You’ve probably seen the headlines. Some news station flashes a scary map, points to a city like Chicago or Philadelphia, and calls it a "war zone." It makes for great TV. But if you actually look at the data—the real, cold numbers—you realize that most people are looking at the wrong thing.
If you want to know how dangerous a place actually is, you don’t look at the total number of bodies. You look at the rate.
Basically, comparing the total murders in a massive city like New York to a mid-sized city like St. Louis is like comparing a shark attack in the ocean to a shark attack in a swimming pool. The ocean has more sharks, sure, but you're a lot more likely to get bitten in that pool. That is the essence of us cities per capita murders. It’s the "per 100,000 people" metric that levels the playing field and reveals where the real trouble spots are.
What the 2024 and 2025 Data Actually Says
Honestly, the last couple of years have been a rollercoaster. After a massive, scary spike in homicides during the pandemic years of 2020 and 2021, something weird happened. The numbers started to plummet.
According to the Council on Criminal Justice (CCJ), homicides in major U.S. cities dropped by roughly 16% in 2024. That trend didn't just stop; it accelerated into 2025. By mid-2025, cities were seeing an additional 17% decline on average.
But even with things getting better overall, the "per capita" leaders stay surprisingly consistent.
Take St. Louis, Missouri. For years, it has sat at or near the top of the list for us cities per capita murders. In 2024, its rate was roughly 48.6 per 100,000 residents. Compare that to New York City, which had a rate of about 4.7. Even though New York had more total murders because it has 8 million people, an individual in St. Louis was statistically over ten times more likely to be a victim.
✨ Don't miss: Ukraine War Map May 2025: Why the Frontlines Aren't Moving Like You Think
Then there is New Orleans. In some recent stretches, the Big Easy actually overtook St. Louis for the #1 spot, hitting rates as high as 46 to 53 per 100,000. It’s a city of jazz and world-class food, but it’s also a city that has struggled deeply with structural poverty and a police force that has been stretched thin for a decade.
The Cities That Might Surprise You
Most people assume the "dangerous" cities are just the ones they see on The Wire or in rap videos. But the per capita data tells a different story.
- Memphis, Tennessee: This city has seen a brutal surge. While other cities saw rates drop in 2023 and 2024, Memphis actually saw its homicide rate climb to over 40 per 100,000. It’s currently one of the few places where the trend is going the wrong way.
- Birmingham, Alabama: It’s not always on the national news, but Birmingham consistently ranks in the top five. High levels of aggravated assault and a high murder rate per capita make it statistically more dangerous than much larger metros.
- Baltimore, Maryland: Baltimore is the "comeback kid" in a weird, tragic way. It used to be the undisputed heavyweight of high murder rates. However, in 2024 and 2025, it saw some of the biggest drops in the country—down nearly 40%. It's still high (around 35-36 per 100,000), but the progress is real.
Why Chicago Gets a Bad Rap
Let’s talk about Chicago. Everyone loves to talk about Chicago.
In terms of total volume, Chicago often leads the nation. In 2023, it had over 600 murders; in previous years, it topped 800. Those are big, scary numbers. But when you look at us cities per capita murders, Chicago usually doesn't even crack the top 10.
Its rate typically hovers around 24 per 100,000.
Is that high? Yes. Is it worse than St. Louis (48) or New Orleans (46)? Not even close. The reason Chicago stays in the news is simply because of the sheer scale. It’s a huge city, so the "body count" is high, but the statistical risk for an average resident is lower than in many smaller, Midwestern cities.
🔗 Read more: Percentage of Women That Voted for Trump: What Really Happened
The Mid-Size Crisis
Something nobody talks about is the rise of the mid-sized city. Places like Little Rock, Arkansas and Jackson, Mississippi have seen their rates explode. Jackson, in particular, has seen rates that rival the worst years of 1990s-era Detroit.
When a city has only 150,000 people, it only takes a small increase in "beefs" or gang activity to send the per capita rate through the roof.
Understanding the "Why" Behind the Numbers
Data is just math, and math doesn't have a soul. To understand why certain cities lead in us cities per capita murders, you have to look at what's happening on the ground. Experts like Adam Gelb from the Council on Criminal Justice point to a few specific things that happened post-2020.
First, there was the "Great Disruption." The pandemic didn't just make people sick; it broke the social systems that keep the peace. Schools closed, community centers shut down, and the "street outreach" workers who usually mediate gang disputes were stuck at home.
Second, we have the clearance rate problem.
In some of these high-murder-rate cities, the police only "solve" (arrest someone for) about 30% to 40% of murders. When people feel like the police can’t or won't protect them, they start taking matters into their own hands. It becomes a cycle of retaliation. "You shot my cousin, so I have to shoot you because the cops won't do anything." That's how a single dispute turns into ten murders in a month.
💡 You might also like: What Category Was Harvey? The Surprising Truth Behind the Number
Is the Trend Finally Flipping?
The good news? 2025 was one of the best years for crime reduction in a generation.
By the end of 2025, the national murder rate had fallen to levels we haven't seen since before the 2020 spike. Some experts believe the "fever" has finally broken. In Chicago, homicides are heading for a 10-year low. In Detroit, the 2024 murder count was the lowest it had been since the 1960s.
It’s not just "better policing," either. It’s a mix of things:
- Violence Interruption: Cities are finally funding "credible messengers"—former gang members who talk kids out of pulling triggers.
- Economic Stabilization: As the post-pandemic economy leveled out, some of the "desperation crime" subsided.
- Technology: Better use of data to predict where shootings might happen (though this is controversial).
Actionable Steps for Reality-Based Safety
If you're looking at these numbers because you're moving, traveling, or just curious, don't just look at the city-wide rate. Safety is hyper-local. In almost every city mentioned above, the vast majority of violence is concentrated in just a few blocks or specific neighborhoods.
- Check Precinct-Level Data: Most major cities (like New Orleans or St. Louis) have open data portals. Look at the specific neighborhood, not just the city name.
- Look at Trends, Not Snapshots: A city might have a high rate today because of one bad month. Is the 3-year trend going up or down?
- Don't Ignore "Non-Fatal" Stats: Murder rates are often a matter of how good the local trauma hospital is. If you want to know how much shooting is happening, look at "Aggravated Battery with a Firearm" stats.
The reality of us cities per capita murders is that the "dangerous" label is often more complex than a ranking. While the South and Midwest still struggle with the highest rates, the massive declines in 2024 and 2025 suggest that the worst of the recent violence wave is finally behind us.