You've heard it a thousand times since you were five years old. Usually, it’s a well-meaning relative or a particularly chipper barista telling you to turn that frown upside down. It sounds like the ultimate cliché. It’s the kind of phrase that usually makes people want to roll their eyes rather than actually crack a smile. But here’s the thing: while it sounds like toxic positivity at its peak, there is actually a fascinating, somewhat messy, and deeply researched biological mechanism behind the idea that forcing a facial expression can change your mood.
It’s called the facial feedback hypothesis.
Basically, the theory suggests that your brain isn't just a one-way street. We usually think that we feel happy, and then our brain tells our face to smile. But research implies the street runs both ways. Your facial muscles can actually send signals back to your brain, essentially tricking it into adjusting your emotional state. It's weird. It’s slightly controversial in the world of psychology. And honestly, it’s way more complex than just "cheer up, buttercup."
Where did "Turn That Frown Upside Down" even come from?
We can’t really pin the phrase on one specific person. It’s been part of the American vernacular for decades, showing up in everything from 1920s-era songs to mid-century self-help posters. But the actual concept goes back way further than the catchy rhyme. Even Charles Darwin was obsessed with this. In his 1872 book, The Expression of the Emotions in Man and Animals, Darwin noted that the "free expression by outward signs of an emotion intensifies it." He basically argued that if you let your face go slack or scowl, you’re going to feel worse.
If you repress the frown? You might just feel better.
Fast forward to the late 1980s. A psychologist named Fritz Strack conducted a now-famous study where he had people hold a pen in their mouths. One group held it with their teeth—forcing a sort of "smile" shape—while the other held it with their lips, which created a bit of a "pout." The "teeth" group found cartoons significantly funnier than the "lips" group did. For years, this was the "gotcha" evidence for the facial feedback hypothesis. It proved that even an involuntary muscular movement could shift how we perceive the world.
But science is never that simple. In 2016, a massive attempt to replicate Strack’s study across 17 different labs failed to find the same results. For a minute there, the idea that you could turn that frown upside down was looking like total junk science.
Then came the Many Smiles Collaboration in 2022. This was a huge, global effort involving nearly 4,000 people from 19 countries. They used different methods—some people mimicked photos of actors smiling, while others were told to move specific facial muscles (like the zygomaticus major) without being told they were making a "smile." The results? There was a measurable, albeit small, increase in happiness.
📖 Related: Does Ginger Ale Help With Upset Stomach? Why Your Soda Habit Might Be Making Things Worse
It turns out that while a fake smile won’t cure clinical depression or make a terrible tragedy disappear, it actually does have a tiny, statistically significant impact on your "momentary" mood.
The Duchenne Smile vs. The Botched Grin
Not all smiles are created equal. If you’ve ever seen a corporate headshot where the person looks like they’re being held hostage, you’ve seen a non-Duchenne smile. A real, "genuine" smile is called a Duchenne smile, named after Guillaume Duchenne, a French neurologist who studied facial expressions by literally shocking people’s faces to see which muscles moved.
A Duchenne smile involves two main muscles:
- The zygomaticus major, which pulls the corners of your mouth up.
- The orbicularis oculi, which crinkles the corners of your eyes (the "crow's feet").
When people tell you to turn that frown upside down, they’re usually only thinking about the mouth. But the brain is smarter than that. If you only move your mouth, your brain often recognizes the "fake." It’s the eye crinkle that really triggers the neurological shift. This is why "smizing"—the Tyra Banks term for smiling with your eyes—isn't just a modeling trick. It’s actually how you signal to your own nervous system that things are okay.
Why this isn't just "Toxic Positivity"
We need to address the elephant in the room. There is a very real danger in the "just smile" culture. Psychologists call it Emotional Labor. If you work in retail or hospitality, you know exactly what this is. You’re exhausted, a customer is yelling at you about a coupon, and you have to maintain a "pleasant" expression.
Research from the Pennsylvania State University has shown that people who are forced to fake-smile all day at work—especially when they're feeling negative emotions—actually have a higher risk of burnout and even heavier alcohol consumption after work.
So, when does "turning that frown upside down" actually work, and when is it harmful?
👉 See also: Horizon Treadmill 7.0 AT: What Most People Get Wrong
The difference is intent.
If you are using a smile as a tool for yourself—to nudge your mood slightly higher during a stressful commute or to break a spiral of negative thoughts—it can be a helpful biohack. But if you’re using it to mask deep-seated pain or because society is demanding you perform happiness for others, it’s a recipe for mental exhaustion. You can't just slap a sticker over a "check engine" light and expect the car to fix itself.
