It started with a protest. Not a quiet one, either. In 1985, Bono found himself sitting in a room with Keith Richards and Ron Wood, the legendary guitarists of the Rolling Stones, and the vibe was... loose. They were working on a track for the Sun City anti-apartheid project, a massive collaborative effort spearheaded by Steven Van Zandt to boycott the luxury South African resort. Bono had this sketch of a song. It was jagged. It was angry. But when he tried to play it for the Stones, he realized something embarrassing. He didn't know how to play the blues.
That song was Silver and Gold.
Most casual fans know it from the massive Rattle and Hum movie or the live album, where Bono famously shouts about "Amereecay" and Charles Manson. But the history of the track is way more tangled than a simple live performance. It’s actually the pivot point where U2 stopped being just a post-punk band from Dublin and started trying to become the biggest rock band in the world by inhaling American roots music.
Why Silver and Gold marked a massive shift for U2
Before this track, U2 was all about atmosphere. Think The Unforgettable Fire. It was gauzy, experimental, and very European. Then comes "Silver and Gold," and suddenly they’re trying to sound like they grew up in the Mississippi Delta. Or at least, they were trying to understand the soul of the people who did.
Bono wrote the lyrics in a New York hotel room, fueled by the disgust he felt regarding the apartheid regime in South Africa. The song is written from the perspective of a man trapped in that system—someone who has nothing while the world trades in the very minerals (the silver and gold) being ripped out of his land. It’s gritty. It’s uncomfortable. Honestly, it’s one of the few times U2’s political anger felt truly sharp and serrated rather than soaring and anthemic.
The original version featured Keith Richards and Ron Wood. You can hear the dirt under their fingernails on that recording. It’s sloppy rock and roll in the best way possible. When U2 eventually re-recorded it as a B-side for "Where the Streets Have No Name," they polished it up, but they kept that primal, acoustic-heavy drive. Edge’s guitar work here is fascinating because he ditches the delay pedals. He plays it straight.
The Rattle and Hum performance: "This is a song called Silver and Gold"
If you were alive in the late 80s or have spent any time on YouTube’s classic rock corners, you’ve seen the footage. Denver, Colorado. November 1987. Bono looks like he’s about to vibrate out of his skin.
He delivers a mid-song monologue that has become legendary—and a bit polarizing. "OK, Edge, play the blues!" he yells. Then he launches into a tirade about the "moral majority" and "backwards-looking" people who were supporting the South African government. It’s peak Bono. For some, it’s the moment U2 became "too much." For others, it’s the most authentic moment of the Joshua Tree era.
📖 Related: Why American Beauty by the Grateful Dead is Still the Gold Standard of Americana
What’s often missed in the spectacle is the musicality of that specific live take. Adam Clayton’s bass line is incredibly heavy, almost menacing. It doesn't follow a standard blues progression; it feels more like a march. Larry Mullen Jr. isn't swinging the beat; he's hitting it like he’s trying to break the snare head. This is U2 trying to find a middle ground between their punk roots and the Delta blues they were obsessed with at the time.
The link between Sun City and U2's evolution
To understand the weight of "Silver and Gold," you have to look at the Sun City album. This wasn't just another "We Are the World" charity single. It was an aggressive, political middle finger to the industry. Artists like Miles Davis, Lou Reed, and Run-D.M.C. were involved.
Bono being invited into that circle changed him. He realized that to be a global band, U2 needed to move past the "white flag" imagery of War. They needed a deeper vocabulary.
- The Sun City version is sparse and acoustic.
- The Joshua Tree B-side version is more "U2-sounding" with a fuller band arrangement.
- The live Rattle and Hum version is the definitive "rock" interpretation.
The lyrics: Wealth, oppression, and the "Prize"
The song’s protagonist is someone who is "cold as a stone," watching the wealth of his nation benefit everyone but him. When Bono sings about the "price of silver and gold," he isn't talking about jewelry. He’s talking about the human cost of the mining industry in South Africa during the 1980s.
"I can't see the bright stars shine / As I'm down in the hole, in the silver and gold."
It’s a claustrophobic lyric. It mirrors the feeling of being trapped in a mine, but also the metaphorical trap of poverty. The "captain" mentioned in the song represents the oppressive authority, the one who takes the riches while the worker gets the dust.
Interestingly, the song also touches on the idea of the "chosen ones." U2 has always wrestled with their faith, and here, Bono uses that lens to look at the hypocrisy of religious leaders who stayed silent during apartheid. It's a precursor to songs like "Until the End of the World," where the lyrics get much darker and more complex.
