game on the calendar anymore. It's a clash of identities. One team is trying to maintain its throne at the top of the NWSL, and the other is a hungry, scrappy newcomer that has finally figured out how to make the giants bleed.
If you want to stay ahead of the curve, keep an eye on the official NWSL standings and the NWSL+ app for full match replays. These tactical shifts happen fast, and by the next time these two meet, the "Royalty" might just be ready to take the crown for real.
To get the most out of the next match, focus on the individual battle between Barbra Banda and Kate Del Fava. That 1v1 matchup usually dictates the entire flow of the game. If Del Fava can keep Banda facing her own goal, Utah has a genuine chance at an upset. If Banda turns and faces the net? It's usually game over.