Planning a trip to San José or the Osa Peninsula usually starts with a flurry of excitement about sloths and surfing, but then you hit the official government sites and things get heavy. Honestly, reading the U.S. State Dept Costa Rica advisories can feel like a splash of cold water. One minute you're looking at boutique eco-lodges, and the next you're reading about "Exercise Increased Caution." It sounds ominous. But here’s the thing: you have to know how to translate "government-speak" into actual reality on the ground.
The State Department isn't your travel agent. Their job is to be the cautious parent of the world.
Currently, Costa Rica often sits at a Level 2 travel advisory. For context, that puts it in the same category as many popular European destinations. It’s not a "do not travel" warning, but it’s definitely not a "ignore everything and leave your brain at the airport" situation either. Most people see the words "crime" and "kidnapping" in these bulletins and panic, but the nuance is where the real story lives.
Deciphering the Level 2 Status
What does "Exercise Increased Caution" really mean when we talk about the U.S. State Dept Costa Rica guidance? Basically, it means the baseline risk of petty theft is high enough that the government wants you to stop being a "distracted tourist."
Crime happens. It's a reality.
The State Department specifically highlights "petty crime" as a major concern. This isn't usually about violent confrontations, though those exist in specific pockets. It’s more about the "smash and grab." You leave your backpack in the rental car to take a quick photo of a Macaw? Gone. You set your phone on the table at a beach bar in Puerto Viejo while you go to the bathroom? Also likely gone.
The U.S. Embassy in San José handles a staggering number of lost passport cases every year. That’s not a coincidence. It's a direct result of travelers underestimating how quickly a professional thief can move.
The Geography of Risk
Costa Rica isn't a monolith. The safety profile of the Four Seasons in Papagayo is lightyears away from certain neighborhoods in south San José or the port city of Limón. The U.S. State Dept Costa Rica notes often mention specific areas where extra vigilance is required.
Limón is a frequent flyer on these warning lists. While the Caribbean coast is culturally rich and stunning, the city of Limón itself struggles with higher rates of narcotics-related violence. Does that mean you can't go to Cahuita or Puerto Viejo? No. But it means you probably shouldn't be wandering around the Limón docks at 11:00 PM looking for a craft cocktail bar. They don't really have those there, anyway.
📖 Related: Food in Kerala India: What Most People Get Wrong About God's Own Kitchen
Nature is More Dangerous Than People
Something the State Department mentions—but travelers often gloss over—is the environmental risk. In Costa Rica, the "green" is beautiful but occasionally deadly.
Rip currents are a huge deal.
Most beaches in Costa Rica do not have lifeguards. You’re often on your own. The State Department warns about this because drowning is a leading cause of accidental death for U.S. citizens abroad. You see a beautiful, empty beach and think it’s paradise; the ocean sees a way to pull you 200 yards out into the Pacific before you can yell for help.
Then there are the volcanoes. Costa Rica is literally built on them. Poás and Turrialba aren't just scenery; they are active geological features. When the State Department issues a notice about volcanic activity, they aren't being dramatic. Eruptions can lead to sudden park closures and respiratory issues from ash. If the "U.S. State Dept Costa Rica" feed says a park is restricted, believe them. Don't try to find a "secret" trail around the barricades.
The Reality of Healthcare and Logistics
If you get into trouble, the State Department's role is limited. They can help you find a doctor or contact your family, but they aren't paying your bills.
Costa Rica has a dual healthcare system: the Caja (public) and private clinics.
Private hospitals like CIMA or Clínica Bíblica in San José are world-class. They look like luxury hotels and have the tech to match. But they want payment upfront. Or at least a very solid insurance guarantee. This is why the State Department screams about travel insurance. If you have a heart attack in La Fortuna, getting you to a specialist in San José via private ambulance or medevac can cost upwards of $20,000.
Driving is a Sport (And Not a Safe One)
The State Department warns about road conditions for a reason.
👉 See also: Taking the Ferry to Williamsburg Brooklyn: What Most People Get Wrong
Costa Rican roads are a chaotic mix of brand-new highways and "oh my god is that a crater?" backroads. Landslides are common during the rainy season (May to November). If you’re driving a rental car, you’re a target. Not necessarily for carjacking, but for the "flat tire" scam. Someone pokes a hole in your tire at a gas station, follows you until you pull over, and then "helps" you change it while their buddy swipes your luggage from the front seat.
