You’ve seen the highlights. The 17-catch game against USC that felt more like a glitch in the Matrix than a Big Ten football game. The wildcat snaps where he looked like a 260-pound freight train with a steering wheel. Most people watching the Tyler Warren NFL draft cycle last year saw a guy who just "got open." But if you actually dig into the tape, the story of how he went from a decommitted Virginia Tech quarterback to the 14th overall pick for the Indianapolis Colts is way weirder.
Honestly, he shouldn't have been that good.
Think about it. Most tight ends are either "big receivers" who can't block a middle schooler or "sixth offensive linemen" with bricks for hands. Warren basically decided he didn't care about those labels. He caught 104 passes in 2024. 104! That isn't just a Penn State record; it’s a "you're making the rest of the country look bad" record. He ended up with 1,233 yards and 8 scores through the air, plus another 4 on the ground. He was a John Mackey Award winner for a reason.
Why the League Was Terrified (and Obsessed)
Drafting a tight end in the first round is usually a gamble that makes GMs sweat. For every Brock Bowers, there's a dozen guys who just sort of... exist. But Tyler Warren was different because of the "how."
📖 Related: Indiana University Basketball Score Today: Why Everyone is Looking at Saturday Instead
He played 40-plus snaps at quarterback, wideout, and in the backfield. He even lined up at center once against USC just to mess with their heads before sprinting out for a jump ball. NFL scouts love that kind of versatility, but they also get skeptical. Is he a "Jack of all trades, master of none"?
The Measurables vs. The Reality
When the 2025 draft cycle hit its peak, the "wingspan controversy" started. It sounds silly, but it’s a real thing. Warren is roughly 6-foot-6, but his wingspan is actually shorter than his height. In the scouting world, that’s usually a death sentence for a blocker.
- Height: 6'5.5"
- Weight: 256 lbs
- The "Short Arm" Problem: 31 3/4" arms.
- The Result: He still dominated.
How? Leverage and IQ. Because he grew up as a quarterback at Atlee High School, he sees the field like a play-caller. He knows exactly when a linebacker is leaning the wrong way. He’s not the fastest guy on the field—he won't outrun a corner in a straight line—but his "snappiness" at the top of his routes is top-tier.
The Indianapolis Colts Fit: Why Pick 14?
When Chris Ballard and the Colts took him at 14, people compared him to Dallas Clark. It makes sense. Indianapolis needed a "safety blanket" for Anthony Richardson who could also punish teams in the run game.
Warren didn't just show up to be a decoy. In his rookie 2025 season, he put up 71 catches for 791 yards. For a rookie tight end, those are Pro Bowl numbers (which, by the way, he actually made). He proved that the "TE1" debate between him and Michigan's Colston Loveland was mostly a matter of taste. Loveland was the younger, "higher ceiling" guy, but Warren was the "win now" piece.
What scouts actually said behind closed doors
There’s a bit of a myth that Warren was a perfect prospect. He wasn't. Charlie Campbell and other insiders noted that his blocking technique could be... messy. He’d get his hands too wide. He’d grab. In the Big Ten, he could just overpower people with raw strength. In the NFL? Those are holding penalties.
But his character was off the charts. Coaches at Penn State called him the "ultimate teammate." He was a four-time Academic All-Big Ten guy. You don't have to worry about him missing a meeting or failing to learn the playbook. He's a pro's pro.
The "Berserker" Mentality
He wore No. 44 at Penn State because he idolized John Riggins. You can see it when he runs. He doesn't look for the sideline; he looks for the nearest defender's chest. That's rare for modern tight ends who often play like oversized wideouts. Warren is a "Y" tight end who can actually play in the dirt, even if his arm length says he shouldn't.
Actionable Insights for Future Evaluators
If you're looking for the "next" Tyler Warren in future drafts, stop looking at 40-yard dash times. Start looking at these three things:
- High School Background: Quarterback experience is a massive "cheat code" for tight ends. It gives them a spatial awareness that can't be taught.
- Contested Catch Rate: Warren sat at about 70% in college. If a guy can't separate with speed, he must be able to win the 50/50 balls.
- Positional Fluidity: If a college team is comfortable putting their TE at Wildcat QB or Fullback, it means he has the "functional strength" that translates to the league.
The Tyler Warren NFL draft story is basically a lesson in not overthinking the "limitations." Short arms? Who cares if you catch 100 balls. Not a 4.4 runner? Doesn't matter if you're never covered. He’s now a cornerstone in Indy, and the rest of the league is still wondering how they let a John Mackey winner slide to the middle of the first round.
✨ Don't miss: Finding Radio Florida State Football: How to Never Miss a Kickoff Again
Check the tape from his USC game again. It's the blueprint. If a player can lead his team in receiving while occasionally taking the snap, you don't worry about his wingspan—you just hand him the jersey.
Next Steps for Draft Fans:
Monitor the 2026 tight end class for "converted" athletes like Oregon's Kenyon Sadiq, who are beginning to mirror Warren's "move-TE" versatility. Also, keep an eye on the Colts' offensive scheme in 2026; if Warren's target share stays above 20%, he’s on a trajectory to rival the elite tier of Kelce and Kittle.