When a high-profile tragedy hits the headlines, the first place people usually look for answers is the local government. In the case of young Trigg Kiser, that search led straight to the Maricopa County Medical Examiner’s Office. It wasn't because of a mystery or some medical anomaly. Honestly, it was because the public's thirst for details often collides head-on with a family's desperate need for privacy.
Trigg Kiser was only three years old when he passed away in May 2025. He was the son of Emilie Kiser, a massive social media influencer, and her husband, Brady. After a drowning accident in their backyard pool in Chandler, Arizona, the toddler fought for his life in the hospital for six days. He eventually died on May 18.
The story didn't end with the funeral. Because the death involved a child and a drowning, the Maricopa County Medical Examiner became a central figure in the narrative. People weren't just curious; they were relentless.
The Role of the Maricopa County Medical Examiner
Whenever an accidental death occurs, especially involving a minor, the medical examiner is legally required to step in. They perform the autopsy, determine the official cause of death, and file the paperwork that becomes part of the public record.
In Arizona, these records are generally accessible to anyone who asks. That’s the law. But for the Kiser family, this law felt like a secondary trauma. By late May 2025, the City of Chandler and the Maricopa County Medical Examiner had been flooded with over 100 separate public records requests.
📖 Related: The Galveston Hurricane 1900 Orphanage Story Is More Tragic Than You Realized
Journalists, "internet sleuths," and even just curious followers wanted to see the autopsy report. They wanted the police bodycam footage. They wanted the nitty-gritty details of what happened in those few minutes while Brady Kiser was reportedly distracted by the couple's newborn.
Why the Records Mattered
Public records from the medical examiner serve a specific purpose:
- They provide an unbiased, scientific account of a death.
- They confirm the "manner of death" (in this case, accidental).
- They help investigators determine if criminal negligence occurred.
The Lawsuit Against the Medical Examiner's Office
Emilie Kiser didn't just sit back and let the documents go public. She did something relatively rare for a public figure in this situation: she sued.
She filed a legal motion against the City of Chandler and the Maricopa County Medical Examiner to block the release of specific details. Her lawyers argued that the "media frenzy" was infringing on the family's right to grieve privately. It was a classic battle between the public's right to know and an individual's right to privacy.
👉 See also: Why the Air France Crash Toronto Miracle Still Changes How We Fly
The court eventually granted an order to redact parts of the reports. This is why you won't find every single detail of the medical examiner's findings online. The judge recognized that while the fact of the death was public, the gruesome or highly personal details didn't need to be.
The Police Investigation and the "No Charges" Decision
While the medical examiner was handling the physical evidence, the Chandler Police Department was looking at the circumstances.
They eventually recommended that Brady Kiser be charged with a class 4 felony for child abuse. The allegation? Criminal negligence. Police reports suggested he had been distracted—some reports even mentioned a $25 sports bet on a phone—while Trigg was near the pool.
However, the Maricopa County Attorney’s Office (MCAO) had the final say. In July 2025, they announced they would not move forward with charges.
✨ Don't miss: Robert Hanssen: What Most People Get Wrong About the FBI's Most Damaging Spy
They basically said there was "no likelihood of conviction." To win a criminal negligence case, you have to prove a "gross deviation" from what a reasonable person would do. The MCAO decided that a few minutes of distraction, however tragic the result, didn't meet that high legal bar for a felony.
Lessons for Families and Public Figures
This case changed how a lot of people think about the medical examiner and public records. Usually, we think of these offices as just "doing their job," but in the age of viral social media, their files become fuel for the fire.
If you ever find yourself in a situation where a loved one’s records are being sought by the media, you've actually got a few options:
- Seek a Protective Order: Like the Kisers, you can petition a court to seal or redact sensitive autopsy photos or descriptions.
- Understand Your State Laws: Every state is different. Some states, like Florida, have very strict laws (the "Earnhardt Law") that keep autopsy photos private by default. Arizona is much more "open," which is why the lawsuit was necessary.
- Direct Communication: Sometimes, the Medical Examiner’s Office can provide a summary to the media that satisfies the public interest without releasing the full, traumatic file.
The tragedy of Trigg Kiser is a reminder that behind every "medical examiner case" is a family that just wants to be left alone. The legal battle wasn't about hiding the truth; it was about protecting what was left of a family's peace.
If you are following cases like this, it's worth remembering that these records aren't just data points—they are the final chapters of a real person's life. Respecting that boundary is something we're still trying to figure out as a society.
Next Steps for Information:
Check your local state statutes regarding "Public Records Exceptions for Autopsy Reports" to understand what is and isn't private in your area. If you are dealing with a similar privacy issue, consult with a civil litigation attorney who specializes in records redaction.