Honestly, if you grew up in the early 2000s, you probably remember Shante Smith. Vivica A. Fox didn't just play a character; she basically birthed a whole archetype of the "relationship guru" that's still all over TikTok and Instagram today. Two Can Play That Game is one of those movies that feels like a time capsule. It’s got the sharp suits, the flip phones, and that very specific brand of glossy cinematography that defined Screen Gems’ early millennium output. But beyond the nostalgia, there’s something weirdly enduring about the "rules" Shante preaches.
People still talk about this movie. Why? Because dating hasn't actually changed that much, even if the apps have made it way more chaotic. The central premise—that a woman can "program" a man to behave by using a ten-day plan—is objectively wild. It's toxic. It’s hilarious. And, in the context of the film, it’s a brilliant setup for a battle of the sexes that actually gives the male lead, played by Morris Chestnut, some real agency. Usually, in these types of movies, the guy is just a foil. Not here. Keith Powers fights back.
The Shante Smith Method vs. Modern Dating Reality
Shante’s "Ten Day Plan" is the backbone of Two Can Play That Game. She’s the girl all her friends go to for advice. You know the type. She’s got a checklist for everything. When she catches her boyfriend Keith out with another woman (played by Gabrielle Union, who was basically the queen of the "other woman" or "mean girl" roles back then), Shante doesn't cry. She goes to war.
The movie breaks the fourth wall. Shante looks right at us. She explains that dating is a game of power. Most people get this wrong—they think the movie is just a silly comedy. It’s actually a satire of the "Rules" era of dating. In the late 90s and early 2000s, books like The Rules by Ellen Fein and Sherrie Schneider were huge. They told women to be mysterious, never answer the phone on a Friday night, and basically manipulate their way to a ring. Shante is the cinematic embodiment of that philosophy.
But here’s the kicker: the movie eventually admits Shante is full of it.
Why the "Rules" usually fail
Real relationships aren't scripts. In the film, Keith eventually figures out he’s being played. Once the target knows the game, the game is over. That’s the most honest thing the movie says. You can’t "game" your way into a healthy partnership because a partnership requires vulnerability, which is the exact opposite of what Shante teaches. She teaches control.
I think we see this today with the "high value man" or "soft girl" discourse on social media. It's the same thing. Everyone is trying to find a shortcut to avoid getting their feelings hurt. Two Can Play That Game shows that when you treat your partner like an opponent, you both end up losing.
A Cast That Defined a Decade
We have to talk about the cast. This movie is a "who's who" of Black Hollywood in 2001.
- Vivica A. Fox: She was at the height of her powers here. Her delivery is sharp, and she manages to make a somewhat controlling character incredibly likable.
- Morris Chestnut: Keith is charming, but he’s also smart. When he realizes Shante is running "the program" on him, his retaliation is just as calculated.
- Anthony Anderson: He provides the comic relief, but his character also represents the "typical" guy perspective of the era.
- Gabrielle Union: Even in a smaller role as Conny, she’s a scene-stealer. She plays the "threat" with just enough edge.
- Mo'Nique: As Diedre, she is the absolute highlight for many fans. Her "no-nonsense" (and often very loud) advice serves as a contrast to Shante’s polished, corporate approach to love.
The chemistry works because it feels like a real friend group. They’re all sitting in those classic 2000s restaurant booths or lounges, debating the "he-said, she-said" of it all. It’s the kind of dialogue that influenced shows like Girlfriends or even the later Think Like A Man franchise.
The Direct Link to "Think Like A Man"
You can't talk about Two Can Play That Game without mentioning Think Like A Man. Released over a decade later, the latter film is basically the spiritual successor to Shante Smith’s world. Both movies deal with the idea of using a "playbook" to navigate dating.
🔗 Read more: Why Ginuwine When We Make Love is Still the Blueprint for R\&B Slow Jams
In Two Can Play That Game, the playbook is Shante’s own mind. In Think Like A Man, it’s Steve Harvey’s book. The common thread is the belief that there is a secret code to the opposite sex.
