You’re staring at your newborn, who was supposed to have that "soft as a peach" skin everyone talks about, but instead, they look like a teenager going through a rough puberty. It’s frustrating. It's also incredibly common. Most parents find themselves scouring late-night forums or Reddit threads the second those tiny red bumps appear on their baby's cheeks. One name that pops up constantly—almost like a cult favorite—is Tubby Todd baby acne solutions, specifically their All Over Ointment.
But does it really do anything?
Neonatal acne affects roughly 20% of newborns. It’s usually hormonal, triggered by lingering maternal hormones or even the baby’s own developing endocrine system. Pediatricians will tell you to leave it alone. "It'll clear up in a few weeks," they say. But when you're looking at those inflamed bumps every day, "waiting it out" feels like an eternity. That’s where the hype around Tubby Todd comes in.
The Science of Baby Acne vs. Heat Rash
Before you slather anything on your kid, you have to know what you’re dealing with. Baby acne (acne neonatorum) usually shows up around week two or three. It looks like small red or white bumps. It's not usually itchy.
On the flip side, you’ve got milia—those tiny pearly white cysts that are basically trapped keratin. Then there’s cradle cap, which is greasy and yellowish. Tubby Todd’s marketing often lumps these together under the umbrella of "sensitive skin issues," but the way the All Over Ointment (AOO) interacts with these conditions varies wildly.
The AOO is essentially a thick, plant-based balm. It uses ingredients like colloidal oatmeal, jojoba esters, and camellia leaf extract. For dry skin or eczema, it’s a powerhouse. For true hormonal baby acne? The results are more anecdotal. Since baby acne is inflammatory and hormonal, rather than caused by bacteria or clogged pores in the traditional adult sense, many experts argue that topical treatments are just "helping the skin stay hydrated" while the hormones balance themselves out.
Why Everyone Is Obsessed With the All Over Ointment
Honestly, the brand has mastered the "cool parent" aesthetic, but the ingredients list is where the actual value lies. Unlike traditional petrolatum-based ointments (looking at you, Aquaphor), Tubby Todd feels less like axle grease and more like a high-end face cream.
- Colloidal Oatmeal: This is the heavy hitter. It’s FDA-recognized for skin protection. It creates a barrier that locks in moisture and keeps irritants out.
- Camellia Sinensis (Green Tea) Leaf Extract: This is an antioxidant. It helps soothe redness, which is why parents swear it "cures" acne overnight. It’s likely just reducing the inflammation enough that the bumps look less angry.
- Beeswax and Jojoba: These provide the "slip" and the seal without feeling suffocating.
I've seen parents use Tubby Todd baby acne treatments on everything from drool rash to patches of eczema. The reason it "works" for acne isn't necessarily because it attacks the acne itself, but because it strengthens the skin barrier. A strong barrier means less secondary irritation. If a baby has sensitive skin plus acne, the acne looks ten times worse. By calming the skin, the acne becomes less noticeable.
What the Pediatricians Say
Most doctors are cautious. Dr. Sheila Fallon Friedlander, a pediatric dermatologist, often notes that neonatal acne is self-limiting. You don't need to treat it.
However, there is a psychological component to parenting. We want to do something. If you’re going to use something, it shouldn’t be harsh. You have to avoid adult acne medications—no salicylic acid, no benzoyl peroxide. Those will wreck a newborn's thin skin. Tubby Todd fills a gap because it’s "clean" enough that most doctors won't tell you not to use it, even if they aren't officially prescribing it.
Is it a miracle? No.
Is it better than using a harsh soap? Absolutely.
In fact, the biggest mistake parents make is over-washing. Scrubbing at baby acne makes it flare up. The skin gets dry, the body produces more oil to compensate, and suddenly the "gentle" acne looks like a breakout from a horror movie.
The "Purge" and Real User Experiences
You’ll see some reviews saying it made the acne worse. Usually, that’s not "purging" (babies don't really purge like adults do with Retinol). It’s usually either an allergic reaction to one of the botanical extracts or the ointment is too occlusive for that specific baby’s skin type.
