New York City doesn't usually do "natural disaster" anxiety unless it involves a blizzard or a hurricane. You’ve seen the movies. We’ve all watched The Day After Tomorrow or Deep Impact where a wall of water taller than the Empire State Building swallows Manhattan whole. It's great for ticket sales, but for a long time, the idea of a tsunami a New York was treated as pure science fiction.
Then came 2013.
On a clear June day, a six-foot wave slammed into the New Jersey coast and pushed up into New York’s harbors. It wasn't a monster from a film, but it was a "meteo-tsunami," and it caught everyone off guard. It turns out the Atlantic isn't as quiet as we like to think. While the Pacific gets all the credit for seismic drama, the East Coast has its own brand of watery chaos brewing beneath the surface.
The Canary Islands and the "Big One" Theory
If you want to talk about a massive tsunami a New York, you have to look 3,000 miles away at the Cumbre Vieja volcano on the island of La Palma. For years, a specific theory has circulated among disaster preppers and geologists alike. The idea, popularized by Dr. Simon Day and Dr. Steven Ward, suggests that a massive chunk of the volcano’s western flank could collapse into the Atlantic during a future eruption.
Think about dropping a brick into a bathtub. Now make that brick the size of a small mountain.
The model suggests this collapse would trigger a mega-tsunami. In this scenario, waves traveling at the speed of a jet engine would cross the ocean, hitting the Eastern Seaboard within eight to nine hours. By the time it reached the New York coastline, the water could—theoretically—be dozens of feet high.
But here’s the thing: most modern geologists think this is a bit of a stretch. Dr. Bill McGuire and other researchers have pointed out that the flank of Cumbre Vieja is likely to crumble in stages, not one giant block. Instead of a city-leveling wave, you’d get a series of smaller, though still dangerous, surges. It's the difference between a landslide and a slow leak. Still, the risk isn't zero. Nature is weirdly unpredictable.
👉 See also: Ethics in the News: What Most People Get Wrong
Meteotsunamis: The Invisible Threat
We usually think tsunamis come from earthquakes. That’s the "classic" version. But New York is actually more susceptible to something called a meteotsunami. These aren't caused by shifting plates, but by rapid changes in atmospheric pressure.
When a fast-moving storm front hits the shallow water of the continental shelf at just the right speed, it creates a wave that grows as it moves toward the shore. Honestly, it’s a bit of a freak occurrence.
On June 13, 2013, a meteotsunami hit the Jersey Shore and surged into New York Harbor. Over 30 tide gauges recorded the event. While it was only a few feet high, the force was enough to sweep people off a jetty in Barnegat Inlet. It happened on a sunny day with no earthquake in sight. This is the tsunami a New York scenario that keeps the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) awake at night because they are incredibly hard to forecast. You don't get the "receding water" warning sign like you do with seismic waves.
The Hudson Canyon and Submarine Landslides
People forget that New York sits right at the edge of a massive underwater cliff. The Hudson Canyon is basically an underwater Grand Canyon that starts off the coast of the city and plunges into the deep Atlantic.
This is where the real geological danger hides.
Submarine landslides are a massive risk. If an earthquake—even a relatively small one—triggers a collapse of the sediment piled up on the edge of the continental shelf, it pushes a massive volume of water toward the coast. We have historical proof of this in the North Atlantic. In 1929, the Grand Banks earthquake triggered a submarine landslide that sent a 25-foot wave into Newfoundland.
✨ Don't miss: When is the Next Hurricane Coming 2024: What Most People Get Wrong
If a similar slide happened in the Hudson Canyon? The lead time for a tsunami a New York would be minutes, not hours.
Why Manhattan’s Geography Makes it Worse
New York City is basically a collection of islands. That’s a problem. Manhattan is a long, skinny finger of land surrounded by deep channels. When a surge of water enters a narrow space like the East River or the Verrazzano Narrows, the water has nowhere to go but up. It’s called "funneling."
- Battery Park: Low-lying and exposed directly to the harbor.
- The Rockaways: A literal barrier island that takes the first hit.
- The Subway System: A giant, interconnected series of straws ready to suck up sea water.
