You’re probably looking at your plant right now and calling it a Christmas cactus. Most people do. It’s sitting there in a plastic nursery pot, maybe dropping a few magenta buds on your carpet, and you’re just happy it’s alive. But here’s the thing: there’s a massive chance your plant isn't actually a Christmas cactus. Honestly, about 90% of the plants sold in big-box stores like Home Depot or Lowe’s during the holidays are actually Thanksgiving cacti.
Does it matter? Well, yeah. If you want it to bloom at the right time, you’ve gotta know what you’re working with. These plants aren't even "true" cacti in the way we think of them—no deserts, no sand, no blistering heat. They’re epiphytes. They grow on trees in the Brazilian rainforest.
Let's break down the different types of Christmas cactus and why the nursery industry basically lied to you.
The Big Three: Thanksgiving, Christmas, and Easter
Botanically speaking, we are looking at the Schlumbergera genus. It’s a mouthful. Most enthusiasts just call them "Holiday Cacti." While they look similar at a glance, the differences are etched right into the leaves—or rather, the phylloclades. Those flattened segments aren't actually leaves; they’re stems that photosynthesize.
The Thanksgiving Cactus (Schlumbergera truncata)
This is the one you probably own. It's the most common of the types of Christmas cactus found in commerce because it’s easy to ship and blooms early enough for the peak shopping season. You can tell it’s a truncata because the segments have these sharp, claw-like projections. They look like little crab claws. In fact, some people just call it the Crab Cactus.
The flowers are another giveaway. They grow horizontally. If you look closely at the pollen-bearing parts (the anthers), they are usually yellow. It’s a tough plant. It handles a bit of neglect better than its cousins. But don't expect it to wait until December 25th to show off. These guys usually start popping in November, right around the time you're stuffing a turkey.
📖 Related: Is there actually a legal age to stay home alone? What parents need to know
The True Christmas Cactus (Schlumbergera x buckleyi)
This is the "heirloom" plant. It’s the one your grandmother had that’s been living in the same ceramic pot since 1974. You almost never find these in stores anymore. Why? Because the stems are pendulous. They hang down. That makes them a nightmare to package and ship without breaking segments off.
The edges of the segments on a true Christmas cactus are smooth and rounded. No claws. No sharp points. Just gentle, scalloped ridges. When it finally blooms—usually late December through January—the flowers hang straight down like delicate chandeliers. Unlike the Thanksgiving variety, the anthers on these are typically purplish-pink. It’s a more elegant look, honestly. It’s symmetrical.
The Easter Cactus (Rhipsalidopsis gaertneri)
Now, this one is the outlier. It’s technically a different genus, though scientists keep moving it around. It blooms in the spring. If your "Christmas" plant is suddenly bursting with life in April, you’ve got an Easter cactus. The segments are even more rounded, often with tiny little bristles at the ends. The flowers are totally different, too. Instead of those long, tubular "double" flowers, these look like daisies or stars. They only open in the bright light of day and close up tight at night.
Why Identification Actually Matters for Care
You might think a leaf is just a leaf. It isn't.
The Schlumbergera truncata (Thanksgiving) and Schlumbergera x buckleyi (Christmas) have slightly different needs when it comes to "setting" their buds. They are thermophotoperiodic. That's a fancy way of saying they need a specific combo of cool nights and long periods of darkness to trigger flowers.
👉 See also: The Long Haired Russian Cat Explained: Why the Siberian is Basically a Living Legend
If you have a Thanksgiving type, it’s a bit more triggered by the drop in temperature. The true Christmas type is more sensitive to the light cycle. If you keep your living room lights on until midnight every night, your true Christmas cactus might never bloom. It needs about 12 to 14 hours of total, uninterrupted darkness. I’m talking "closet dark."
The Mystery of the Yellow Christmas Cactus
For a long time, you could get these plants in red, pink, or white. That was it. Then came 'Gold Charm.' This was a game-changer in the world of types of Christmas cactus. Yellow is a recessive trait in Schlumbergera. Breeding it took years of crossing and back-crossing.
But here’s a weird fact: if your yellow cactus is kept too cool while the buds are forming, the flowers will turn pink. It’s a temperature-sensitive mutation. To keep a yellow cactus truly yellow, you have to keep it above 65°F (18°C) once those tiny buds appear. If you put it in a drafty hallway, you’re going to end up with a muddy, peach-colored mess.
Soil, Water, and the "Forest" Factor
Because these are jungle plants, they hate "cactus soil." If you buy a bag of sand-heavy succulent mix, you're going to kill it slowly. They want orchid bark. They want peat moss. They want to be damp but never, ever soggy.
In the wild, they grow in the crooks of tree branches where rain washes over their roots and then drains away instantly. If you let them sit in a saucer of water, the roots will turn to mush in forty-eight hours. I’ve seen it happen. You’ll see the segments start to wilt and turn purple, and your first instinct will be to water it more. Don't. That purple color is often a sign of stress, either from too much sun or—more likely—root rot.
✨ Don't miss: Why Every Mom and Daughter Photo You Take Actually Matters
Common Misconceptions and Troubleshooting
People freak out when their plant drops its buds. It’s called "bud drop," and it’s the most frustrating thing about owning any of the types of Christmas cactus. Usually, it’s because you moved the pot. These plants are divas. Once the buds are set, they don't want to be rotated, they don't want to be moved to a different room, and they certainly don't want a blast of cold air from the front door.
- Segments falling off? You're likely overwatering or the plant is sitting in a draft.
- Wrinkled leaves? It’s thirsty. Check the soil. If it’s bone dry, give it a soak. If it’s wet, your roots are dead.
- Not blooming? Not enough darkness. Move it to a guest room that no one uses at night.
Expert Tips for Longevity
These plants are incredibly long-lived. There are documented cases of Schlumbergera plants living for over 100 years, passed down through generations. To get yours to that age, you need to stop repotting it every year. They actually prefer to be root-bound. A tight fit in the pot encourages more flowers and less "leafy" growth.
Wait until the plant is literally pushing itself out of the pot before you move it up a size. And when you do, only go one inch wider.
Actionable Next Steps for Your Plant
If you want to master your holiday display, start by identifying what you actually have.
- Check the "teeth" on the segments. If they are pointy, you have a Thanksgiving cactus. If they are rounded, it’s a Christmas cactus.
- Audit your lighting. Starting in October, make sure the plant gets 12+ hours of darkness. A basement or an unused bedroom is perfect.
- Stop fertilizing in late summer. You want the plant to stop growing new segments and start focusing on flower production.
- Check the temperature. Keep the plant around 60-65°F at night during the fall to ensure the buds set properly.
Knowing the specific types of Christmas cactus in your collection changes how you approach the holiday season. It turns a "disposable" grocery store plant into a long-term companion that can outlive your car, your house, and maybe even you. Get the soil right, get the light right, and just leave it alone. Most of the time, that's all it really wants.