The Vagus Nerve and the Physiological Connection
How does a muscle movement actually change your chemistry? It’s not magic; it’s the vagus nerve. This is the longest nerve in your body, running from your brainstem all the way down to your abdomen. It’s the "reset button" for your parasympathetic nervous system—the system responsible for "rest and digest."
When you engage in a full-face smile, you’re potentially stimulating pathways that tell the vagus nerve to chill out. This can lead to:
- Lowered heart rate.
- Reduced cortisol (the stress hormone) levels.
- A slight release of endorphins.
Basically, you’re hacking your body’s stress response. You aren't "lying" to yourself so much as you are giving your nervous system a physical cue that it's safe to relax. It's similar to how deep breathing works. You aren't "happy" just because you took a deep breath, but the physical act of breathing deeply forces your heart rate to slow down, which then makes it easier to feel calm.
Practical Ways to Use Facial Feedback (Without Being Annoying)
If you want to actually use this turn that frown upside down logic in your daily life, you have to do it right. Doing it wrong just makes you feel like a liar.
Try the Chopstick Trick. This is a variation of the Strack study. If you’re feeling incredibly stressed, place a pen or a chopstick horizontally between your teeth. Don’t let your lips touch it. This forces your face into a muscular position that mimics a smile, including the eye-crinkling muscles. Hold it for 60 seconds. It sounds ridiculous. You will look ridiculous. But it’s a controlled way to trigger that facial feedback without the pressure of "trying" to be happy.
✨ Don't miss: How to Treat Uneven Skin Tone Without Wasting a Fortune on TikTok Trends
Another method is Mirror Work. This isn't about affirmations. It's about looking at yourself and intentionally relaxing your forehead and jaw. We carry a massive amount of tension in our brow. By consciously "un-frowning"—releasing the corrugator supercilii (the muscle that scrunches your eyebrows)—you’re sending a signal to your amygdala that the "threat" has passed.
The Social Contagion Factor
There’s another reason why people want you to turn that frown upside down: humans are mirrors. We have mirror neurons that make us subconsciously mimic the expressions of the people we’re looking at. If you’re scowling, the people around you will likely feel a slight uptick in their own cortisol. If you smile, they might mirror it, which then feeds back into their mood, creating a loop.
This doesn’t mean you owe the world a smile. You don't. But it does explain why "service with a smile" became a thing. It’s not just about being polite; it’s about managing the collective nervous system of the room.
What the Critics Say
It’s worth noting that many modern researchers, like Nick Coles of Stanford University, emphasize that the effect of a smile on mood is "small." It’s not a "get out of sadness free" card. If you are experiencing grief or a clinical depressive episode, telling yourself to smile is like trying to put out a forest fire with a water pistol.
Some studies suggest that the effect only works if you actually believe it might. If you’re doing it with a sense of "this is stupid and won’t work," your brain is likely focusing more on the cynicism than the muscular feedback.
Actionable Steps for Real Results
Don't just take the phrase at face value. Use the biology behind it.
- The 60-Second Hold: Next time you're stuck in traffic and feeling your blood boil, try to hold a wide, Duchenne-style smile for one full minute. Watch how your heart rate reacts.
- The Brow Release: Throughout the day, check in on your "resting frown face." Are your eyebrows bunched together? Consciously smooth your forehead. This "negative feedback" (removing a frown) is often more effective than "positive feedback" (adding a smile).
- Acknowledge the Pain First: Before you try to change your expression, acknowledge why you’re frowning. "I'm stressed because of this deadline." Once acknowledged, then use the smile as a physiological tool to lower the stress, not to hide the problem.
- Check Your Eyes: If you’re going to smile, make sure your eyes are involved. Tighten those lower lids. If you only move your mouth, you’re just stretching skin; you’re not triggering the brain.
The idea to turn that frown upside down isn't just some hokey advice from a greeting card. It's a primitive, biological "hack" that connects our facial muscles to our emotional centers. While it won't change your life or solve your bank account balance, it can give you a 3% to 5% boost in your ability to handle a rough moment. Sometimes, in a world that feels increasingly heavy, that tiny percentage is exactly what you need to get through the next ten minutes.
Focus on the physical release of the tension in your face. Let the corners of your eyes crinkle. Don't worry about looking "happy" for the world; just do it to give your nervous system a momentary break from the grind. Small physical shifts lead to small mental shifts, and those shifts add up over time.