You’ve probably seen the meme. A guy in a sharp suit ruins the whole look with clunky, square-toed loafers that look like he borrowed them from a 1990s IT consultant. Or maybe you've seen the opposite: someone wearing dainty, velvet slippers to a casual brunch. It’s a mess out there. Honestly, choosing from the various types of loafers men wear shouldn't feel like a high-stakes exam, but here we are.
Loafers are the Swiss Army knife of footwear. They bridge the gap between "I'm heading to a board meeting" and "I'm just grabbin' a coffee." But the nuance matters. If you wear a driving shoe with a tuxedo, you'll look like you forgot your real shoes in the car. If you wear a heavy-duty lug sole penny loafer to a wedding, you might look a bit like a confused lumberjack.
Let's break down the actual reality of what’s on the shelves in 2026.
The Penny Loafer: The One That Started the Fire
This is the OG. G.H. Bass basically invented the modern version back in 1936, calling them "Weejuns" (a nod to Norwegian farm shoes). The defining feature? That little leather strap across the top—the saddle—with a tiny slit. Legend says prep school kids in the '50s tucked pennies in there for emergency phone calls. Whether that’s true or just a great marketing story, the name stuck.
Penny loafers are incredibly versatile. You can go for a classic "beefroll" style—where the leather on the sides of the saddle looks like, well, a beefroll—which is more casual. Brands like Rancourt or Oak Street Bootmakers specialize in this chunky, Americana vibe. On the flip side, you’ve got sleeker, more refined versions from makers like Crockett & Jones or Drake’s. These are the ones you wear with a navy suit when you want to look like you own a villa in Tuscany.
Don’t overthink the socks here. White tube socks with pennies are having a weirdly big "prepcore" moment right now (thanks, Jacob Elordi), but if you aren't a movie star, maybe stick to no-show liners or a solid navy wool sock.
Tassel Loafers: For When You Want a Little Pizzazz
Tassel loafers are polarizing. Some guys think they look like something their grandfather wore to a country club. Others see them as the ultimate "power shoe." Honestly, they're both.
They originated when an actor named Paul Lukas asked two different shoemakers to create a version of a fringed shoe he'd found in Europe. Alden eventually merged the ideas into the tassel loafer we know today. Unlike the penny, the tassel loafer often features a "360-degree" lacing system where the leather lace goes all the way around the heel and ends in the tassels on the vamp.
Why they're great:
- They add texture to a boring outfit.
- They feel more "dressed up" than pennies.
- They look killer with a sport coat and grey flannels.
If you’re worried about looking too old-fashioned, look for a version in dark brown suede rather than shiny oxblood leather. Suede softens the look and makes it feel a lot more approachable for a Saturday night dinner.
The Horsebit (Gucci) Loafer: The Wall Street Uniform
In 1953, Aldo Gucci noticed that everyone was wearing penny loafers but thought they were a bit too "common." He added a metal bit—inspired by a horse’s snaffle—and suddenly, the loafer was a status symbol. By the 1980s, these were the unofficial uniform of Wall Street.
Today, you don't have to be a corporate raider to wear them. While the Gucci 1953 model is the gold standard, plenty of other brands like Ferragamo or Carmina make excellent "bit loafers." They’re inherently dressy because of the hardware.
Kinda weirdly, bit loafers are one of the few slip-ons that people consistently pair with full suits. The metal acts like jewelry for your feet. Just keep the rest of your accessories (watch, belt buckle) in the same metal family—gold with gold, silver with silver—unless you really want to lean into the chaotic-neutral aesthetic.
Venetian and Slipper Loafers: The Minimalist Choice
Venetian loafers are basically what happens when you take a penny loafer and strip away all the bells and whistles. No strap, no tassel, no bit. Just a clean, uninterrupted expanse of leather.
Because they’re so plain, the quality of the leather is everything. If the leather looks cheap, the shoe looks like a house slipper you bought at a drugstore. But in a high-quality calfskin or a rich "rough-out" suede, they’re incredibly elegant. They’re the "quiet luxury" of the shoe world.
