Honestly, if you only look at a box score, you’re missing the point of Tyler Allgeier.
Most people see the "backup" tag next to his name and assume he’s just there to give Bijan Robinson a breather. They see the 2025 season where he averaged 3.6 yards per carry and think he’s slowing down. But the tyler allgeier game log tells a much weirder, much more physical story than just a secondary stat line.
He is essentially the human equivalent of a sledgehammer. While Bijan is the Ferrari weaving through traffic, Allgeier is the guy the Atlanta Falcons bring in when they just want to break the other team's spirit.
The 2025 Season: A Masterclass in the Dirty Work
Looking at the most recent tyler allgeier game log for 2025, you’ll notice a bizarre trend. He had a career-high 8 rushing touchdowns despite having his lowest rushing yardage total since entering the league.
Basically, he became the ultimate "closer."
Take Week 10 against the Colts, for example. He only had 11 carries, but he punched in two scores. Or Week 13 against the Jets, where he managed just 20 yards on the ground but caught two passes for 35 yards and found the end zone. He’s become this touchdown-dependent fantasy enigma, but for the Falcons, he’s the guy they trust when the game is on the line in the red zone.
He played in all 17 games. That’s a theme with him—availability. He’s missed exactly one game in his entire four-year career. In a league where running backs' knees seem to explode if they look at the turf wrong, Allgeier is a tank.
✨ Don't miss: Why the Ravens vs Titans Playoffs 2020 Rematch Was the Most Disorienting Game of the Decade
Highs and Lows of the Recent Campaign
It wasn't all goal-line glory. There were games where he was practically invisible.
- Week 3 vs Panthers: 1 carry for 4 yards. Total dud.
- Week 9 vs Patriots: 2 carries for 6 yards.
- Week 15 vs Buccaneers: 2 carries for 18 yards.
Then, out of nowhere, he’d explode. In Week 16 against Arizona, he tied Bijan Robinson with 16 carries and racked up 79 yards. He has this way of reminding the coaching staff that he’s still that guy who broke the Falcons' rookie rushing record back in 2022. He finished 2025 with 143 carries for 514 yards. Not eye-popping, sure. But those 8 touchdowns? Those are what keep him on the field.
What Most People Get Wrong About His Role
The biggest misconception is that he’s "losing" his job.
He never really had the "lead" job once Bijan arrived, but his efficiency in short-yardage situations is actually why the Falcons' offense stayed functional during their 2025 run. According to tracking data, Allgeier recorded a huge chunk of his yardage after contact. He isn't the guy who is going to outrun a safety for 80 yards. He’s the guy who is going to hit a linebacker so hard the linebacker needs a seat on the bench.
He actually led the team in rushing touchdowns this past year (8) compared to Bijan's 5 on the ground. Think about that. The "backup" is the one getting the high-value touches when they’re five yards from the paint.
The BYU DNA
You sort of have to look at his college days to understand why he plays like this. He was a walk-on at BYU. He actually played linebacker for a while in 2019 because they were short on defensive depth. You can still see that linebacker mentality when he has the ball. He doesn't look for the sideline; he looks for someone to run over.
When he finally moved back to RB full-time in 2020 and 2021, he went nuclear, leading the nation with 23 rushing touchdowns in his final year. That nose for the end zone has translated perfectly to the pros.
The Statistical Breakdown (No Fluff)
Let's talk about the actual career trajectory shown in the tyler allgeier game log over the years.
In 2022, he was the focal point. He ran for 1,035 yards on 210 carries. He was a 5th-round steal.
In 2023, the volume dropped (186 carries, 683 yards) because the Falcons drafted a generational talent in the first round.
In 2024, it stayed steady: 137 carries for 644 yards. He actually improved his yards per carry back up to 4.7 that year.
Then 2025 happened. The YPC dropped to 3.6, but the efficiency inside the 10-yard line skyrocketed.
It’s a fascinating shift. He’s evolved from a "workhorse" into a "specialist."
🔗 Read more: Columbus Crew vs. Atlanta United: Why This MLS Rivalry Just Got Way More Intense
The Impending Free Agency Drama
As of early 2026, Allgeier is hitting the open market.
He’s mentioned in interviews that he’s always viewed himself as a starter. And honestly? He’s right. There are probably 10-12 teams in the NFL right now where he could walk in and be the RB1 in a power-running scheme. The Falcons have some massive contracts looming—Drake London is going to need a bag, and Kyle Pitts is always in the conversation. Keeping a high-end "backup" like Allgeier might be a luxury Atlanta can no longer afford.
If he leaves, some team is going to get a guy with very little "tread" worn off the tires. Since he hasn't been the primary guy for three years, his body hasn't taken the 300-carry-a-season beating that ruins most RBs by age 26.
Why Every Fantasy Manager Hates/Loves Him
If you’ve ever rostered Allgeier, you know the pain. He’ll give you 2 points one week and 18 points the next because he vulture-steals two touchdowns from Bijan. But that’s exactly what makes him valuable in real-world football. He’s the ultimate "insurance policy." If Bijan goes down, the Falcons' playbook doesn't change because Allgeier can handle 20 carries a game without blinking.
What Really Happened in the 2025 Finale
His last game of the 2025 regular season against the Saints was classic Tyler. 7 carries, 16 yards. On paper? Terrible. In reality? He was used specifically to kill the clock in the fourth quarter. He was running into 8-man boxes specifically designed to stop him, just to keep the clock moving so the Saints couldn't get the ball back. Atlanta won 19-17.
That’s the "hidden" value. You don't get fantasy points for "clock killing," but you win NFL games because of it.
Actionable Insights for Fans and Analysts
If you're tracking Tyler Allgeier’s future, here is what you need to watch for:
- Target Share: Watch if his receiving targets increase. He showed flashes in 2023 with a 75-yard screen play, but he only had 14 catches in 2025. If he wants to be a true RB1 elsewhere, he has to prove he’s more than just a thumper.
- Landing Spots: Look for teams with "zone-heavy" schemes. Allgeier is elite at one-cut running. If he lands with a team like the Niners or even the Texans, his stats could triple overnight.
- Durability Metrics: He’s a rare back who finishes runs leaning forward. That means he's almost always gaining an extra 1.5 yards after he's technically been tackled.
Tyler Allgeier is the guy who makes the "pretty" plays possible by doing the ugly work first. Whether he’s in Atlanta or a new city in 2026, the game log proves one thing: he is one of the hardest players in the league to actually bring to the ground.
💡 You might also like: Wade and LeBron Alley Oop: What Really Happened in That Iconic Photo
If you're looking to dive deeper into how his performance impacts specific betting lines or fantasy matchups, you should check out the latest advanced rushing metrics on Next Gen Stats to see his "yards over expected" numbers. They paint a much prettier picture than the raw 3.6 YPC.