Let’s be real for a second. If you’re looking at Tyjae Spears’ final 2025 stat line, you’re probably not impressed. It looks like a classic "post-hype" disaster on paper. A preseason ankle injury that landed him on IR, a month of missed games, and a Tennessee Titans offense that—well, let’s just say they weren’t exactly the 2000 Rams with a rookie quarterback at the helm.
But if you actually watched the games, especially that late-season stretch where the Titans started to find some rhythm, you know the Tyjae Spears fantasy outlook for 2026 is a lot more complicated than a simple "avoid" tag.
Honestly, the fantasy community is basically split into two camps right now. One side sees a guy with no ACL who can't stay on the field. The other side sees the most explosive playmaker in Nashville who just needs the coaching staff to stop "Pollard-ing" the backfield. Both are sort of right, but the truth is usually found in the middle of those extremes.
The 2025 Rollercoaster: What We Actually Learned
Tyjae’s second year was supposed to be the breakout. Then the Titans signed Tony Pollard to a massive deal. Then Spears got hurt in August. It was a mess from the jump.
📖 Related: Why the Dallas Cowboys Helmet Logo Never Actually Changes
When he finally got back on the field in Week 5 against Arizona, he was clearly playing second fiddle. He had 14 rushing yards. That's it. For a few weeks, he was basically a roster clogger. You couldn't start him, but you were terrified to drop him because of the talent.
Then things shifted.
Check out the Week 16 game against Kansas City. The Titans actually won that game 26-9. Spears went off for 52 rushing yards, a touchdown, and 53 receiving yards. That’s over 20 points in PPR leagues. He did that against a Spagnuolo defense that doesn't just hand out yards for free.
Late-Season Usage (Last 4 Games of 2025)
- Touch Distribution: Spears began eating into Pollard’s share significantly by December.
- Efficiency: He averaged 5.5 yards per carry in several mid-season outings, while Pollard hovered around 3.9 for much of the year.
- The Passing Game: He remains one of the elite tackle-breakers in the league. PFF tracked him at 0.55 avoided tackles per reception. That is literally top-of-the-league stuff.
The big takeaway from last year isn't that Spears failed. It’s that the Titans' offense was in a state of total flux. They were transitioning to Cam Ward, their first-overall pick at QB. They fired Brian Callahan mid-season. It was chaos. But in that chaos, Spears proved that when he touches the ball, good things happen.
Why 2026 Is the Real "Make or Break" Year
The Titans are heading into 2026 with a new head coaching search and a clear directive: build around Cam Ward.
For the Tyjae Spears fantasy outlook, this is huge. Ward showed massive growth in the final eight games of 2025, throwing 10 touchdowns to just one interception. When a young QB stabilizes, the check-down back becomes a goldmine. Think back to Austin Ekeler with early Justin Herbert or Alvin Kamara with Drew Brees. Spears has that exact profile. He’s not a "between the tackles" grinder like Derrick Henry was. He’s a space creator.
One major hurdle remains, though: the "No ACL" factor.
It’s the elephant in the room. We saw him miss five games in 2024 and then a chunk of 2025. Is his body holding up? The high ankle sprain from last August wasn't related to his chronic knee issue, but it contributes to the "injury prone" label that is tanking his ADP.
If you're drafting today, you're getting a massive discount because people are scared of the medicals. But in fantasy, we buy talent and path to touches. Pollard isn't getting any younger, and his efficiency took a massive hit last year. The Titans' offensive line also finished near the bottom of the league in run-blocking grades. If they fix even 20% of that line in the draft, Spears' ceiling moves from a Flex play to a high-end RB2.
Tactical Advice for Managers
If you're in a dynasty league, you've probably seen Spears on the trade block. Most managers are willing to move him for a late second-round pick or even a third.
That is a "buy" all day long.
You aren't buying a 300-touch workhorse. You're buying a guy who can give you 150 carries and 60 catches. In PPR formats, that is a weekly starter. The Titans’ schedule at the end of 2025 was actually pretty tough, yet Spears still produced those RB1 weeks when the volume was there.
What to Look For This Offseason
- The Coaching Hire: If Tennessee hires an offensive mind from the Shanahan or McVay tree, buy Spears immediately. Those systems prioritize backs who can win in the passing game.
- Free Agency: If the Titans bring in another veteran "plodder," it actually helps Spears. It means they want Pollard/Veteran to do the dirty work while Spears stays fresh for high-value touches.
- The Knee Updates: Watch for any news about "maintenance" or "swelling." If he enters camp clean, his price will skyrocket by August.
Stop looking at the season totals from last year. They’re a lie. They don't account for the IR stint or the quarterback growing pains. Look at the Weeks 14-16 window where he looked like the best player on the field. That’s the guy you’re drafting.
Go check your league's trade block. If the Spears owner is frustrated by the "down year," offer a mid-round pick and a depth receiver. It’s the kind of move that wins leagues when a player's talent finally aligns with a stable situation.
Next Steps for Your Roster:
Identify the "zero-RB" candidates in your upcoming drafts. Spears fits this perfectly. He will likely be available in the 8th or 9th round of redraft leagues because of the Pollard overlap. Target him as your RB3 with massive upside. If you're in a dynasty format, send out a low-ball offer now before the Titans hire a flashy new head coach who mentions Spears' name in a press conference. Once the hype starts, the window closes.