It happened fast. On a Wednesday night in late January 2025, the sky over Washington, D.C. turned into a scene of absolute chaos. An American Airlines passenger jet and a U.S. Army Black Hawk helicopter collided mid-air, plummeting into the Potomac River. 67 people died. It was the worst U.S. aviation disaster in over fifteen years, and honestly, the kind of tragedy that usually makes a country go quiet in mourning.
But that’s not what happened this time.
Within 24 hours, President Donald Trump was standing in the White House briefing room. He did the usual stuff first—a moment of silence, some words about a "dark and excruciating night." Then, things took a sharp turn. Without a formal report from the National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) or a single piece of forensic evidence in hand, the president pointed a finger at a very specific culprit.
He said the quiet part out loud: Trump blames DEI for crash possibilities.
The Common Sense Argument
When reporters pushed him on why he was bringing up Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) before the flight recorders were even fully analyzed, Trump’s answer was vintage. "Because I have common sense," he said. Basically, his argument is that the government has spent years prioritizing "identity politics" over raw "brain power."
He specifically targeted the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA). He claimed that under the Biden and Obama administrations, the bar for air traffic controllers was lowered to hit diversity quotas. He even read aloud from a list of "targeted disabilities" found on the FAA website—things like "severe intellectual disability" and "psychiatric disability"—implying these were the people now guiding planes.
It sounds terrifying when you put it like that. Who wants a "psychologically inferior" person (his words, not mine) in the tower when they're flying at 30,000 feet?
What the FAA Actually Does
Here is the thing about that FAA website list: it’s real, but it’s kinda misleading the way it was presented. The FAA does have a "special emphasis" on hiring people with disabilities. However, they aren't putting people with severe intellectual disabilities in the air traffic control tower.
The FAA is a massive agency. They hire thousands of people for everything from accounting and HR to janitorial services and data entry. The rigorous standards for air traffic controllers—including intense psychological screening, medical exams, and the "Aviation Selection and Training Corporation" (AT-SAT) test—haven't actually been scrapped.
👉 See also: How to Check Status of Ballot: What Most People Get Wrong
Elon Musk and the Boeing Connection
You can't talk about this without mentioning Elon Musk. He's been beating this drum for a while, especially regarding Boeing. Remember when that door plug blew off the Alaska Airlines flight in 2024? Musk was all over X (formerly Twitter) saying that when you reward executives for hitting DEI targets instead of safety targets, things start falling apart.
Trump and Musk are basically on the same page here. They see DEI not as a way to find "overlooked talent," but as a "mind virus" that distracts from excellence. On his first day back in office in 2025, Trump signed an executive order to "End Radical and Wasteful Government DEI Programs." He wants to return to what he calls "merit-based hiring."
The "Lowered Standards" Debate
Is there any truth to the idea that standards changed? Well, sort of, but it’s nuanced. Back in 2014, under the Obama administration, the FAA did change how they screened air traffic controllers. They introduced a "biographical assessment."
Critics, including many veteran controllers, hated it. They claimed it filtered out highly qualified graduates from collegiate aviation programs in favor of "off-the-street" hires who checked certain demographic boxes. Trump actually mentioned this, claiming he fixed it during his first term, only for Biden to "lower it" again.
But here is the reality check:
📖 Related: What Time Is It Going to Rain Today: The Mid-January Mess Explained
- The NTSB hasn't found any evidence that a "DEI hire" caused the D.C. crash.
- Understaffing is a much bigger, more documented problem.
- The FAA has been short-handed for years, leading to exhausted controllers working mandatory overtime.
What Really Happened in the Potomac?
While the political firestorm was raging, the NTSB was actually doing the work. Early looks at the data suggest the airspace around Reagan National Airport (DCA) was incredibly congested that night. You had a military helicopter on a training mission flying near the path of a commercial jet.
The "strong opinions" Trump shared—like the idea that the helicopter pilot should have just "stopped very quickly"—don't really square with how physics or aviation works. Helicopters can’t just "stop" like a car when a 100,000-pound jet is coming at them at 150 knots.
The Pushback
Former Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg didn't hold back. He called Trump’s comments "despicable" and pointed out that during the Biden years, there were zero commercial airline crash fatalities despite millions of flights.
The National Air Traffic Controllers Association (NATCA) also weighed in. They basically told everyone to pipe down and wait for the facts. Their take? Speculation hurts the integrity of the investigation and scares the public for no reason.
Actionable Insights: What This Means for You
If you’re reading the headlines and feeling a bit sketched out about your next flight, here are a few things to keep in mind to cut through the noise:
1. Check the NTSB Reports
Don't get your safety data from a press conference. The NTSB is the gold standard. They release a "Preliminary Report" within 15 days of an accident and a "Factual Report" later. If you want to know if there was a controller error, wait for their data.
2. Understand the "Merit" Argument
The debate over DEI isn't going away. In 2026, we’re going to see a massive shift in how federal agencies hire. If you work in a regulated industry, expect "DEI" to be replaced by "Performance-Based Excellence" frameworks. This might change how you're evaluated or hired.
3. Watch the Staffing Numbers
The real danger in the skies right now isn't "woke" policies; it's the fact that we don't have enough people. Keep an eye on FAA funding bills. If the government doesn't hire 3,000+ new controllers soon, "close calls" will keep happening regardless of who is in the White House.
4. Separation of Politics and Safety
Aviation safety has historically been non-partisan. When it becomes a political football, the focus shifts away from technical fixes (like better ground radar or collision avoidance systems) and toward culture wars. Demand that your representatives focus on the technical side of the NTSB findings.
The wreckage has been pulled from the Potomac, but the political fallout is just beginning. Whether or not Trump blames DEI for crash incidents in the future, the standard for "merit" in America is officially under the microscope. We're headed for a period where every mistake in a federal agency will be scrutinized through this lens. Stay focused on the data, not just the "common sense" soundbites.