You probably learned in middle school that a president can only serve two terms. It’s one of those "gold standard" rules of American politics, right up there with the three branches of government and the Bill of Rights. But if you look at a list of commanders-in-chief, there’s this one guy—Franklin Delano Roosevelt—who stayed in the White House for over twelve years. He was elected to four terms. Honestly, it's kinda wild to think about now.
Imagine a president today trying to stay for a third term, let alone a fourth. The internet would literally explode. Back in the 1940s, it wasn't exactly a quiet affair either, but the world was basically on fire. Between the Great Depression and World War II, a lot of people felt like switching "horses in midstream" (as the saying went) was a recipe for disaster.
But FDR’s marathon presidency changed everything. It led directly to a major update to the Constitution, ensuring that no one could ever pull a four-peat again.
The Unwritten Rule That Lasted 150 Years
Before the US president 4 terms anomaly, there was no law saying you couldn't run forever. The Constitution originally left it open. However, George Washington—who was basically the ultimate influencer of the 1700s—decided two terms was enough. He was tired, sure, but he also didn't want the presidency to turn into a "light" version of a monarchy.
After Washington stepped down, it became a gentleman’s agreement. Thomas Jefferson followed it. James Madison followed it. For about 150 years, everyone just sort of agreed that two terms was the limit for the sake of democracy.
Then came 1940.
💡 You might also like: Robert Hanssen: What Most People Get Wrong About the FBI's Most Damaging Spy
Why FDR Broke the Tradition
By 1940, Roosevelt had already served two full terms. Usually, this is where a president starts looking at beachfront property and planning their library. But FDR was staring at a world where Nazi Germany was swallowing Europe. At home, the US was still shaking off the dust of the Great Depression.
He didn't exactly "campaign" for a third term in the traditional sense at first. He played it cool, basically waiting for his party to "draft" him. And they did. The 1940 election against Wendell Willkie was a huge deal because it shattered the Washington precedent.
- The 1932 Election: FDR wins his first term during the height of the Great Depression.
- The 1936 Election: He wins in a landslide, carrying every state except Maine and Vermont.
- The 1940 Election: He breaks tradition, arguing that a change in leadership would be dangerous during a global crisis.
- The 1944 Election: Even with his health failing, he wins a fourth term to see the end of World War II.
When he won that fourth election in 1944, his opponent, Thomas Dewey, was pretty vocal about the risks. He called the idea of four terms a "threat to our freedom." Honestly, he had a point that resonated with a lot of people, even those who liked FDR.
The Physical Toll of Four Terms
People didn't see what was happening behind the scenes. In 1944, FDR was actually quite ill. He had congestive heart failure and high blood pressure, but the public didn't really know the extent of it. He looked thinner, sure, but he was still the guy on the radio—the "Fireside Chat" voice that Americans trusted.
He died in April 1945, just 11 weeks into his fourth term. He never got to see the end of the war he helped manage.
📖 Related: Why the Recent Snowfall Western New York State Emergency Was Different
The Backlash and the 22nd Amendment
After FDR passed away, Congress didn't waste much time. There was a lingering "never again" vibe in Washington. Both Republicans and many Democrats felt that while FDR might have been the right guy for that specific crisis, leaving the door open for a "President for Life" was a terrible idea for a republic.
In 1947, Congress passed the 22nd Amendment. It was ratified in 1951.
Basically, the law now says:
- No person can be elected president more than twice.
- If you take over for someone else and serve more than two years of their term, you can only be elected once on your own.
This means the absolute max anyone can serve is technically ten years (two years of someone else's term + two of your own elected terms).
Could It Ever Happen Again?
Short answer: No. Not without another Constitutional Amendment, which is incredibly hard to pass. You’d need two-thirds of both the House and Senate, plus three-quarters of the states to agree. In our current political climate, getting three-quarters of the states to agree on a lunch order is basically impossible.
👉 See also: Nate Silver Trump Approval Rating: Why the 2026 Numbers Look So Different
Some people argue that term limits are actually bad because they kick out experienced leaders when people might still want them. They say it's undemocratic to tell voters they can't vote for someone. On the flip side, most historians agree that term limits are a vital "break" on executive power. It prevents the government from becoming too centered around one personality.
What You Should Know About Presidential Limits
If you're following the news or studying history, it's worth noting that the US president 4 terms situation was a "black swan" event. It took a global economic collapse AND a world war to make it happen.
- Precedent vs. Law: Tradition held for 150 years; law has held for about 75.
- The Vice President Factor: Because of the 22nd Amendment, who a president picks as a VP is arguably more important now than it was in the 1800s.
- The Global Context: Many countries without term limits have seen their leaders slowly turn into autocrats. The 22nd Amendment is a specific "guardrail" to prevent that here.
Actionable Insights for History Buffs
If you're interested in how this actually played out on the ground, here is what you can do to dig deeper:
- Listen to the "Fireside Chats": You can find the audio online. Listen to the 1940 and 1944 speeches. You'll hear how he framed his decision to stay in power as a duty rather than an ambition.
- Read the 1944 Campaign Coverage: Look at how the media handled his health. It's a fascinating look at how "gatekeeping" worked before the era of 24/7 social media.
- Study the 22nd Amendment Debates: Check out the Congressional Record from 1947. The arguments about "monarchy" vs. "stability" are surprisingly similar to the political debates we have today.
Understanding why we only had one US president 4 terms helps explain why our government is structured the way it is now. It wasn't just about one man; it was about the country deciding where the line between "leader" and "ruler" should be drawn.