Then you have actual slippers. Think velvet or patent leather with a low vamp (that means more of your foot/sock shows). These are strictly for evening wear or "fancy at home" vibes. If you’re wearing velvet slippers to a grocery store, you better be a retired rockstar or someone with a very large inheritance.
Driving Shoes: Not for Long Walks
We need to talk about driving shoes because men keep wearing them incorrectly.
The driving loafer—popularized by Tod’s and their "Gommino" sole—was designed for one thing: driving. The rubber pebbles on the bottom (the "nubs") provide grip on the pedals and protect the heel from scuffing against the floor mat.
✨ Don't miss: Anemone nemorosa: Why This Little Wood Anemone Is Way More Complex Than It Looks
They are soft. Usually unlined. They feel like socks. But here is the catch: those rubber nubs wear down incredibly fast if you walk on concrete all day.
"Driving shoes are the sports cars of the shoe world—great for the experience, terrible for the commute."
If you’re going to buy a pair, brands like Aurélien or M. Gemi offer great value, but keep them for short distances. They’re perfect for a summer road trip or a quick flight where you need to breeze through security.
The Belgian Loafer: The "If You Know, You Know" Shoe
Invented by Henri Bendel in the 1950s, the Belgian loafer is easily identified by the tiny, decorative bow on the front. They usually have a very soft, "sacchetto" construction, meaning they’re flexible and fit like a glove.
For a long time, these were a niche item for the New York upper crust. Now, they’re everywhere. They have a very distinct, dandy-ish silhouette. They aren't for everyone. They're slim, often colorful, and very European. If you want to try them, start with a neutral color like "sand" or "chocolate" suede.
Materials and Soles: The 2026 Reality
It’s not just about the style; it’s about how they’re built. In 2026, we’re seeing a massive shift toward hybrid soles. Brands like Cole Haan and Ecco are putting sneaker-like foam inside classic-looking penny loafers.
Is it "pure"? No. Is it comfortable for a 12-hour workday? Absolutely.
🔗 Read more: The Black Suit Full Body Look: Why Most Guys Still Get It Wrong
If you want something that lasts decades, look for a Goodyear welt. This means the sole is stitched to the upper, not just glued. It allows you to resole the shoe when the bottom wears out. It’s more expensive upfront but cheaper over ten years. If you just want something for a specific wedding and don't care about 2035, a "Blake stitch" or cemented (glued) sole is fine and usually results in a thinner, more flexible shoe right out of the box.
How to Not Look Like a Clown: Quick Styling Rules
Honestly, the biggest mistake is the trouser-to-shoe ratio. Loafers are low-profile. If you wear them with wide, pooling trousers that cover the whole shoe, you look like you have hooves.
- Taper is king: Your pants should ideally hit the top of the shoe or have a very slight "break."
- The Sock Debate: No-show socks are the standard. However, a contrast sock (like white or a bright color) can work if the rest of your outfit is very simple and intentionally "vintage."
- Texture Matching: Suede loafers go with denim, chinos, and linen. Smooth calfskin leathers go with wool trousers and suits. Don't mix them up unless you’re feeling experimental.
Practical Next Steps for Your Wardrobe
If you're looking to start or refresh your collection, don't buy five pairs at once. Start with a dark brown suede penny loafer—it is the single most useful shoe a man can own. It works with jeans, it works with a suit, and it doesn't require the constant polishing that black leather does.
Once you have the brown suede penny, look at a black bit loafer for more formal occasions or a tassel loafer in oxblood for some character. Avoid the ultra-cheap "fast fashion" loafers; they’ll fall apart in three months and give you blisters that will make you swear off the style forever. Stick to heritage brands or specialized modern makers who prioritize construction over logos.
Invest in a shoe horn. Since loafers don't have laces, people tend to "stomp" their way into them, which crushes the heel counter over time. Using a shoe horn keeps the silhouette sharp for years. Also, get some cedar shoe trees. They soak up the moisture (let's be real, your feet sweat in these) and prevent the leather from smelling like a gym locker.