Oakmont Country Club doesn't care about your feelings. It doesn't care about your "brand" or how far you carry your driver on a launch monitor. If you walk onto those grounds in Western Pennsylvania expecting a fair fight, you've already lost. History shows that U.S. Open scores at Oakmont are less about golf and more about survival.
The 2025 U.S. Open just wrapped up there, and honestly, it was another reminder that this place is a beast. J.J. Spaun took the trophy with a 279, finishing at just 1-under par. Think about that. In an era where guys are routinely shooting 20-under on the PGA Tour, the best players in the world struggled to keep it under par for four days.
People always talk about the "Church Pews" bunkers or the fact that there are basically no trees. But the real story is in the numbers. They tell a tale of carnage.
Why 2007 Was a Total Bloodbath
If you want to see what Oakmont looks like when it's truly angry, look at the 2007 U.S. Open. Angel Cabrera won that year. His score? A 285. That is 5-over par.
✨ Don't miss: Cruz Azul juego de hoy: Por qué La Máquina se juega más que tres puntos
It’s almost unheard of in the modern game for a winner to be over par, but Oakmont is built different. That week, the course was so firm and the greens were so fast that over sixty rounds were recorded in the 80s. The cut line was a staggering 11-over par. Imagine being a professional golfer, shooting 10-over for two days, and still making the weekend.
Cabrera didn't win because he was flashy. He won because he was gritty. He carded a 76 on Saturday and most people thought he was done. Then he came out on Sunday and fired a 69. It was one of only two rounds under par that entire day. Tiger Woods and Jim Furyk both had chances to catch him, but they couldn't buy a birdie on the 72nd hole.
The Scoring Reality at Oakmont
Looking back through the decades, you see a pattern. The winning scores fluctuate wildly based on how much rain the area gets.
- 1927: Tommy Armour won with a 301 (+13).
- 1935: Sam Parks Jr. finished at 299 (+11).
- 1953: Ben Hogan mastered it at 283 (-5).
- 1962: Jack Nicklaus won his first major here at 283 (-1).
- 1973: Johnny Miller's miracle 279 (-5).
- 1983: Larry Nelson at 280 (-4).
- 1994: Ernie Els at 279 (-5) after a playoff.
- 2016: Dustin Johnson at 276 (-4).
- 2025: J.J. Spaun at 279 (-1).
Basically, if you can get to 4 or 5-under par, you're usually holding the trophy. But getting there is a nightmare.
That 63: The Round Nobody Will Shut Up About
We have to talk about Johnny Miller in 1973. It is arguably the greatest round of golf ever played. Miller started the final round six strokes back. He was tied for 13th. Nobody was looking at him.
Then he went out and hit all 18 greens in regulation. Every single one. On Oakmont's greens, that’s like trying to land a marble on a moving car roof. He birdied the first four holes. Even with a bogey on the 8th, he didn't blink. He finished with a 63.
The "Miller 63" stood as the major championship record for 44 years. It wasn't just the score; it was the way he did it. The course was slightly softer that day due to rain, which is the only reason the U.S. Open scores at Oakmont that year weren't much higher. Even then, only three other players broke 70 that Sunday.
The Dustin Johnson Era and "The Ruling"
Fast forward to 2016. Dustin Johnson finally broke his major slump, but it wasn't without drama. His winning score was a 4-under 276, which actually tied the lowest 72-hole total at Oakmont for a U.S. Open.
But do you remember the penalty? On the 5th green during the final round, his ball moved slightly as he was preparing to putt. He didn't think he caused it. The official on the hole didn't think he caused it. But then, on the 12th tee, the USGA told him they might penalize him after the round.
He had to play the last seven holes not knowing what his actual score was.
He ended up finishing with a 68 on the course, but the USGA tacked on a one-stroke penalty afterward, making his official final-round score a 69. He still won by three. It showed a level of mental toughness people didn't think DJ had back then. Most guys would have crumbled under that kind of bureaucratic nonsense.
Why 2025 Felt Different
The 2025 tournament was a bit of a throwback. The USGA set the course up to be long—measuring 7,372 yards—and the par-3 8th hole was stretched out to over 300 yards at one point.
J.J. Spaun’s 1-under par victory was a masterclass in lag putting. The greens were rolling at a 15 on the Stimpmeter. If you missed on the wrong side of the hole, you weren't just looking at a three-putt; you were looking at the ball rolling off the green entirely.
The scoring average for the week was over 73. When you look at the U.S. Open scores at Oakmont from 2025, you see a lot of big names missing the cut. Bryson DeChambeau, the defending champ, tried to "bomb and gouge" it but found out quickly that the 5-to-6-inch rough doesn't allow for that. You can't muscle a ball out of Oakmont's rough and expect it to stop on those greens.
Actionable Insights for Golf Fans
If you're tracking these scores or planning to bet on the next major at a venue like this, keep these things in mind:
👉 See also: Deion Sanders Graphic Tee: Why the Prime Effect is Taking Over Your Closet
- Look for Total Driving: It's not just distance. You have to hit the fairway. At Oakmont, missing the short grass by a yard is the same as missing it by thirty.
- Value the "Grinders": Players who are comfortable making pars and don't chase birdies tend to survive.
- Watch the Weather: If the forecast is dry, expect the winning score to be over par. If it rains, the "Johnny Miller effect" comes into play and someone might actually go low.
- Lag Putting is King: Stats like "3-putt avoidance" are way more important than "strokes gained putting" from short range.
Oakmont remains the ultimate test because it doesn't allow for luck. The scores reflect the difficulty of a course that was designed to be the meanest in the world. Whether it's 1927 or 2025, the recipe is the same: stay out of the bunkers, hit the middle of the greens, and hope your nerves don't fry before the 18th hole.
To really understand the difficulty, go back and watch the highlights of the 2007 final round. Seeing Tiger Woods struggle to hold a green with a wedge tells you everything you need to know about why a 5-over par score can be world-class.