It sounds like something out of a spy thriller, but for Kilmar Armando Abrego Garcia, it’s a living nightmare. On March 12, 2025, the 29-year-old sheet metal apprentice was doing something as mundane as picking up his five-year-old son from a parking lot in Maryland. Suddenly, ICE agents surrounded him. They told him his immigration status had changed—which it hadn't—and within 72 hours, he was on a plane.
Not just any plane. He was on a deportation flight bound for El Salvador’s Terrorism Confinement Center (CECOT), a "mega-prison" notorious for its harsh conditions. Now, the U.S. admits mistakenly deporting Maryland man to El Salvador, but the road to getting him back is turning into a historic legal and diplomatic train wreck.
Honestly, the details of how this happened are kinda terrifying. Kilmar wasn't just some guy under the radar. He actually had a "withholding of removal" order from 2019. That’s a legal protection a judge gives you if they think you’ll likely be tortured or killed in your home country. He was checking in with ICE regularly, working toward his journeyman license, and raising his special-needs son with his wife, Jennifer Vasquez Sura, a U.S. citizen.
The "Administrative Error" That Sent a Father to a Mega-Prison
When the news first broke, the government called it an "administrative error." Basically, they messed up the paperwork. Robert Cerna, an acting ICE field office director, admitted in court filings that Kilmar wasn't even on the original manifest for that March 15 flight. He was an "alternate." When other people were taken off the list for various reasons, Kilmar was bumped up.
The system just... ignored his 2019 protection.
👉 See also: Who's the Next Pope: Why Most Predictions Are Basically Guesswork
The government’s argument is basically that they did it in "good faith" because they believed he was a member of MS-13. But here’s the kicker: the "evidence" for that gang affiliation was largely based on him wearing a Chicago Bulls hat and hoodie years ago. No criminal record. No charges. Just a hat and a vague tip from an informant that a judge had already looked at and decided wasn't enough to deport him.
A Legal Tug-of-War at the Highest Level
U.S. District Judge Paula Xinis was not happy. During a hearing in April 2025, she described the deportation as an "illegal act." She ordered the government to bring him back.
But then things got weird.
The Trump administration's Department of Justice, led by Attorney General Pam Bondi, argued that because Kilmar was already on Salvadoran soil, U.S. courts didn't have the power to order his return. They claimed it was now a matter of "foreign relations."
✨ Don't miss: Recent Obituaries in Charlottesville VA: What Most People Get Wrong
The case went all the way to the Supreme Court. The justices eventually ruled that the administration must "facilitate" his return. But "facilitate" is a slippery word. The government interpreted it as "we'll provide a plane if El Salvador lets him go," while El Salvador’s President Nayib Bukele basically said, "No thanks, we're keeping him."
- March 12: Kilmar is arrested in Maryland.
- March 15: He is flown to El Salvador and sent to CECOT.
- March 31: U.S. officials admit the "administrative error" in court.
- April 4: Judge Xinis orders his return by midnight the following Monday.
- April 10: The Supreme Court weighs in, telling the U.S. to help get him back.
Why This Case Has Everyone Worried
If you've been following the news, you know this isn't just about one guy. It’s about whether a "mistake" can strip someone of their due process rights forever.
His lawyer, Simon Sandoval-Moshenberg, put it pretty bluntly: if the government can just say "oops" and then claim they can't fix it, then immigration laws don't really mean anything.
The diplomatic side of this is even messier. While the U.S. was admitting the mistake, Salvadoran officials were doubling down. Bukele even referred to Kilmar as a "terrorist" on social media. It creates this impossible situation where a U.S. resident is stuck in a foreign prison because of a clerical error and a political stalemate.
🔗 Read more: Trump New Gun Laws: What Most People Get Wrong
What’s happening now?
Right now, Kilmar is still in custody. His wife, Jennifer, only found out where he was when she saw photos of prisoners at CECOT and recognized his tattoos and head scars.
The U.S. government is facing massive pressure from over 30 Senators, including Maryland’s Chris Van Hollen, who are demanding a full review of how this happened. They want to know if there are other "Kilmars" out there—people with legal protections who were swept up in mass deportation flights by mistake.
Key Takeaways and Next Steps
This case is a wake-up call for anyone navigating the immigration system. An "administrative error" can happen to anyone, even those with "protected status."
If you or someone you know is in a similar situation—having a withholding of removal or asylum pending—staying proactive is the only defense.
- Keep Paperwork Handy: Always have a physical and digital copy of your withholding of removal or stay of removal orders. If you're stopped, these are your most powerful tools.
- Contact Your Reps: In Kilmar’s case, the involvement of Maryland’s congressional delegation was the only reason the story got national traction. If a mistake happens, call your Senator or Representative immediately.
- Know Your ICE Rights: Even if an officer says your status has changed, you have the right to see a judge before being removed if you have an existing protection order.
- Legal Defense Funds: Support organizations like the Capital Area Immigrants' Rights (CAIR) Coalition or Murray Osorio PLLC, who are on the front lines of these "error" cases.
The fact that the U.S. admits mistakenly deporting Maryland man to El Salvador doesn't change the reality that he is still behind bars. The legal fight is far from over, and it will likely set the precedent for how the U.S. handles wrongful deportations for the next decade.