So, you’re 22 and you need a set of wheels for a road trip. You hop on a booking site, see a compact car for $30 a day, and think, "Sweet, I can swing that." Then you hit the checkout screen and—BAM—the price doubles. That’s the "Young Driver Surcharge" hitting you like a ton of bricks. Honestly, it’s one of the most frustrating parts of being a young traveler today.
Most people think it’s actually illegal for a rental company to deny you a car if you’re under 25. That is flat-out wrong. In the United States, only Michigan and New York have laws that legally mandate companies to rent to drivers as young as 18. Everywhere else? They can basically tell you to take a hike. Or, more commonly, they’ll let you rent the car but charge you a "risk fee" that makes your wallet weep.
The Real Math Behind the Under 25 Rent A Car Mess
Why do they do this? It isn’t just some corporate conspiracy to ruin your vacation. Insurance companies are obsessed with data. According to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) and the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS), drivers under 25 are statistically more likely to be involved in accidents. Because of this, insurance premiums for rental agencies skyrocket for that age bracket.
They pass that cost directly to you.
Usually, this daily fee ranges from $15 to $35. If you’re renting a car for a week, you’re looking at an extra $200 just for being young. It’s annoying. It’s expensive. But if you know which levers to pull, you can actually get around a lot of these costs.
How to Dodge the Under 25 Rent A Car Surcharge Legally
You don't have to just accept the first price you see. There are specific memberships and "hacks" (the legal kind) that wipe these fees off the map.
AAA is your best friend. Seriously. If you are between 20 and 24, a AAA membership usually pays for itself in a single day of renting. Why? Because Hertz has a long-standing partnership with AAA where they waive the young driver fee entirely for members. You might pay $60 for a year of AAA, but you’ll save $200 on your rental. It’s a no-brainer.
USAID and Military Orders. If you are active-duty military or a government employee traveling on official business, most agencies like Enterprise and Avis waive the age requirements and the fees. Even if you're on leisure travel, many companies offer significant discounts or fee waivers for military personnel. You’ll need your ID, obviously.
Corporate Codes. If you work for a big company—think Deloitte, Amazon, or even a local university—your HR department might have a "corporate discount code." These codes often include a clause that waives the underage fee. Check your employee handbook. You'd be surprised how many people leave this money on the table.
📖 Related: Doylestown things to do that aren't just the Mercer Museum
The "Big Three" Comparison
Not all rental companies treat 21-year-olds the same.
Hertz is often the most expensive upfront but, as mentioned, the AAA hookup makes them the cheapest for young drivers if you have that card.
Enterprise is the "safe" bet. They generally allow rentals for those 21 and up at most locations, but their fees are strictly local. A suburban Enterprise in Ohio might charge you $15 a day extra, while an Enterprise at LAX might hit you for $30.
Avis and Budget are basically the same company. They usually have a hard floor at 21 years old. If you’re 19 and trying to rent from them, forget it unless you’re in New York or Michigan.
The Hidden Restrictions Nobody Mentions
Even if you pay the fee, you can’t just rent anything on the lot.
Most agencies have a "class restriction" for anyone using an under 25 rent a car service. You want that Mustang convertible? Probably not happening. The burly Suburban for your eight friends? Nope. Usually, you are restricted to:
- Economy cars
- Compacts
- Standard Sedans
- Sometimes small SUVs (like a RAV4)
Exotics, luxury SUVs, and high-performance vehicles are almost universally off-limits to anyone under 25. They see a 23-year-old in a Corvette as a $70,000 liability waiting to happen.
Peer-to-Peer: The Turo Alternative
Turo is the "Airbnb of cars," and it’s changed the game for young drivers. But don't think it's a free pass.
👉 See also: Deer Ridge Resort TN: Why Gatlinburg’s Best View Is Actually in Bent Creek
Turo allows drivers as young as 18 to book cars, which is great. However, if you're under 21, you’ll be hit with a "Young Driver Fee" that can be $50 a day or more. If you're 21 to 25, the fee is usually around $30.
The plus side? You might find a cool older car that a traditional agency wouldn't carry. The downside? If you wreck a Turo car, you’re dealing with a private owner and Turo’s specific insurance (Liberty Mutual), which can be a massive headache compared to a standard corporate rental agreement.
Insurance: Don't Get Burned Twice
When you go to the counter, the agent is going to try to sell you the Collision Damage Waiver (CDW). It’s usually another $20-$30 a day.
For an under 25 rent a car user, this is where it gets tricky. Your personal car insurance might cover rentals, but only if you have "full coverage" (comprehensive and collision) on your own car back home. If you only have liability on your beat-up 2010 Civic, it won't cover a 2024 rental car.
Also, check your credit card. Chase Sapphire Preferred and American Express Gold often offer primary or secondary rental insurance. Crucial point: Some of these credit card insurance perks have age limits in the fine print. Always call the number on the back of your card and ask, "Does my rental coverage apply if I am 22 years old?"
Do not guess. If you guess wrong, you’re on the hook for the full value of a new car.
Why Michigan and New York are Weird
If you’re 18 and desperate for a car, these are your only two havens.
In New York, state law says they have to rent to you if you're 18+. But there's a catch. The state allows companies to charge a massive surcharge. For 18-20 year olds in NY, the fee can be $100 per day. It’s almost better to just take an Uber or the train.
✨ Don't miss: Clima en Las Vegas: Lo que nadie te dice sobre sobrevivir al desierto
In Michigan, the fee is capped much lower, making it the most "youth-friendly" state for rentals.
Actionable Steps for Your Next Rental
If you’re ready to book, don't just click "Reserve" on a random travel site. Follow this specific workflow to save the most cash.
- Join AAA Immediately. Even if you don't own a car, the Hertz fee waiver alone is worth the membership fee.
- Check USAA. If your parents were in the military, you might be eligible for USAA. They have rental partnerships with Hertz, Avis, and Budget that frequently waive or heavily discount young driver fees.
- Download the Hertz Gold Plus Rewards and Enterprise Plus apps. Sometimes, being a "member" of their free loyalty programs gets you slightly lower surcharges or access to better customer service when you're trying to negotiate a fee at the counter.
- Avoid Airport Pickups. Airports add "concession recovery fees" and "facility charges" that can add 20% to your bill. Taking an Uber to a "neighborhood" rental location 10 miles away can save you $100 over a weekend.
- Bring a Credit Card. Most places will not let an under-25 driver use a debit card. If they do, they’ll put a $500 to $1,000 "hold" on your account. That’s rent money you can’t touch for a week.
Renting a car when you’re young is basically a tax on your age. It's not fair, but it's the reality of the industry's risk assessment. By using AAA or corporate codes, you can usually bring that "under 25" price back down to what everyone else is paying.
Verify the specific location's policy. Rental car branches are often franchises. Even if the national website says one thing, a specific owner in a high-theft area might have stricter rules. Always call the local desk—not the 1-800 number—to confirm they have the car you want and will honor your fee waiver.
Inspect the car like a detective. Young drivers are often scrutinized more during the return process. Take a video of the entire car—including the roof and the rims—before you leave the lot. If there is a tiny scratch, make sure it's noted on the paper. Do not trust the "Oh, we know about that one" verbal promise from the lot attendant.
Compare the total cost, not the daily rate. A $25/day car with a $35/day surcharge is more expensive than a $45/day car with no surcharge. Use a calculator and look at the "estimated total" on the final booking page before you put in your credit card info.
The industry is slowly changing, and some startups are trying to court younger drivers without the predatory fees, but for now, the legacy players still run the show. Play their game by their rules, but use their own discount programs against them to keep your travel budget intact.