The U.S. Open is basically a torture test disguised as a sporting event. People talk about the Masters and the green jacket, sure, but if you ask any pro about the tournament that actually keeps them up at night, it's this one. It's the rough. It's the greens that feel like putting on a marble countertop. Most of all, it's the mental toll of knowing that one bad swing doesn't just cost you a stroke—it can ruin your entire week.
Winning here isn't just about being good at golf. You've got to be comfortable being miserable.
The Brutal Reality of Being One of the U.S. Open Winners Golf Fans Remember
Look at the history of U.S. Open winners golf enthusiasts hold in high regard, and you'll notice a pattern. They aren't always the "hottest" players on tour at that moment. Instead, they’re the guys who can scramble for par like their lives depend on it. Take Bryson DeChambeau’s win at Pinehurst No. 2 in 2024. That wasn’t a clinic in perfection; it was a masterclass in grit. That bunker shot on the 72nd hole? Pure nerve. He joined an elite list of people who didn't let the USGA's sadistic course setup break them.
Historically, the USGA (United States Golf Association) has a reputation for pushing courses right to the edge of "fair." Sometimes they fall off the cliff. Remember Shinnecock Hills in 2004 or 2018? The greens died. They literally stopped holding water and became impossible to play. In those years, the winner wasn't necessarily the best ball-striker; they were the last person standing. Retief Goosen’s 2004 performance, where he out-putted Phil Mickelson on greens that looked like burnt toast, remains one of the most underrated displays of mental fortitude in the history of the sport.
It's weird, honestly. We watch sports to see greatness, but we watch the U.S. Open to see struggle.
The Names That Define the Era
Jack Nicklaus and Tiger Woods. Obviously. They both have four and three titles respectively (Jack is tied with Willie Anderson, Bobby Jones, and Ben Hogan for the record of four). But think about Ben Hogan for a second. His 1950 win at Merion is legendary because he did it just 16 months after a car accident that nearly killed him. He was literally wrapping his legs in bandages just to be able to walk the course. That is the "U.S. Open identity." It's pain.
Then you have the heartbreak stories.
Phil Mickelson has six—six!—runner-up finishes. He is the greatest player to never win this specific trophy. It’s the only leg of the Career Grand Slam he’s missing, and at this point, it feels like a cruel joke from the golf gods. Every time he got close, something went sideways. Winged Foot in 2006 is the one that still haunts people. A driver on the 18th hole when he just needed a par? It was chaotic. But that’s what this tournament does; it makes even the smartest players make questionable decisions under pressure.
Why Course Setup Dictates the Leaderboard
Every year, the conversation starts with the grass. How high is the rough? How fast are the greens?
In 2023 at LACC (Los Angeles Country Club), Wyndham Clark shocked everyone by holding off Rory McIlroy. People thought the course was too easy because Rickie Fowler and Xander Schauffele shot 62s in the opening round. But by Sunday? It was a grind. Clark's ability to hit "heavy" shots out of that nasty Bermuda rough was what separated him.
The USGA shifted their philosophy a bit recently. They used to want the winning score to be Even Par. If it went to -10, they felt like they failed. Now, they seem more interested in "variety." They want players to use every club in the bag. At Oakmont, that means dodging church pew bunkers. At Pebble Beach, it means hitting tiny greens while the wind tries to knock you into the Pacific Ocean.
Recent Champions and the Power Shift
- 2024: Bryson DeChambeau (-6) - Pinehurst No. 2. A win for the "new" school of power and physics.
- 2023: Wyndham Clark (-10) - LACC. The underdog story that actually stuck.
- 2022: Matt Fitzpatrick (-6) - The Country Club. A lesson in precision and course management.
- 2021: Jon Rahm (-6) - Torrey Pines. The breakthrough for a generational talent.
It's interesting to see how the winners are trending. For a while, it was all about "bomb and gouge"—hit it as far as possible, find it in the rough, and wedge it onto the green. But courses like Brookline and Pinehurst have started to penalize that. You can't just muscle your way through a U.S. Open anymore. You need a short game that can survive a 40-foot putt with six feet of break.
The Mental Tax of the Open
You've probably heard players say it's the "longest week in golf." They aren't exaggerating.
