Public discourse today is messy. You've probably seen the heated threads on X or TikTok where someone flatly claims that black people are more racist than other groups, usually pointing to viral videos or personal anecdotes of prejudice. It’s a polarizing topic. People get defensive immediately. But if we’re going to actually look at the data and the sociology behind these claims, we have to move past the shouting matches and look at how "racism" is actually defined by experts versus how it's used in everyday conversation.
Context matters. A lot.
When people type the phrase "black people are more racist" into a search engine, they are usually looking for one of two things. They are either looking for statistics on hate crimes and interpersonal bias, or they are trying to understand why "reverse racism" isn't a term used in academic circles. It’s complicated because the word "racism" actually does double duty in the English language.
For most people, racism just means "prejudice." It’s a person-to-person thing. If someone treats you poorly because of your skin color, that feels like racism. Period. However, for sociologists and historians, racism is more about power dynamics and systemic outcomes. This gap in definition is where most of the fighting happens.
The Data on Interpersonal Prejudice and Perception
Let’s look at the numbers. If we define racism as "racial prejudice" or "in-group favoritism," we can look at psychological studies. The Pew Research Center has done extensive work on how different groups view one another. In various surveys, Black Americans often report higher levels of racial identity and solidarity. Some critics argue this in-group preference is a form of exclusion.
However, when you look at the FBI’s Uniform Crime Reporting (UCR) Program, the data on hate crimes tells a specific story. In 2022, the FBI reported that 59.1% of known hate crime offenders were White, while 21.1% were Black. Given that Black people make up about 13-14% of the U.S. population, some argue these figures show a disproportionate involvement in racially motivated incidents. This is often the "smoking gun" used in online debates to claim that black people are more racist.
But data is rarely a straight line.
✨ Don't miss: Am I Gay Buzzfeed Quizzes and the Quest for Identity Online
Criminologists like Dr. James Nolan, a former FBI official, often point out that hate crime reporting is notoriously inconsistent. Many local police departments don't report at all. Furthermore, the motivation behind a crime is often hard to prove in court. Is a fight between two people of different races a "hate crime" or just a fight? It depends on who is holding the clipboard.
Why the "Power + Prejudice" Definition Changes the Conversation
If you walk into a Sociology 101 classroom at any major university, the professor will likely tell you that Black people cannot be racist in a systemic sense. This drives a lot of people crazy. It feels like a double standard.
The logic goes like this: Racism = Prejudice + Power.
In this framework, racism isn't just about being mean. It's about having the institutional power to affect someone's life—their ability to get a mortgage, their likelihood of being arrested, or the quality of their healthcare. Since Black Americans, as a group, do not hold the majority of institutional power in the U.S. (wealth, legislative control, or corporate ownership), academics argue they can be prejudiced, but they can't be racist because they can't enforce that prejudice on a scale that shifts the entire society.
Honestly, this feels like semantics to a guy who just got yelled at on the subway. To him, it’s all the same. But to a policy maker, the distinction is everything. If a White landlord refuses to rent to Black tenants, that’s a systemic barrier to housing. If a Black landlord refuses to rent to White tenants, it’s still illegal and wrong, but it doesn’t create a national housing crisis for White people because they have thousands of other options.
That’s the "power" part of the equation.
🔗 Read more: Easy recipes dinner for two: Why you are probably overcomplicating date night
The Impact of Social Media Echo Chambers
Algorithms love conflict. If you click on one video of a Black person being "racist" toward a White person, your feed will suddenly be full of them. This creates a "frequency illusion." You start thinking it’s happening everywhere.
Professor Tali Sharot, a neuroscientist, has studied how our brains seek out information that confirms our existing biases. If you already believe that black people are more racist, you will find "evidence" every single day on your phone. You’ll ignore the millions of normal, positive interactions happening in the real world.
Examining the Concept of "Lateral Racism"
There is also the issue of prejudice within minority communities, sometimes called "lateral violence" or "horizontal racism." This happens when marginalized groups turn on each other. We see this in tensions between Black and Asian communities, or Black and Latino communities in cities like Los Angeles or New York.
In 2021, following the rise in anti-Asian hate crimes, there was a huge debate about the identity of the attackers. While viral videos often showed Black offenders, a study by the University of Maryland and the Association for Asian American Studies found that the vast majority of anti-Asian incidents were actually committed by White offenders, though the media coverage didn't always reflect that ratio.
The perception that black people are more racist toward other minorities is often fueled by high-profile, violent incidents that get massive views, while the mundane, everyday systemic issues get ignored.
What Most People Get Wrong About "Reverse Racism"
The term "reverse racism" is a bit of a misnomer. Racism is just racism. But when people use the phrase, they are usually talking about Affirmative Action or Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) programs.
💡 You might also like: How is gum made? The sticky truth about what you are actually chewing
Some White and Asian Americans feel these programs are a form of state-sanctioned racism. They see it as a "zero-sum game"—if a Black student gets a spot in medical school, they feel it was "stolen" from someone more "qualified."
The Supreme Court actually weighed in on this recently in the Students for Fair Admissions v. Harvard case (2023). The court ruled that race-conscious admission programs were unconstitutional. This was a massive win for those who believe that focusing on race—no matter the intent—is inherently racist.
Actionable Insights for Navigating the Tension
Understanding this topic requires more than just looking at a few charts. It requires a bit of emotional intelligence. If you find yourself in a debate about whether black people are more racist, here are a few ways to keep the conversation productive:
- Distinguish between "Prejudice" and "Systemic Power": Acknowledge that anyone can be prejudiced. No race has a monopoly on being a jerk. But also recognize that some prejudices have more weight behind them because of historical and institutional backing.
- Look at the Source: When you see a "viral" video, check the context. Was it edited? Who posted it? Is it a one-off event being used to paint an entire group of millions of people?
- Check the Stats, not the Vibes: Go to the FBI UCR or the Bureau of Justice Statistics. Don't rely on what "seems" to be true based on your social media feed.
- Acknowledge Individual Accountability: Racism shouldn't be a "get out of jail free" card. If a Black person commits a hate crime, they should be held accountable just like anyone else. Most people on all sides of the political aisle actually agree on this, even if it doesn't seem like it on the news.
- Read the Room: Understand that for many Black Americans, the "racism" they experience is death by a thousand cuts—microaggressions, being followed in stores, or being passed over for promotions. When they hear someone say "black people are the real racists," it feels like an erasure of their daily reality.
The reality is that we are living in a time of deep tribalism. It’s easy to find a "villain" in another group. It’s much harder to look at the historical structures that keep us at each other's throats. Whether you think the problem is individual bias or systemic oppression, the only way forward is a shared set of facts and a lot more empathy than we currently see on the internet.
To move the needle, start by looking into the Harvard Implicit Association Test (IAT). It’s a tool that helps you see your own subconscious biases, regardless of your race. You might be surprised by what you find. From there, read books like "Why Are All the Black Kids Sitting Together in the Cafeteria?" by Dr. Beverly Daniel Tatum. It offers a deep, non-combative look at how racial identity develops. Education, rather than outrage, is usually the best way to handle these complex social dynamics.