During Hurricane Sandy, we saw how vulnerable the infrastructure is. The water didn't even have the velocity of a tsunami, and it still paralyzed the city. A true tsunami carries massive debris—cars, shipping containers, pieces of piers—which act like battering rams. The physical impact of the water is often more lethal than the drowning risk itself.
The Fault Lines We Don't Talk About
New York isn't California, but it isn't "dead" either. The 125th Street Fault in Harlem and the 26th Street Fault are real. While they aren't likely to produce a Magnitude 9.0 quake, the East Coast’s crust is older and "colder" than the West Coast’s. This means seismic energy travels much further and more efficiently here.
A moderate quake off the coast could easily destabilize the unstable sediment on the continental slope.
Geologists from the Lamont-Doherty Earth Observatory at Columbia University have spent years mapping these risks. They found that the region has a history of "moderate" quakes every century or so. We’re actually a bit overdue for a shake. While the quake itself might just knock some pictures off your wall, its effect on the ocean floor is the real wild card.
🔗 Read more: What Really Happened With Trump Revoking Mayorkas Secret Service Protection
Is New York Ready?
Sort of.
Following the 2013 meteotsunami, NOAA and the National Weather Service upgraded their buoy systems. The DART (Deep-ocean Assessment and Reporting of Tsunamis) stations are now better at filtering out storm surges from actual wave events. New York City also has the "Know Your Zone" evacuation plan.
But let’s be real. If a massive wave hits during rush hour, evacuation is a pipe dream. The bridges would be gridlocked instantly. The "vertical evacuation" strategy—moving to the upper floors of high-rise buildings—is the only viable option for many. However, that assumes the building's foundation can withstand the lateral force of thousands of tons of moving water. Most modern skyscrapers are designed for wind loads, not water impacts.
Practical Steps and Survival Realities
You can't stop a wave, but you can understand the mechanics of survival in an urban environment. A tsunami a New York wouldn't look like a curling surfer wave; it would look like a rising, churning wall of black sludge and debris.
- Ditch the Car: If a warning is issued, traffic will be your death sentence. Move on foot to higher ground or higher floors immediately.
- The 50-Foot Rule: In New York, "high ground" means getting at least 50 to 100 feet above sea level. This isn't just about the wave height; it’s about the "run-up," where water surges uphill.
- Watch the River: If you see the East River or the Hudson receding unnaturally, exposing the riverbed, you have seconds. Don't go down to look at it. Run.
- Stay Out of Basements: This seems obvious, but many Sandy fatalities occurred in basement apartments. In a tsunami, these become pressurized death traps instantly.
The most effective thing you can do right now is familiarize yourself with the NYC Flood Hazard Mapper. It shows exactly which streets turn into rivers first. Knowledge of your specific block's elevation—whether you’re in Chelsea or the Upper West Side—is the difference between being trapped and being safe.
The Bottom Line on the Risk
The likelihood of a catastrophic, "movie-style" tsunami hitting New York this year is incredibly low. But the risk of a meteotsunami or a landslide-generated wave is a statistical certainty over a long enough timeline. We live on an island at the edge of a deep ocean canyon. Ignoring that is just bad planning.
The Atlantic is waking up, and the geological record shows that New York’s coastline has been reshaped by water many times before. It will happen again. The only question is whether we’ll be looking at our phones or the horizon when it does.
Actionable Next Steps
- Identify your zone: Check the NYC Emergency Management website to see if your home or office is in an evacuation zone. Most of Lower Manhattan and Long Island City are Zone 1.
- Learn the "Natural Warnings": If you feel an earthquake that lasts more than 20 seconds, or see the ocean behave strangely, don't wait for a text alert. The technology often lags behind the physics of the wave.
- Plan for Vertical Evacuation: If you work in a high-rise, identify the highest accessible floor. Ensure you have a "go-bag" at your desk, not just at home, because you spend half your life in the city's most vulnerable areas.
- Monitor NOAA Weather Radio: In the event of a meteotsunami, this is the fastest way to get data that hasn't been filtered through social media or slow-moving news cycles.