It sounds like a movie plot. It’s actually a Tuesday in Alajuela.
What Most People Get Wrong About the Alerts
People tend to think a State Department alert means a country is "falling apart." That’s not it.
The U.S. State Dept Costa Rica updates are often reactionary. If there’s a spike in break-ins in a specific beach town, they update the site. If the local government changes their entry requirements—like the recent-ish back-and-forth on COVID-19 insurance or digital nomad visas—the State Department logs it.
It’s a data aggregate.
You should also look at the "Safety and Security" section regarding demonstrations. Costa Rica is one of the most stable democracies in Latin America. They don't even have a standing army. But they do love a good protest. Striking workers or students will often block major arteries like Route 27 or the Inter-American Highway. These aren't usually violent, but they will make you miss your flight. The State Department tracks these "bloqueos" (roadblocks) because they are a logistical nightmare for tourists.
Smart Moves for the Modern Traveler
So, how do you actually use this information without letting it ruin your vibe?
First, sign up for the Smart Traveler Enrollment Program (STEP). It’s free. It’s basically just telling the Embassy, "Hey, I’m in the country." If a hurricane hits or a volcano decides to wake up, they can send you targeted SMS alerts. It’s much better than trying to refresh Twitter with 1-bar of signal in the jungle.
✨ Don't miss: Lava Beds National Monument: What Most People Get Wrong About California's Volcanic Underworld
Second, ditch the "obvious tourist" look.
If you’re walking around San José with a $2,000 Leica around your neck and a massive physical map, you’re asking for trouble. Costa Ricans (Ticos) are generally incredibly friendly and helpful, but poverty exists. Don't flaunt wealth in areas where people are struggling.
The Emergency Number is 911
This is a rare case where it's the same as the U.S. and Canada. If you are in immediate danger, call 911. However, don't expect the operator to speak perfect English if you are in a remote area. Learning a few phrases like "Necesito ayuda" (I need help) or "Me robaron" (I was robbed) goes a long way.
The U.S. Embassy is located in the Pavas neighborhood of San José. It's a fortress. If you lose your passport, you’re going there. You’ll need a police report (from the OIJ, the local investigative police) and a hefty fee for the emergency passport.
Actionable Safety Steps Based on Official Guidance
Instead of just worrying about the warnings, turn them into a checklist. This is how seasoned travelers handle the U.S. State Dept Costa Rica advice:
- Audit Your Tech: Use an eSIM so you always have data. Offline Google Maps are a lifesaver when the Waze signal drops in the mountains.
- The "Two-Wallet" Strategy: Keep one wallet with a bit of cash and an expired ID to hand over if you’re ever confronted. Keep your real cards and bulk cash in a hidden spot or a hotel safe.
- The Rental Car Rule: Nothing—literally nothing—stays in the car. Not even a bag of groceries. If a thief sees a bag, they assume there’s a laptop in it.
- Nighttime Navigation: Use official "Red Taxis" or Uber. Uber is technically in a legal gray area in Costa Rica, but it’s widely used and generally considered safer for tracking purposes than hailing a random car off the street.
- Check the Tide Charts: If you’re hitting the Pacific or Caribbean, download a tide app. Knowing when the tide is turning can literally save your life if you're prone to swimming in unmonitored areas.
Costa Rica is a spectacular place. There’s a reason it’s the "Pura Vida" capital of the world. The State Department warnings aren't there to stop you from going; they’re there to make sure you actually make it back home to tell the story. Take the "Exercise Increased Caution" label as a reminder to be present. Don't walk into the jungle without a guide, don't leave your drink unattended, and don't treat the country like a theme park. It's a real place with real risks, but the rewards—the cloud forests, the coffee, the people—are worth the extra bit of vigilance.
Your Next Steps:
- Check your health insurance policy to see if "international medical evacuation" is covered; if not, buy a standalone travel policy.
- Photocopy your passport bio page and your entry stamp (once you arrive) and keep those copies in a separate bag from your physical passport.
- Download the "Waze" app, as it is significantly more accurate for Costa Rican traffic and road closures than any other navigation tool.