You’ve seen the images. On one side, a young Fidel Castro with his signature beard and piercing gaze. On the other, Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, looking remarkably similar. The trudeau castro side by side comparison has been a staple of internet forums, late-night Twitter threads, and even political rallies for years. It’s one of those things that, once you see it, you can’t really unsee. But how much of this is actually rooted in reality, and how much is just a case of "facial pareidolia" fueled by a very strange geopolitical friendship?
The internet loves a good mystery. Honestly, the visual evidence is the strongest part of the whole theory. When you put photos of the two men at roughly the same age next to each other, the resemblance is striking—the brow line, the nose, the way they hold their expressions. It’s enough to make anyone pause. However, when we move past the pixels and start looking at the calendar, the story gets a lot more complicated.
Where did this theory even come from?
It didn’t start in a vacuum. Most people trace the explosion of the trudeau castro side by side memes back to 2016. That was the year Fidel Castro died. Justin Trudeau, as Prime Minister, released a statement that many found surprisingly warm. He called Castro a "remarkable leader" and mentioned his father’s deep pride in calling Castro a friend. That set the internet on fire.
Critics were baffled. Why was a Western democratic leader praising a communist dictator? From there, the digital detectives went to work. They dug up old photos of Margaret Trudeau, Justin’s mother, in Cuba. They found pictures of Castro holding the Trudeau children.
Then came the "suicide note" hoax in 2018. Reports started circulating that Castro’s eldest son, "Fidelito," had left a note naming Justin Trudeau as his half-brother. It was a wild claim. It was also completely false. No such note ever existed, and Cuban state media never mentioned it. Yet, the seed was planted. Even figures like Donald Trump have recently kept the fire alive, mentioning the theory in interviews as recently as late 2024 and 2025. It’s a story that simply refuses to go away.
🔗 Read more: Mail on Election Day: Why the 8 PM Deadline is More Complicated Than You Think
Doing the math: Why the dates don't work
If you’re looking for a smoking gun, you have to look at the timeline. Justin Trudeau was born on December 25, 1971. For him to be Castro’s son, his mother would have had to meet the Cuban leader sometime in the spring of 1971.
Here is what the historical record actually shows:
- Pierre and Margaret Trudeau married: March 4, 1971.
- Justin Trudeau’s birth: December 25, 1971 (exactly nine months and three weeks after the wedding).
- First official visit to Cuba: January 1976.
Wait. 1976? That’s four years after Justin was born.
To believe the theory, you have to believe in a "secret trip." You’d have to assume Margaret Trudeau slipped away to Havana in the middle of her high-profile honeymoon or shortly after her wedding to a man who was arguably the most famous Prime Minister in Canadian history. At the time, Margaret was 22 and Pierre was 51. They were the "it" couple. Paparazzi followed them everywhere. The idea that she could vanish to a Cold War adversary’s island for a secret tryst without a single person noticing is, frankly, a stretch.
Experts like Robert Wright, who wrote Three Nights in Havana, have pointed out that while the Trudeaus and Castro became incredibly close, that bond was forged during that 1976 visit. That was the trip where the famous photo of Castro holding baby Michel Trudeau was taken. Michel was the youngest, not Justin.
The "Uncle Fidel" connection
So, if they aren't father and son, why were they so close? That part is actually true. Pierre Trudeau was a bit of a rebel in the Western world. He wanted Canada to have its own independent foreign policy, which meant making friends with people the United States didn't like.
He and Castro hit it off intellectually. They were both highly educated, arrogant, and loved to argue about philosophy. Castro even flew to Montreal in 2000 to be an honorary pallbearer at Pierre’s funeral. That’s a massive gesture of respect.
Justin Trudeau grew up with this. To him, Castro wasn't just a news figure; he was a family friend. When he wrote that eulogy in 2016, he was writing from a place of personal history, which is likely why it sounded so tone-deaf to the rest of the world. He was looking at the man through the lens of his father’s friendship, not necessarily the lens of geopolitical human rights.
Why we want to believe it anyway
Human brains are wired for patterns. We love "what if" scenarios. When you see a trudeau castro side by side image, your brain is doing what it’s supposed to do: finding similarities.
There’s also a political element. If you don’t like Justin Trudeau’s policies, it’s very tempting to link him to a controversial figure like Castro. It’s a way of saying, "See? He’s not one of us." It turns a policy disagreement into a biological destiny.
But biologically, the evidence just isn't there. Justin Trudeau looks a lot like his father, Pierre, when Pierre was younger—slim build, sharp features. He also shares a lot of his mother’s facial structure.
Practical takeaways from the rabbit hole
Looking at these theories can be a fun distraction, but they teach us a lot about how misinformation lives forever on the internet. Here is how to navigate it:
- Check the conception window: Whenever a "secret child" theory pops up, check the birth date against the first known meeting. Usually, that’s where the theory falls apart.
- Visual similarity isn't DNA: Doppelgängers exist. There are people who look like you right now who aren't related to you.
- Consider the source: Most of these claims resurface during times of political tension. That’s rarely a coincidence.
If you’re genuinely interested in the Trudeau-Cuba connection, the best thing to do is read the actual history of Canada-Cuba relations. It’s a fascinating look at how a medium-sized power like Canada played both sides during the Cold War. It’s a story of diplomacy, ego, and a very unlikely friendship between a French-Canadian intellectual and a Cuban revolutionary. You don't need a secret paternity plot to make that story interesting; the reality is already pretty wild.