If you see the bumps turning into yellow crusts, that’s not acne anymore—that might be seborrheic dermatitis or even a staph infection. Stop the ointment. Call the doctor.
But for the 80% of parents who see success, the timeline is usually about 24 to 48 hours. The redness fades. The skin texture smooths out. It’s why the "before and after" photos on Instagram are so compelling. It’s not that the hormones disappeared; it’s that the skin stopped being so reactive to them.
🔗 Read more: Your 37 weeks pregnant appointment: What really happens when you’re officially full term
Comparing Tubby Todd to the Alternatives
If you aren't ready to drop $30 on a jar of ointment, you've got options.
- Breast Milk: The "liquid gold" cure. It contains lauric acid, which has antibacterial properties. It’s free. It’s right there. Many moms swear by dabbing a little on the acne.
- Mustela No-Rinse Cleansing Water: Great for keeping the area clean without drying it out.
- Cerave Baby: A more clinical approach with ceramides. It’s cheaper, but lacks the soothing botanicals that give Tubby Todd its "glow."
The reality is that Tubby Todd baby acne results often come down to the specific formulation of their All Over Ointment. It’s thick. It stays put. It doesn't rub off on the bassinet sheet the second you put the baby down.
Does the Price Tag Match the Value?
Let's talk money. It's expensive for a 3.5oz jar.
But a little goes a long way. You aren't frosting a cake; you're dabbing a pea-sized amount on cheeks. One jar can realistically last through the entire newborn phase and well into the toddler "scraped knee" phase.
The brand is also Leaping Bunny certified and made in the USA, which matters to a lot of people nowadays. You’re paying for the sourcing and the lack of synthetic fragrances. Fragrance is the number one enemy of baby acne. If you use a scented "baby" lotion on acne, you're basically pouring gasoline on a fire. Tubby Todd’s fragrance-free approach is a necessity, not a luxury.
Tips for Applying Tubby Todd on Baby Acne
If you decide to go for it, don't just go to town.
- Patch Test First: Put a tiny bit on the baby’s leg. Wait 24 hours. If there’s no redness, you’re good for the face.
- Cleanse Gently: Use lukewarm water. No washcloths—they're too abrasive. Use your hands. Pat dry. Never rub.
- Less is More: Apply a thin layer. If the skin looks "wet" or greasy ten minutes later, you used too much. It should absorb.
- Consistency: Use it twice a day. Once in the morning, once after the evening bath.
When to Worry
Most "acne" is harmless. But if your baby has a fever, if the bumps are oozing, or if the rash is spreading rapidly down the body, that’s not baby acne. That’s a medical situation.
True baby acne is localized to the face, neck, and sometimes the back. It doesn't bother the baby. If they’re scratching at it or acting fussy, it’s likely eczema or a different skin condition that might need a mild steroid cream or an antifungal, not a boutique ointment.
Practical Steps for Clearing Baby Skin
If you’re dealing with a flare-up right now, take a breath. It looks worse to you than it does to the baby.
Start by simplifying. Cut out all scented soaps. Stop using "baby perfume" or scented laundry detergents on your own clothes—remember, the baby’s face is pressed against your shirt half the day.
If you choose to try Tubby Todd baby acne solutions, start with the All Over Ointment on a clean, dry face. Watch the redness. If it’s going to work for your child, you’ll usually see a visible difference in the "angry" level of the red bumps within two days.
If it doesn't work? Don't stress. Your baby's skin is constantly evolving. What works at two weeks might not work at two months. The goal isn't "perfect" skin—it's comfortable, protected skin. Sometimes that means a $30 jar of ointment, and sometimes it just means time and a little bit of patience while those hormones settle down.
- Audit your laundry: Switch to a "free and clear" detergent for everything the baby touches, including your own bedding.
- Monitor the humidity: Dry air makes skin more reactive. A cool-mist humidifier can sometimes do more for baby acne than any cream.
- Keep hands off: It’s tempting to "pick" at the whiteheads. Don't. It leads to scarring and infection.
- Consult a professional: If the acne persists past the 4-month mark, it might be infantile acne (which is different from neonatal acne) and may require a dermatologist's intervention to prevent permanent pitting.