If you had Indiana playing Miami for a national title on your 2025 preseason bingo card, honestly, you're either a time traveler or a liar. But here we are. It is January 18, 2026, and the updated college football rankings look like something out of a fever dream. The final AP and Coaches polls are basically on ice until tomorrow night’s trophy presentation at Hard Rock Stadium, but the CFP hierarchy has already been blown to bits.
The Hoosiers are sitting at No. 1. Unbeaten. 15-0.
It feels weird just typing that. Curt Cignetti didn't just "flip the script" in Bloomington; he burned the old script, threw the ashes in the White River, and built a powerhouse out of transfers and sheer audacity. Meanwhile, Miami—the No. 10 seed that everyone counted out after they tripped up late in the season—is the last team standing from the ACC. They aren't just "back." They're terrifying.
The CFP Top 5 and the Chaos of the Semifinals
The bracket didn't care about blue-blood feelings this year. Georgia and Ohio State were the heavy favorites to meet in the final, but the updated college football rankings post-semifinals tell a much more violent story.
📖 Related: NFL Football Teams in Order: Why Most Fans Get the Hierarchy Wrong
- Indiana (15-0): They didn't just beat Oregon in the Rose Bowl; they dismantled them 56-22. It wasn't even as close as the score looked.
- Ohio State (12-2): The Buckeyes are technically "idle," but their loss to Indiana in the Big Ten title game and the subsequent playoff exit has them sitting in a weird limbo.
- Georgia (12-2): Kirby Smart’s bunch looked human against Miami.
- Texas Tech (12-2): The Red Raiders proved the Big 12 is no joke, but they couldn't survive the onslaught of a resurgent Miami.
- Oregon (11-2): The Ducks ran into the Indiana buzzsaw and never recovered.
It's wild to see Texas Tech and Indiana in the top four while traditional giants like Alabama and Texas are watching from the couch. Alabama actually tumbled down to No. 11 in the final regular-season stretch after a home loss to Texas and a road stumble at Vanderbilt. Yes, Vanderbilt. The Commodores actually cracked the top 10 in the basketball polls this week too, just to rub it in.
Why Miami’s No. 10 Seed Was a Total Lie
The Hurricanes entered the playoff as the 10th seed, but if you look at the updated college football rankings through the lens of "who is actually playing well right now," they’re easily Top 2. Cam Ward’s successor at QB has been lighting up defenses, and that defensive front just bullied Georgia in the Chick-fil-A Peach Bowl.
Miami is 13-2, but those two losses feel like ancient history. They’ve averaged 40+ points in the playoffs. They are the ultimate "peaking at the right time" squad. Most analysts—the guys who actually watch the tape and don't just stare at logos—will tell you that Miami’s speed on the edges is the only thing that can actually bother Indiana’s disciplined offensive line.
👉 See also: Why Your 1 Arm Pull Up Progression Isn't Working (And How to Fix It)
The Big Ten’s Absolute Dominance (And One Big Flaw)
The Big Ten ended the season with three teams in the top five. That sounds like a victory lap for the conference, right? Well, sort of. While Indiana and Ohio State carried the banner, the middle of the pack was a mess.
Michigan plummeted to No. 18 after a late-season collapse, and Penn State somehow managed to finish 6-6, which is genuinely impressive given the talent on that roster. The updated college football rankings show a massive gap between the "haves" and the "have-nots" in the new 18-team super-conferences. You're either a playoff contender or you're fighting for a spot in the Weed Eater Bowl. There is no in-between anymore.
Notable Movers in the Final Week
- Vanderbilt: Stayed relevant at No. 12 after a 10-2 season that nobody saw coming.
- Notre Dame: Settled at No. 9. Always there, never quite over the hump.
- Texas A&M: Finished at No. 7. Mike Elko has them moving, but they lacked the "big game" punch to move into the top four.
- Arizona: Actually ranked No. 22 in football while being No. 1 in basketball. A weird time to be a Wildcat.
Real Talk: The Polls are Still Subjective
Even with a 12-team playoff, the AP Poll and the Coaches Poll still matter for recruiting and "prestige." There is a massive debate right now about whether a 2-loss Georgia should be ranked ahead of a 2-loss Texas Tech.
✨ Don't miss: El Salvador partido de hoy: Why La Selecta is at a Critical Turning Point
The "eye test" people love Georgia. The "resume" people point to the Red Raiders. Honestly, the updated college football rankings often reward the bigger brand name when the records are identical. It’s a flaw in the system that hasn't gone away just because we added more playoff games.
What Happens Tomorrow Night?
The national championship game (Monday, January 19) is the final piece of the puzzle. If Indiana wins, they’ll be the first unanimous No. 1 from a non-traditional power in the modern era. If Miami pulls the upset, the pollsters are going to have a headache. Do you put a 2-loss Miami at No. 1 over a 15-1 Indiana?
Probably. The winner of the game usually gets the crown.
But for the fans in Bloomington, the rankings don't matter as much as the reality: they are 60 minutes away from the impossible.
Actionable Insights for the Offseason
- Watch the Portal: Indiana’s success was built on specific "plug-and-play" transfers. Expect every mid-tier Power 4 school to try and copy the Cignetti blueprint this February.
- Schedule Strength Matters: The SEC’s "cannibalization" actually hurt their final rankings this year. If you're a Top 15 team, one bad week against a "bottom-feeder" like Vandy can ruin your seeding.
- Futures Betting: Keep an eye on the early 2027 odds. Teams like Nebraska (who finished strong just outside the Top 25) are primed for a leap now that the playoff path is wider.
The final updated college football rankings will drop Tuesday morning, right after the confetti is swept off the field in Miami. Whether it's "Cream and Crimson" or "The U" at the top, the 2025-26 season has officially killed the idea that only four teams matter.