The world first met Tyler Goodson as a voice through a speaker—a young, rough-around-the-edges tattoo artist from Woodstock, Alabama. He was the protégé, the surrogate son, and the only person who seemed to truly understand the eccentric brilliance of John B. McLemore. When the podcast S-Town dropped in 2017, it didn't just tell a story. It blew the doors off a small town and turned regular people into global characters overnight.
But fame in a place like Woodstock isn't like fame in Hollywood. There are no red carpets. Just more eyes on your business and more people whispering at the gas station. Tyler Goodson once famously told Esquire that it was "hell being famous without the rich part."
Honestly, he wasn't wrong. While the podcast won Peabodys and broke download records, Tyler stayed in the same town, dealing with the same old "Shit Town" problems, only now they were amplified by the glare of a national spotlight.
The Standoff in Woodstock: A Tragic Final Act
On December 3, 2023, the story of Tyler Goodson reached a violent and heartbreaking conclusion. It wasn't a slow burn or a philosophical debate like the podcast; it was a three-hour confrontation with law enforcement that ended in gunfire.
Police were called to a home in Woodstock after midnight for what was described as a "call for service"—later reported by local outlets as a domestic situation. Tyler barricaded himself inside. According to the Alabama Law Enforcement Agency (ALEA), the situation escalated until Tyler allegedly brandished a gun at officers.
The most chilling part? He posted to Facebook while it was happening.
"Police bout to shoot me down in my own yard," he wrote at 1:39 a.m. It was his final public message. He was shot by officers and later pronounced dead at a hospital at the age of 32. He left behind five children.
Woodstock Mayor Jeff Dodson, who knew Tyler’s family for decades, called it the worst day he’d ever had in office. He was quick to point out that Tyler wasn't just a "character" to the people in Bibb County. He was a father and a friend who struggled with very real demons, including depression.
Why Tyler Goodson’s Story Still Matters
You can’t talk about Tyler without talking about John B. McLemore. Their relationship was the heartbeat of S-Town. John, the clock restorer who hated his town but couldn't leave it, saw something in Tyler. He taught him, worked with him, and—at least according to Tyler—intended to leave him everything.
✨ Don't miss: Rodney Carrington Fred Song: Why This Nonsense Classic Still Works
But John died by suicide before the podcast even aired. He didn't leave a will.
That lack of a legal paper trail triggered a cascade of legal nightmares for Tyler. He was eventually charged with third-degree burglary and theft for taking items from John’s property—items he insisted John wanted him to have. In 2017, he pleaded guilty and received a 10-year suspended sentence with five years of probation.
This is where the ethics of "true crime" and long-form journalism get messy. Brian Reed, the host of the podcast, captured Tyler’s life at his most vulnerable. When the show became a hit, Tyler was essentially trapped in a narrative of his own making, unable to escape the "troubled youth" label that 100 million listeners had pinned on him.
The Reality of "Podcast Fame"
- No Financial Safety Net: Unlike reality TV stars, podcast subjects rarely get paid. Tyler was still working at his tattoo shop, Black Sheep Ink, and doing plant work to get by.
- Legal Scrutiny: The podcast literally documented the "crimes" Tyler was later charged with.
- Mental Health: The loss of John B. McLemore was a massive blow to Tyler, one he arguably never fully recovered from.
The Legacy of Woodstock and "S-Town"
What most people get wrong about Tyler Goodson is thinking he was just a sidekick in someone else's mystery. In reality, he was the living embodiment of the struggle John B. McLemore ranted about. He was a man trying to build a life in a place that felt like it was constantly pulling him under.
The town of Woodstock—population roughly 1,500—is still there. It’s about 35 miles southwest of Birmingham, a quiet place that was never prepared to be the most famous small town in America for a summer.
The tragedy of Tyler's death has renewed debates about media voyeurism. Did the podcast help him, or did it just put a target on his back? There are no easy answers. Some fans feel a deep connection to him, while locals often feel the show exploited their community's worst moments for entertainment.
If you’re looking for a silver lining, it’s hard to find one here. It’s a sad story because it’s a human one. It didn't have a scripted ending or a neat resolution. It ended with a grieving family and a town wondering how things went so sideways.
Moving Forward: What to Do Next
If the story of Tyler Goodson and the ending of S-Town leaves you feeling unsettled, there are a few ways to process it beyond just re-listening to the episodes.
First, consider the impact of mental health in rural communities. Mayor Dodson mentioned that "depression is real," and in places like Woodstock, resources can be scarce. Supporting organizations like the American Foundation for Suicide Prevention or local Alabama mental health initiatives is a way to turn that "voyeurism" into actual help.
Second, if you're a fan of the show, remember Tyler as a father and an artist, not just a voice on a track. He was a talented guy who found himself at the center of a cultural phenomenon he never asked for.
💡 You might also like: James Caan and The Gambler Cast 1974: Why This Gritty Masterpiece Still Stings
Finally, take a look at the legal complexities of "heir property" and the importance of having a will. Much of Tyler’s legal trouble started because John B. McLemore didn't have his affairs in order. It’s a boring, practical lesson, but it’s one that could have changed the entire trajectory of Tyler Goodson's life.