You’re standing in the middle of a crowded Nordstrom Rack, staring at a pair of New Balance 9060s. They’re a Men’s 9. You usually wear a 9. You slide them on, and suddenly, your toes are screaming. Why? Because the us shoes size chart is, quite frankly, a bit of a lie. It’s not a fixed law of physics like gravity; it’s more of a loose suggestion that varies wildly depending on whether you’re looking at Nike, Allen Edmonds, or a pair of cheap flip-flops from a gas station.
Fit matters.
If you’ve ever wondered why your European size 42 feels like a boat but your US 9 feels like a vice grip, you aren't crazy. The American sizing system is actually based on an old English measurement called a "barleycorn." Yes, really. One barleycorn is exactly 1/3 of an inch. While the rest of the world moved toward the metric system or the Mondopoint system, the US stuck with a method developed before the lightbulb was invented.
The Math Behind the US Shoes Size Chart
Standard US sizing starts at a baseline. For men, a size 1 is roughly 7.75 inches long. Every full size you go up adds one barleycorn (1/3 inch). A half size? That’s 1/6 of an inch. It sounds precise until you realize that every manufacturer uses a different "last"—the wooden or plastic foot mold used to shape the shoe.
Brannock is the name you need to know. Charles Brannock invented that silver sliding metal contraption you see at the shoe store back in 1925. It is the gold standard. If you haven't had your foot measured on a real Brannock device in the last five years, you’re probably buying the wrong size. Your feet flatten and lengthen as you age. Gravity is a beast.
Men’s vs. Women’s Sizing Discrepancies
Here is where it gets annoying. There is exactly a 1.5-size difference between the men’s and women’s us shoes size chart. If a woman wears a size 8.5, she is a size 7 in men’s. But wait—width is the silent killer here. A standard "medium" width for women is a "B" grade. For men, a "medium" is a "D." So, if a guy tries to buy a women’s shoe in his "equivalent" size, it’s almost certainly going to be too narrow across the ball of the foot.
Why Brands Ignore the Chart
Nike runs small. Adidas runs "true to size" but has a wider midfoot. Vans feel like flat boards. Converse Chuck Taylors? You basically have to size down a full step or you’ll look like you’re wearing clown shoes.
Why do they do this? International manufacturing. Most shoes are made in factories across Vietnam, China, and Indonesia. When they convert the Mondopoint or European sizing to the US system, things get lost in translation. A European 44 is often marketed as a US 10.5, but mathematically, it’s closer to a 10.7. Brands just round up or down based on how they want the "vibe" of the fit to feel.
How to Actually Measure Your Foot at Home
Forget the printable PDF rulers you find online. They almost never scale correctly when you hit "print," and you'll end up ordering a size 12 when you're an 8. Do this instead:
Find a piece of paper, a pen, and a wall. Tape the paper to the floor, flush against the baseboard. Stand on the paper with your heel firmly against the wall. Have a friend—or struggle yourself—to mark the very tip of your longest toe. Don't assume it's your big toe; for many, it’s the second toe (Morton's Toe). Measure that distance in inches.
Once you have that number, use this rough guide:
- 9.25 inches: Women's 6 / Men's 4.5
- 9.625 inches: Women's 7.5 / Men's 6
- 10.25 inches: Women's 9.5 / Men's 8
- 10.5 inches: Women's 10.5 / Men's 9
- 11 inches: Women's 12 / Men's 10.5
Remember to measure your feet at the end of the day. Your feet swell after you’ve been walking around. If you measure at 8:00 AM, those shoes will feel like torture devices by 4:00 PM.
The Width Factor: D, E, and EE
Most people ignore the letters. If you see a "D" next to a size, that’s standard for men. "B" is standard for women. But if you have a wide forefoot, you need an E or a 2E. If you have "duck feet" (narrow heel, wide front), the standard us shoes size chart won't help you much. You’ll need to look for brands like Altra or Topo Athletic that feature a "foot-shaped" toe box.
High arches also change how you interact with the chart. A high arch pulls the toes back, making the foot measure shorter on a flat scale than it actually behaves inside a shoe. If you have flat feet, your foot will "splay" or elongate under pressure, meaning you might need to size up just to accommodate the spread.
👉 See also: Borders for flower beds ideas: What most gardeners get wrong about their edges
International Conversions: A Necessary Evil
If you’re buying luxury Italian loafers or German hiking boots, the US chart is a secondary thought for those designers.
- UK sizing is usually one full size down from US men's. A UK 9 is a US 10.
- EU sizing is the most consistent but uses smaller increments.
- CM (Centimeters) or JPN sizing is actually the most honest. It literally just measures the length of the foot.
If a shoe tongue has the CM measurement, trust that over the US number every single time. It doesn't lie.
Common Myths About Shoe Sizing
"They’ll stretch out."
Maybe. If it’s high-quality unlined leather, sure, it’ll give a little. But if it's a synthetic running shoe or a patent leather heel? No chance. If it doesn't fit in the store, it won't fit in the street.
Another one? "I'm always a size 10."
You aren't. You might be a 10 in a dress shoe but an 11 in a running shoe because you need "thumb's width" of space at the front to prevent your toenails from turning black during a 5k.
Actionable Steps for a Perfect Fit
Stop guessing.
First, go to a running specialty store and get a 3D foot scan. Most of them do it for free now. They’ll tell you your exact length, width, and arch height in millimeters. Keep that data on your phone.
Second, check the "Heel-to-Toe" drop. This doesn't affect the size, but it affects how the size feels. A high drop pushes your foot forward into the toe box, making the shoe feel smaller than it is.
Third, always check the return policy. If a brand doesn't offer free exchanges, they don't trust their own sizing chart.
Finally, look at the material. Mesh stretches; GORE-TEX does not. If you’re buying waterproof boots, go up a half size to accommodate thicker socks and the lack of flexibility in the fabric.
Proper fit isn't just about comfort; it's about biomechanics. Wearing the wrong size from the us shoes size chart can lead to bunions, plantar fasciitis, and even lower back pain. Take the extra ten minutes to measure correctly. Your knees will thank you in ten years.