Most people think the border between the U.S. and Canada has always been this polite, shared space of maple syrup and hockey trades. It's the "longest undefended border in the world," right? Well, honestly, that's a relatively new vibe.
History is messier.
There was a time when the United States Canada war wasn't just a hypothetical "what if" scribbled in a Pentagon basement. It was a series of brutal, often chaotic invasions where the U.S. tried—and repeatedly failed—to turn Canada into the 14th (or 15th, or 20th) state.
The War of 1812: When Washington Burned and Canada Didn't Budge
You've probably heard of the War of 1812. Most Americans remember it for the "Star-Spangled Banner" or Andrew Jackson at New Orleans. But for Canadians, this was basically their war of independence.
It started because the British were messing with American ships and pressing sailors into service. The U.S. was furious. But instead of just fighting at sea, Thomas Jefferson famously said that taking Canada would be a "mere matter of marching."
He was wrong. Very wrong.
In June 1812, the U.S. declared war and launched a three-pronged invasion. They expected the locals to welcome them as liberators. Instead, they met Major-General Isaac Brock and the Shawnee leader Tecumseh. These two were a powerhouse duo. Brock was bold, and Tecumseh’s warriors were terrifying to the underskilled American militias.
At the Battle of Queenston Heights, the Americans got thrashed. Even though Brock died in the charge, the U.S. invasion stalled.
Then things got ugly.
In 1813, American troops captured York—which we now call Toronto—and burned down the parliament buildings. They literally torched the place. It was a petty move, and the British didn't forget it. A year later, they sailed up the Chesapeake, marched into Washington D.C., and burned the White House and the Capitol to the ground in direct retaliation.
The whole thing ended in 1815 with the Treaty of Ghent. Basically, everyone agreed to stop fighting and go back to the original borders. It was a stalemate on paper, but it changed everything for the people living there.
Why the 1812 Conflict Still Matters
- Canadian Identity: This was the moment Canadians started feeling like "not Americans."
- Indigenous Loss: Tecumseh’s dream of an independent Indigenous nation died with him at the Battle of the Thames.
- The "Militia Myth": Canada started believing its own citizens could defend the land without a massive professional army.
The Weird "Wars" You Never Learned in School
Between 1815 and the early 1900s, things stayed tense. We’re talking "neighbor looking at you over the fence with a shotgun" tense.
Take the Aroostook War of 1838. It’s often called the "Pork and Beans War." Why? Because nobody actually died in battle. It was a dispute over the border between Maine and New Brunswick. Both sides sent militias into the woods. They mostly just yelled at each other and struggled with supply lines. The only "casualties" were from accidents or illness.
Then there was the Pig War of 1859.
I’m serious.
On San Juan Island, an American farmer shot a pig belonging to the British Hudson’s Bay Company because it was eating his potatoes. This escalated into a full-on military standoff. For weeks, British warships and American soldiers stared each other down over a dead hog. Eventually, they realized how ridiculous they looked and settled it through arbitration.
But not every "minor" conflict was funny.
The Fenian Raids (1866–1871)
After the American Civil War, a group of Irish-Americans called the Fenians decided the best way to free Ireland from Britain was to... invade Canada?
It sounds like a fever dream, but they actually did it.
These were battle-hardened Civil War veterans. They crossed the border several times, winning the Battle of Ridgeway in 1866. They even raised an Irish flag on Canadian soil. The U.S. government eventually cracked down on them, but these raids pushed the Canadian colonies to finally unite into one country in 1867.
Basically, Canada became a country because they were tired of getting raided by people from the U.S.
War Plan Red: The 20th Century Invasion Strategy
Fast forward to the 1920s and 30s. You’d think the two countries were best friends by then.
Not quite.
The U.S. military actually developed a top-secret strategy called War Plan Red. It wasn't just a "just in case" folder; it was a detailed blueprint for a full-scale invasion of Canada. The goal was to seize key ports like Halifax to stop the British Navy from using them.
The plan involved:
- Chemical Warfare: They discussed using gas to disable Canadian defenses.
- Bombing Campaigns: Targets like Winnipeg and Vancouver were on the list.
- Land Occupation: Massive troop movements across the border to neutralize the "Red" (British/Canadian) threat.
Canada wasn't oblivious. They had their own plan, Defence Scheme No. 1. Their strategy was basically to launch a surprise attack on places like Seattle and Detroit to buy time for the British to arrive.
✨ Don't miss: George W. Bush and Skull and Bones: The Truth Behind the Secret Society
The plans weren't officially scrapped until 1939 when World War II forced everyone to finally pick the same side.
Modern Reality: The "Soft" War Over Water and Rocks
We aren't shooting at each other anymore, but the United States Canada war has shifted into the courtroom.
There are still disputed territories.
Have you heard of Machias Seal Island? It’s a tiny, 20-acre rock off the coast of Maine. Both countries claim it. Canada keeps a lighthouse keeper there 24/7 just to maintain "sovereignty." The U.S. doesn't recognize the claim, and every year, lobster fishermen from both sides get into shouting matches over who has the right to the lucrative "Grey Zone" waters around it.
Then there’s the Northwest Passage.
As Arctic ice melts, this shipping route is becoming a gold mine. Canada says it’s theirs. The U.S. (and most of the world) says it’s international water. It sounds like a boring legal debate, but with trillions of dollars in trade and oil at stake, it’s the closest thing we have to a modern border conflict.
Actionable Takeaways: How to Understand This History
If you want to actually "get" the relationship between these two giants, you have to look past the tourism ads.
- Visit the Battlefields: If you're near Niagara Falls, go to Old Fort Erie or Queenston Heights. You’ll see the war from the Canadian perspective, which is wildly different from what’s taught in U.S. schools.
- Check the Maps: Look at the "Grey Zone" near Maine on a maritime map. It’s one of the few places on Earth where the border is literally a fuzzy line.
- Read the Primary Sources: Look up the actual text of War Plan Red (it was declassified in the 70s). It’s chilling to see how clinical the U.S. military was about invading its "best friend."
The United States Canada war history proves that peace isn't the absence of conflict—it’s the decision to stop fighting. We moved from burning capitals to arguing over lobster traps and Northwest Passage transit fees. That’s progress, even if it’s still a little salty.
Check your local historical society for "War of 1812" bicentennial records to see if your own town played a part in the invasion routes.