👉 See also: Why October London Make Me Wanna Is the Soul Revival We Actually Needed
Critical reception and the "Pretentious" label
Let's be real. This era of U2 drew a lot of fire. Critics at magazines like Spin and Village Voice started to turn on the band during the Rattle and Hum cycle. They felt U2 was "appropriating" American culture—trying to buy their way into the lineage of B.B. King and Bob Dylan.
"Silver and Gold" was often cited as Exhibit A in the trial of U2’s ego.
But looking back decades later, that criticism feels a bit dated. The band wasn't trying to be the blues; they were using the blues as a tool to express a specific kind of rage that their earlier, shimmering guitar pop couldn't handle. You can't sing about the horrors of apartheid with a shimmering chorus effect and a light delay. You need grit. You need the acoustic guitar to buzz against the frets.
Recording details you probably didn't know
When they did the B-side version at Windmill Lane Studios in Dublin, the vibe was very different from the New York session with the Stones. The band wanted to prove they could handle the material on their own.
- The Guitar Tone: The Edge used a 1945 Martin acoustic for much of the track's foundation. He wanted something that sounded "old," not "studio-perfect."
- The Tempo: If you compare the original Sun City version to the Rattle and Hum version, the live version is significantly faster. This was unintentional, driven by the adrenaline of the tour.
- The Manson Connection: In the live version, Bono mentions "Charles Manson stole this song from the Beatles... we're stealing it back." He was referring to "Helter Skelter," which U2 often played as an intro to "Silver and Gold" on that tour. It was a commentary on how symbols and art can be twisted for evil purposes—just as gold can be used for beauty or for oppression.
Is Silver and Gold still relevant?
The specific political context of apartheid has changed, but the song’s core theme—the disparity between those who own the resources and those who extract them—hasn't gone anywhere.
If you listen to the track today, it doesn't sound like a "80s song." It lacks the gated reverb and synth pads that date so much music from 1987. Because it was recorded with an emphasis on "roots" instruments, it has aged much better than tracks like "Invisible Sun" or even some of the stuff on The Unforgettable Fire.
It serves as a bridge. Without "Silver and Gold," we don't get the experimental leaps of Achtung Baby. The band had to go through this "American phase," stripping everything back to the bone, before they could reinvent themselves with electronic music in the 90s.
✨ Don't miss: How to Watch The Wolf and the Lion Without Getting Lost in the Wild
How to appreciate the track today
If you want to really "get" what they were doing, don't just stream the hits. You have to listen to the versions in order.
Start with the Keith Richards version. It's on the Sun City album (Artist United Against Apartheid). Hear the vulnerability in Bono’s voice. He sounds like a student in the presence of masters.
Then, watch the Denver footage. Look at the eyes of the band. They weren't just playing a show; they were on a mission. Even if you find the mid-song speech "cringey" by modern standards, the conviction is undeniable. They believed every word they were saying.
Actionable steps for the U2 collector and listener
If you're looking to dive deeper into this specific era of the band's history, here is how to navigate the "Silver and Gold" catalog:
- Find the B-side: Locate the 20th Anniversary Super Deluxe Edition of The Joshua Tree. It contains the studio version of "Silver and Gold" that many fans actually prefer over the live one because the production is cleaner and the vocals are more controlled.
- The Sun City Connection: Track down the "Sun City" music video. It's a time capsule of 1985 political activism and shows a very young Bono working alongside hip-hop pioneers and rock royalty.
- Check the Lyrics: Read the lyrics without the music playing. It reads more like a poem or a folk lament than a rock song. Notice the lack of a traditional "hook" or chorus—the title is the only repeating anchor.
- Compare the "Helter Skelter" Intro: If you can find bootlegs from the 1987 tour, listen to how the band transitioned from the chaos of the Beatles cover into the steady, pulsing rhythm of "Silver and Gold." It was a masterclass in setlist dynamics.
The song remains a testament to a time when rock bands felt they could change the world with three chords and a lot of shouting. It might be loud, it might be a little pretentious, but it's undeniably human. In a world of over-sanitized, AI-generated pop, the raw, bleeding throat of Bono during "Silver and Gold" feels more necessary than ever. It reminds us that music isn't just for dancing—sometimes, it's for reminding the world that things aren't right.
The legacy of the track isn't just in the charts or the sales. It's in the way it forced a generation of rock fans to look at a map and realize that the jewelry they wore had a history, often a dark one. That's the power of the blues, even when it's being played by four guys from the north side of Dublin.