L.J. Shen is basically the queen of making you hate a man before she makes you ruin your life for him. If you’ve spent any time in the "BookTok" trenches or scrolling through Goodreads looking for a hero who is objectively a terrible person but somehow irresistible, you’ve hit the jackpot with Truly Madly Deeply LJ Shen. This isn't your soft, "let’s hold hands in a meadow" romance. It’s jagged. It’s messy. It’s exactly what Shen fans—the "Shenadians"—crave when they want a story that feels like a bruise you can't stop pressing.
Let's get real for a second.
The romance genre is currently flooded with "sweet" cinnamon roll heroes. While that's fine for some, a huge portion of the reading public wants the villain. They want the guy who doesn't apologize. In this book, we get the story of Arse (yes, that is his name, or rather his nickname) and Everly. It’s part of the Playing with Fire world, and honestly, it might be the most polarizing entry in her recent bibliography.
The Core of Truly Madly Deeply LJ Shen: Chaos in Rome
Most people go to Rome for the pasta and the Colosseum. Everly goes there to escape a life that feels like it’s suffocating her, only to run straight into Arsenio Medici. Arsenio isn't just a "bad boy." That label is too small for him. He’s a product of the Italian underworld, a man who views emotions as a liability and women as temporary distractions.
Shen’s writing style here is punchy. It’s aggressive.
She doesn't waste time with flowery descriptions of the Tiber River unless that river is a metaphor for how deep someone is drowning. The dynamic between Everly and Arsenio works because it’s built on a foundation of mutual destruction. Everly is "good" on the surface, but she’s drawn to the darkness Arsenio radiates. It's that classic trope: the girl who thinks she can fix him versus the man who wants to break her. But Shen flips it.
The prose reflects this tension. You’ll have a paragraph that spans ten lines describing the visceral ache of a heartbreak, followed by a two-word sentence that hits like a physical blow.
He stayed.
That’s the kind of pacing that keeps people reading until 3:00 AM. It's why Truly Madly Deeply LJ Shen consistently ranks high for readers who want "dark contemporary" without crossing the line into full-blown horror. It’s a delicate balance.
Why the "Bully Romance" Tag is Misleading Here
Wait. Is it a bully romance? Sorta.
Arsenio is definitely a jerk. He’s cruel, he’s dismissive, and he uses his power to keep Everly off-balance. However, the nuance that many critics miss is the agency Shen gives her heroines. Everly isn't a doormat. She fights back with a sharp tongue and a stubbornness that matches Arsenio’s ego. This isn't just about one person dominating another; it's a power struggle.
In the broader context of L.J. Shen’s work, like Vicious or The Kiss Thief, this book feels more grounded in its emotional trauma. Arsenio's baggage isn't just a plot device; it’s a character in itself. He’s dealing with the weight of a legacy he didn't ask for, and his lashing out is a defense mechanism. It doesn't excuse him, but it makes him human. People love to hate him, and then they just love him. It’s a weird alchemy that Shen has perfected over dozens of novels.
What Most People Get Wrong About Arsenio and Everly
If you read the one-star reviews on Amazon, you’ll see people complaining that the characters are "unlikable."
That’s actually the point.
Since when did romance characters need to be role models? Truly Madly Deeply LJ Shen explores the "enemies" part of enemies-to-lovers with more sincerity than most. They actually dislike each other. There is genuine friction.
- The "Arse" nickname: It’s polarizing. Some find it cringey; others find it hilarious. It sets the tone for a relationship that is irreverent and lacks the "preciousness" of traditional romance.
- The Setting: Rome isn't just a backdrop. The city’s history—the ruins, the blood, the grandeur—mirrors the relationship.
- The Pacing: The middle of the book slows down to focus on internal monologue, which some find jarring, but it’s where the actual character growth happens.
Honestly, if you want a perfect hero, go read a fairytale. If you want a guy who will make you want to throw your Kindle across the room before you realize you've highlighted half his dialogue, you stay here.
The Evolution of the "Vibe"
Shen’s earlier books were often pure testosterone. They were loud. Truly Madly Deeply feels a bit more atmospheric. There’s a lingering sadness in Everly’s character that resonates with anyone who has ever felt like they were living someone else's life.
"I didn't want a savior. I wanted a witness."
This quote (though I'm paraphrasing the sentiment that echoes through her work) captures the essence of what Everly seeks. She’s not looking for Arsenio to pull her out of the fire; she wants him to stand in it with her. That’s a sophisticated take on romance that moves beyond the "damsel in distress" narrative.
How to Approach This Book if You're New to Shen
If you’ve never read an L.J. Shen book, jumping into Truly Madly Deeply LJ Shen is like jumping into the deep end of a pool without checking the temperature. It’s cold. It’s shocking. But you get used to it.
✨ Don't miss: Characters from The Shining: Why We Can’t Stop Psychoanalyzing the Torrance Family
You have to understand the tropes. This is "Angst" with a capital A.
There will be moments where you think the characters are being toxic. You’re probably right. But in the world of high-intensity contemporary romance, toxicity is often the spice that makes the eventual "Happy Ever After" (HEA) feel earned. When a man like Arsenio finally cracks and shows vulnerability, it carries more weight than a "nice guy" doing something kind. It’s the contrast that sells the story.
Key Themes to Watch For
- Legacy and Expectations: Both characters are running from what their families expect of them.
- The Redemptive Power of Truth: Most of their problems stem from what they won't say. When they finally speak, the world shifts.
- Sensory Writing: Shen is great at describing how things smell, feel, and sound. It makes the Italian setting pop.
The Verdict on the Hype
Is it her best book? That’s subjective. For fans of the Sinners of Saint series, it might feel a little different, maybe a bit more experimental in its emotional arc. But for those who love the Playing with Fire vibe, it’s a natural progression. It’s darker than The Devil Wears Black but perhaps less "high-school drama" than some of her older hits.
The takeaway is simple: L.J. Shen knows her audience. She knows they want the heartbreak. She knows they want the groveling (and Arsenio’s grovel is... significant).
Actionable Steps for Romance Readers
If you're looking to dive into the world of Truly Madly Deeply LJ Shen, here is how to get the most out of the experience without losing your mind:
- Check Your Triggers: This is a Shen book. There will be harsh language, dubious moral choices, and intense emotional conflict. If you prefer "clean" or "sweet" romance, this is not the book for you.
- Read 'Playing with Fire' First: While technically a standalone, the emotional context of the world is much richer if you've read the preceding books. It helps you understand the "flavor" of her storytelling.
- Look for the Subtext: Don't just take Arsenio’s words at face value. He’s an unreliable narrator of his own heart. Pay attention to his actions, especially the small ones he thinks Everly doesn't notice.
- Join the Community: The "Shenadians" on Facebook and Instagram are incredibly active. If you finish the book and need to scream about the ending, there are thousands of people waiting to scream back at you.
- Support the Author Directly: If you enjoy the grit, check out her backlist. Books like Vicious or Sparrow offer a similar "dark hero" energy that has defined her career.
Ultimately, this book is about the messy, inconvenient, and sometimes ugly reality of falling for the wrong person at the right time. It’s not a lesson in healthy dating. It’s a fever dream set in Italy. Enjoy it for the escapism it is, and don't be surprised if you find yourself looking for a flight to Rome—and a guy named Arse—as soon as you hit the final page.