Adrian Monk is a mess. Let’s be real. He’s afraid of milk, ladybugs, and uneven floorboards, yet we spent eight seasons glued to the screen watching him solve murders in San Francisco. When the series wrapped in 2009 (and even after that Peacock movie revival in 2023), it left a "defective detective" shaped hole in our hearts.
People think finding tv shows similar to Monk is just about finding another guy with a badge and a quirk. It’s not. It’s about that specific "Blue Skies" era of television—shows that managed to be cozy, heartbreaking, and genuinely funny all at once. If you’re looking for a replacement that doesn’t feel like a cheap knock-off, you have to look beyond the surface level "obsessive" traits.
The Mentalist vs. Psych: The Big Two
If you haven’t watched Psych, stop reading this and go do it. Honestly. It is the spiritual brother to Monk. While Adrian Monk has actual, debilitating OCD, Shawn Spencer just pretends to be psychic because he’s too lazy to follow police procedure. They both have that "hyper-observational" superpower, though. In fact, the Psych series finale even makes a subtle nod to Monk being in the same universe, implying there’s another "guy" already alphabetizing the pantry at the San Francisco PD.
Then there is The Mentalist. Patrick Jane is basically what happens if Adrian Monk grew up as a con artist and had a lot more charisma. It’s a bit darker. You’ve got the Red John serial killer arc hanging over everything, which gives it a weight that Monk only touched on during the Trudy episodes. But the "case of the week" structure is almost identical. You get a smug, brilliant consultant making the regular cops look like amateurs while he focuses on a speck of dust or a twitch in a suspect’s eye.
💡 You might also like: Songs by Tyler Childers: What Most People Get Wrong
Why Professor T is the British Adrian Monk
If you want something that feels like a literal mirror image, look at the British series Professor T. It stars Ben Miller as Jasper Tempest, a Cambridge criminologist who is—to put it lightly—a lot.
Like Monk, he’s a germophobe. He wears surgical gloves. He has a complicated relationship with his mother. But where Tony Shalhoub played Monk with a sort of frantic, puppy-dog vulnerability, Ben Miller plays Tempest as cold, rigid, and almost robotic. It’s a fascinating contrast. The show even uses surreal musical sequences (mostly Italian opera) to visualize his internal thoughts, which is a neat trick that fans of Monk’s "here's what happened" segments will appreciate. It’s currently heading into its fourth season in 2026, so there is plenty of backlog to binge on PBS or Prime Video.
The New Guard: Elsbeth and High Potential
We are currently in a bit of a "quirky detective" renaissance. For a while, everything was gritty, dark, and set in the rain. Now, we’re getting shows that remember it’s okay to have fun.
📖 Related: Questions From Black Card Revoked: The Culture Test That Might Just Get You Roasted
- Elsbeth: This is a spinoff from The Good Wife, but you don't need to know anything about the original. Elsbeth Tascioni is a high-energy, eccentric lawyer who ends up shadowing the NYPD. She’s the anti-Monk in terms of personality—she’s loud, colorful, and loves everything—but her brain works in that same "wait, why is that cat wearing a sweater?" way that leads to solving the crime.
- High Potential: This one just got a second season renewal. It stars Kaitlin Olson as a single mom with a "high intellectual potential" who goes from cleaning the precinct to solving their toughest cases. It captures that "outsider in the police world" vibe perfectly.
The "Cozy" Factor and Why It Matters
A lot of people forget that Monk was essentially a modern "cozy mystery." It fits in a lineage that goes back to Columbo and Murder, She Wrote. If you liked the "how-catches-who" aspect of Monk, you’ll find that same DNA in Poker Face.
Charlie Cale (Natasha Lyonne) has a "human lie detector" ability. She’s not a cop. She’s just a person on the road who keeps stumbling into murders. It’s directed by Rian Johnson, so it looks like a movie every week, but the heart of it is that same satisfaction of seeing a brilliant person outsmart a villain who thinks they’re the smartest person in the room.
What to Watch Based on Your Favorite Part of Monk
Some people loved the mystery. Others loved the comedy. Here is how to pick your next binge:
👉 See also: The Reality of Sex Movies From Africa: Censorship, Nollywood, and the Digital Underground
- If you loved the assistant dynamic (Sharona/Natalie): Watch Elementary. The chemistry between Jonny Lee Miller’s Sherlock and Lucy Liu’s Joan Watson is the gold standard for the "brilliant wreck and the person who keeps them alive" trope.
- If you loved the "Broken Genius" vibe: Try House, M.D. It’s medical, not criminal, but Gregory House is essentially Sherlock Holmes (or Adrian Monk) if he were a jerk and addicted to Vicodin.
- If you want something light but smart: White Collar. It’s about a con artist helping the FBI. It’s "Blue Skies" TV at its peak—stylish, clever, and very low-stress.
The Reality of OCD Representation
It is worth noting that while we love Adrian Monk, the medical community has some issues with it. Experts from organizations like NOCD have pointed out that the show often treats OCD as a "superpower" or a "quirk" rather than the debilitating disorder it is.
If you’re looking for a show that handles neurodivergence with a bit more modern sensitivity, Will Trent is a great option. The lead character has dyslexia and a traumatic past, but the show treats his adaptations as part of his life, not just a gimmick for a laugh. It’s a bit more "human" in its approach to trauma, even if it lacks the laugh-track energy of early 2000s USA Network.
Your Next Steps
To get started, I'd suggest picking one show based on your current streaming subscriptions:
- On Peacock: Start with Psych or Poker Face. Both are the closest tonal matches.
- On Hulu/Disney+: Check out High Potential or Elementary.
- On Prime Video/PBS: Look for Professor T or the classic Agatha Christie’s Poirot if you want the "fastidious detective" archetype in its purest form.
Don't try to find a perfect clone of Adrian Monk. You won't. Tony Shalhoub's performance is a one-of-a-kind piece of TV history. Instead, look for the shows that capture that specific feeling of a "solved" mystery at the end of an hour, where everything is put back in its place—exactly the way Monk would want it.