Most tournaments allow for a "gettable" birdie here and there to fix a mistake. At the U.S. Open, birdies are rare birds indeed. You spend four days playing defensive golf. Imagine being at your job and knowing that one tiny typo could get you fired. That's what every swing feels like on a Sunday at this tournament.
Brooks Koepka back-to-back wins (2017, 2018) proved that a specific type of personality thrives here. He’s stoic. He doesn't get rattled. When he won at Erin Hills, people said the course was too wide open. So he went to Shinnecock—a brutal, traditional test—and won there too. He showed that the secret to being one of the elite U.S. Open winners golf historians study is basically just having a short memory. You bogeyed? Whatever. Move on.
The Amateur Dream
We can't talk about winners without mentioning Francis Ouimet. 1913. Brookline.
A 20-year-old amateur beat the two best players in the world (Harry Vardon and Ted Ray) in a playoff. It changed American golf forever. Before Ouimet, golf was seen as a British pastime for the wealthy. After he won, it became a sport for the masses. It's the ultimate "it could be you" story, even though modern equipment and professionalization make it nearly impossible for an amateur to win today. The last amateur to really give it a run was Nick Dunlap in other events, but the U.S. Open remains the final mountain for the non-pros.
🔗 Read more: Jon Jones Oblique Kick Explained: Why It Is the Most Hated Move in MMA
How to Watch (and Learn from) the Winners
If you're looking to improve your own game by watching these guys, don't look at their drives. Don't look at the 350-yard carries.
Watch how they play when they miss the green.
The winners are the ones who can chip to five feet from a downhill lie in thick grass. They are the ones who don't "chase" pins. Most amateur golfers get in trouble because they try to hit the hero shot. A U.S. Open winner knows that sometimes, a 30-foot putt for par is a great result. They play to the middle of the green. They accept bogey when double-bogey is staring them in the face.
Honestly, the most important lesson from the U.S. Open is ego management.
What to Look for in Future Tournaments
As we look toward the next few years—Oakmont in 2025, Shinnecock in 2026—the venues are getting tougher again. The USGA is moving back toward traditional, punishing layouts.
- Look for ball-strikers: Guys like Scottie Scheffler or Viktor Hovland who hit a high percentage of greens in regulation.
- Check the weather: If the wind kicks up at a coastal course like Pebble or Shinnecock, the leaderboard will blow up.
- Watch the "grinders": Players who might not have the prettiest swings but never seem to give up on a round.
Winning a U.S. Open changes a career trajectory instantly. It’s a ten-year exemption into the tournament and a five-year exemption into the other three majors. It’s a lifetime of being introduced as a "U.S. Open Champion," which carries a different weight than winning a regular Tour event. It means you survived the toughest test the game has to offer.
Actionable Insights for Golf Fans
If you're following the quest for the next trophy, keep these specific metrics in mind rather than just the world rankings:
- Strokes Gained: Around the Green: This is the most underrated stat at the U.S. Open. When the greens get firm and fast, everyone misses them. The winner is whoever saves par the most.
- Bogey Avoidance: You don't need 20 birdies to win. You need to avoid the "others" (double bogeys or worse).
- Driving Accuracy vs. Distance: On courses with "graduated rough," accuracy matters more than raw power. If the first cut is manageable but the second cut is a pitch-out, look for the guys who hit fairways.
- Mental Reset: Watch the players after a bad hole. If they're slamming clubs or looking at their caddie for someone to blame, they’re probably not going to be holding the trophy on Sunday.
The U.S. Open is a grind, plain and simple. It's not always pretty, but it's the most honest reflection of a golfer's skill and spirit. Whether it's a veteran finally getting his due or a young star proving they have the stones, the list of winners remains the most prestigious "tough guy" club in all of sports.
To truly understand the game, you have to study the players who didn't just play the course, but survived it. Study the bunker saves of 2024 or the putting clinics of years past. The data shows that while technology changes, the requirement for a U.S. Open win remains the same: total control over your ball and your mind. Keep an eye on the "Strokes Gained: Tee to Green" stats leading up to the next championship to identify who has the consistency to handle the pressure.