You remember the trade, right? It was December 2012. The Minnesota Twins sent Ben Revere—the guy who seemingly caught everything in center field—to the Philadelphia Phillies. In return, they got Vance Worley and a lanky, hard-throwing prospect named Trevor May. At the time, May was the Phillies' top prospect. He was supposed to be the next big thing in the rotation.
But if you look back at Trevor May Minnesota Twins history, his path wasn't a straight line. It was messy. It was full of shifts from the rotation to the bullpen, a devastating Tommy John surgery, and a lot of Twitch streaming. Honestly, his Twins tenure is one of the most misunderstood chapters of the team’s recent history.
People tend to remember the ERA. They forget the evolution.
The "Failed" Starter Narrative
When May finally made his debut on August 9, 2014, against the Oakland Athletics, it was... rough. Two innings. Seven walks. Zero strikeouts. You don't see that every day. Most fans wrote him off as another "pitching prospect who couldn't find the zone."
The Twins were desperate for starters back then. They kept trying to make the "Trevor May as a starter" thing happen. In 2015, he actually showed flashes of brilliance in the rotation before being shoved into the bullpen because Ervin Santana came back from a suspension.
It felt like a demotion to him at the time. He said as much. "It's widely assumed that being moved to the bullpen is a demotion," he told reporters back in 2015. But that shift basically saved his career.
He had to learn how to be a "max effort" guy. Instead of pacing himself for six innings, he started letting that 95-97 mph fastball eat in short bursts. The strikeouts started piling up.
Why the 2017 Injury Changed Everything
Just as he was getting comfortable, his elbow gave out. Tommy John surgery in March 2017 wiped out an entire year of his prime. It was a gut punch.
When he came back in 2018, he wasn't the same guy—he was better. He became a high-leverage weapon. In 2019, he posted a 2.94 ERA with 79 strikeouts in 64.1 innings. That's elite. If you were a Twins fan watching those "Bomba Squad" games, you knew that when May came in for the 7th or 8th, the game was usually over.
More Than Just a Pitcher
What makes Trevor May different from your average middle reliever is what he did off the clock.
While most players were playing cards in the clubhouse, May was building a brand. He was a pioneer in the "athlete-streamer" space. He was DJing under the name DJ MAZR. He was streaming Fortnite and Overwatch on Twitch.
Some old-school fans hated it. They thought he wasn't focused. "Why is he playing video games when he should be studying film?" That was the common refrain on Twitter.
The reality? He was studying. He just happened to be one of the first players to openly embrace Statcast data and analytics to fix his own game. He used his tech-savviness to understand why his fastball had "life" and how to optimize his spin rate. He wasn't just playing games; he was building the blueprint for the modern, analytical player.
👉 See also: Why Warriors Highlights Last Night Prove Stephen Curry Still Owns the Fourth Quarter
The Impact of the Pitch Clock
It's weird to think about now, but the pitch clock almost ended his career early. May has been open about his struggles with anxiety. His "routine" on the mound involved taking his time, breathing, and resetting.
When the MLB introduced the pitch clock in 2023, it felt like a personal attack on his mental health. He described it like a guard at a door—his old routine kept the anxiety out. The clock made the guard too slow.
Trevor May Minnesota Twins: The Final Numbers
He eventually left for the Mets in 2021 on a $15.5 million deal, but his identity is still tied to those Minnesota years.
- Strikeout Machine: He finished his Twins career with a K/9 rate consistently north of 10.0.
- The Transition: He went from a struggling starter (7.88 ERA in 2014) to a lockdown reliever.
- The Legacy: He paved the way for the Twins to stop looking for "pitch to contact" guys and start looking for "swing and miss" arms.
He officially retired in late 2023 after a stint with the Oakland A's. He didn't go out quietly, either. He famously ripped A's owner John Fisher on his way out, telling him to "sell the team" during a live stream. It was pure Trevor May: authentic, loud, and tech-integrated.
Actionable Insights for Fans and Players
If you're a young pitcher or a fan trying to understand the modern game, there are three big takeaways from May's time in Minnesota:
- Adaptability is King: Moving to the bullpen isn't a failure. For many, it's the only way to stick in the big leagues.
- Use the Data: May succeeded because he understood why his pitches worked. Don't just throw; know your spin rates and vertical break.
- Build a Brand Early: May is now a successful analyst on Foul Territory and a major YouTuber. He didn't start that after he retired; he started it while he was wearing a Twins jersey.
The Trevor May era in Minnesota wasn't perfect. There were home runs given up at the worst times and frustrating walks. But he was one of the most "human" players to ever wear the pinstripes. He showed that you could be a professional athlete and a massive nerd at the same time—and that being a nerd might actually make you a better pitcher.