If you had told a Mountain West fan five years ago that UNLV football vs Utah State Aggies football would become one of the most high-stakes, heart-attack-inducing matchups in the conference, they probably would’ve laughed at you. For a long time, the Rebels were the team everyone scheduled for an easy "W," while the Aggies were the gritty, consistent contenders from Logan.
Times have changed.
Seriously, the 2025 season capped off a massive shift in how these two programs see each other. When UNLV walked off the field at Allegiant Stadium after that double-overtime thriller on November 15, 2025, it wasn't just another win. It was a statement. The Rebels took a 29-26 victory, extending a three-game win streak against the Aggies that has completely flipped the script on this series.
The Night Allegiant Stood Still: November 15, 2025
Most people expected a blowout. UNLV was sitting at 8-2, looking like a legitimate Top 25 contender under Dan Mullen. Utah State was hovering around .500, fighting for bowl eligibility. But college football doesn't care about your "expected" outcomes.
The game was a defensive slog early on. You’ve got to appreciate the irony: a game in the glitzy, $2 billion Allegiant Stadium turning into a muddy trench war. At halftime, the Aggies led 13-10, and the Rebels looked like they had forgotten how to play football. Anthony Colandrea, the UNLV quarterback, was getting chased by Utah State's pass rush every other snap. It was ugly.
Then the fourth quarter happened.
👉 See also: Ohio State Football All White Uniforms: Why the Icy Look Always Sparks a Debate
Bryson Barnes, the Utah State QB, broke off a 58-yard touchdown run that felt like a dagger. It put the Aggies up 23-20 with only seven minutes left. UNLV's Ramon Villela managed to nail a 32-yard field goal to force overtime, and that’s where things got truly bizarre. Both kickers—Villela and Utah State’s Tanner Rinker—missed field goals in the first overtime. Basically, nobody wanted to win.
Finally, in the second OT, Rinker hit a 39-yarder to give Utah State a lead. But UNLV didn't blink. On the very first play of their possession, Kayden McGee took the handoff and disappeared into a pile of bodies, only to emerge on the other side and sprint 25 yards for the walk-off touchdown. Game over. Rebels win.
A History of One-Sidedness (Until Now)
If we look at the all-time record, Utah State still holds the crown. They’ve won 18 times to UNLV's 10. For a long stretch, the Aggies treated the Rebels like a junior varsity squad. Between 2012 and 2021, Utah State won six in a row. Some of those weren't even competitive—like the 59-28 shellacking in 2018.
But the momentum shifted in 2022. UNLV started recruiting differently. They started playing with a chip on their shoulder.
The 2024 game in Logan was perhaps the loudest signal that the power dynamic had changed. UNLV went into Maverik Stadium and put up 50 points. Fifty! In a 50-34 win, the Rebels showed a level of offensive explosiveness that Utah State just couldn't match. It’s rare to see an "underdog" go into a hostile environment like Logan and just take over, but that’s exactly what happened.
✨ Don't miss: Who Won the Golf Tournament This Weekend: Richard T. Lee and the 2026 Season Kickoff
Notable Games in the Series
- 1995: UNLV wins 42-0 (The largest margin of victory in series history).
- 1986: Utah State wins 7-6 (The definition of a "sickos" game).
- 2025: UNLV wins 29-26 (The double-OT classic).
The Coaching Chess Match
You can't talk about UNLV football vs Utah State Aggies football without looking at the sidelines. Dan Mullen taking over at UNLV was a massive hire. He brought a SEC-level intensity to Las Vegas that the program has never really seen. He’s turned Anthony Colandrea into a playmaker who stays calm under pressure, which was the difference-maker in that 2025 overtime win.
On the other side, Bronco Mendenhall is doing his thing at Utah State. He’s a stabilizer. He took a program that was reeling from coaching turnover and turned them back into a tough, disciplined unit. The Aggies' 3-4 defense in 2025 was surprisingly effective at neutralizing big plays, even if they couldn't quite stop McGee in the final moments.
Key Players Who Changed the Narrative
There are specific names that Aggie and Rebel fans will remember for a long time.
For UNLV, it’s Kayden McGee. His 2025 performance was the stuff of legends. But let’s not forget Anthony Colandrea, who threw for 276 yards in that same game. He isn't the most accurate passer in the world, but he’s got "it." When the play breaks down, he finds a way.
For Utah State, Bryson Barnes has been a warrior. He threw for 256 yards and rushed for 124 in the 2025 loss. It’s hard to ask for more from a quarterback. He basically carried the team on his back. And Braden Pegan—the guy caught 60 passes for 926 yards across the 2025 season. He was a constant headache for Mountain West defensive coordinators.
🔗 Read more: The Truth About the Memphis Grizzlies Record 2025: Why the Standings Don't Tell the Whole Story
What's Next for This Matchup?
As we look toward the 2026 season and beyond, this isn't just a mid-season conference game anymore. It’s a rivalry that determines who gets a shot at the Mountain West Championship. UNLV is no longer the easy win. In fact, they might be the new favorites in the conference.
Utah State is in a bit of a transition period with a lot of guys hitting the transfer portal—like Braden Pegan heading to the University of Utah—but Mendenhall is a master at rebuilding on the fly. They’ll be back.
Actionable Insights for Fans and Bettors:
- Watch the Spread: In the last three matchups, the underdog has covered the spread twice. These teams play each other closer than the "experts" think.
- The Over/Under Trap: Everyone expects high scores because of the Vegas/Logan climates, but the 2025 game proved that these two can get into a defensive grind. Check the defensive depth charts before betting the over.
- Recruiting Matters: Keep an eye on the 2026 commitments. UNLV is landing four-star talent now, which is a total game-changer for the Mountain West.
- Venue Advantage: Allegiant Stadium is becoming a fortress for the Rebels. They play differently on that turf.
The days of skipping a UNLV vs Utah State game are officially over. Whether it's a 50-point blowout or a double-OT heart-stopper, this series has become must-watch TV for anyone who loves college football.
To stay ahead of the next matchup, keep a close eye on the Mountain West injury reports and transfer portal moves during the spring. The rosters for both teams are extremely fluid right now, and a single key departure could swing the 2026 betting line by several points. Check the official athletic sites for UNLV and Utah State for the most recent depth chart updates before the season kicks off.