Critics at the time, like Roger Ebert, were somewhat lukewarm on the film, often calling it formulaic. But Ebert actually gave it a decent review, noting that the movie has a "warmth" to it. He wasn't wrong. Despite the manipulation, you can tell Shante and Keith actually like each other. That’s the magic trick. If they didn't have chemistry, the movie would just be a story about two people being mean to each other.
The Cinematography of the "Urban Rom-Com"
There’s a specific look to this era. Everything is warm. There are lots of golds, deep oranges, and high-end interiors. Director Mark Brown (who also wrote The Wood) knew how to make middle-class Black life look aspirational and stylish. This wasn't a "struggle" movie. It was about successful people with great jobs—Shante is an advertising executive—trying to figure out their personal lives. That aspirational quality is a huge reason why it’s a comfort movie for so many.
Does the Advice Still Work?
Let's get real for a second. If you tried Shante’s "Ten Day Plan" in 2026, it would probably blow up in your face within 48 hours.
- The "Never let them see you sweat" rule: In the movie, Shante stays perfectly composed. Today, we call that "ghosting" or "breadcrumbing" or "being emotionally unavailable." It usually leads to a block on WhatsApp, not a bouquet of roses.
- The "Make him jealous" tactic: Shante uses a fake suitor to get Keith’s attention. In the age of Instagram, this just looks messy.
- The "Wait for him to call" rule: This is dead. Everyone is online 24/7. If you don't respond, people just assume you aren't interested and move on to the next person in their DMs.
The world moved on, but the desire for a plan hasn't. We still want to feel like we have the upper hand. We still want to believe that if we follow steps A, B, and C, we can guarantee a specific outcome in love.
The Soundtracking of Black Romance
Music is a character in Two Can Play That Game. The soundtrack features artists like Alicia Keys, Musiq Soulchild, and Case. It’s that peak "Neo-Soul" meets "R&B" era. When you hear those tracks, it immediately sets the mood. It grounds the comedy in a vibe that feels soulful and authentic. It’s hard to imagine the movie without that specific sonic backdrop. It’s the sound of a very specific moment in Black culture where the "Urban Rom-Com" was a dominant force at the box office.
Challenging the "Battle of the Sexes" Trope
Some modern viewers find the movie a bit dated because of its rigid gender roles. Shante thinks all men act one way; Keith thinks all women act another. It’s very binary.
👉 See also: The Secret History: Why Donna Tartt Still Owns Your Aesthetic
However, the third act subverts this. Shante loses control of the narrative. Her friends’ lives are a mess. Her own relationship is on the brink. The movie acknowledges that her "expertise" is a facade. There's a moment toward the end where the veneer cracks, and we see that Shante is just as scared of being hurt as anyone else. That vulnerability is what makes the movie more than just a series of sketches. It’s a study of ego.
What most people get wrong
People think the movie is an endorsement of games. It’s actually a cautionary tale about them. The title Two Can Play That Game is a warning: if you start playing, don't be surprised when your partner plays back. And they might be better at it than you are.
Actionable Takeaways for the Modern Viewer
If you’re revisiting this classic or watching it for the first time, here is how to actually apply its "wisdom" (or lack thereof) to your life today:
- Watch for the Satire: Don't take Shante's "Steps" literally. Look at the consequences she faces when she chooses manipulation over communication. Use it as a mirror for your own tendencies to "manage" your partner's reactions.
- Appreciate the Craft: Pay attention to the blocking and the fourth-wall breaks. Mark Brown used these to make the audience an accomplice in Shante’s schemes, which was fairly innovative for a standard rom-com at the time.
- Value Honesty Over Strategy: The movie’s "happy" ending only happens when the games stop. The real "win" isn't getting someone to call you; it's being with someone you don't have to trick into loving you.
- Analyze the Power Dynamics: Notice how the movie handles career success. Shante is a powerhouse in her office, but she feels she has to "shrink" or "strategize" to maintain power in her bedroom. It’s a great starting point for a conversation about why we feel the need to perform in our private lives.
Stop trying to "program" the people you date. It didn't work for Shante Smith in 2001 without a whole lot of unnecessary drama, and it definitely won't work in a world where everyone has a "red flag" radar tuned to the max. Real connection starts where the game ends.