If you lived in San Francisco between 2007 and 2016, you know the feeling. It’s that specific, bone-chilling October wind whipping off the Bay while you’re standing on a literal pier, teeth chattering, watching the sun dip behind the Golden Gate Bridge while some indie band plays a synth-heavy set. It was magic. It was also, occasionally, a total disaster.
The Treasure Island Music Festival wasn't just another stop on the bloated summer circuit. It was a boutique experiment. Noise Pop and Another Planet Entertainment basically decided to throw a party on a man-made island with no shade, weird logistics, and a 60-foot Ferris wheel. And for a decade, it worked. People loved it because it felt intimate. No overlapping sets. Just two stages—the Bridge stage and the Tunnel stage—and a lineup that actually felt curated by someone with taste rather than an algorithm.
But then things got weird.
The 2016 Storm and the Beginning of the End
Most people point to 2016 as the year the wheels fell off. It was the tenth anniversary. It should have been a victory lap. Instead, it was a literal hurricane—okay, technically a "Pineapple Express" storm—that turned the festival into a soggy survivalist camp.
I remember the chaos vividly. High winds turned the Ferris wheel into a giant, spinning hazard. Huge chunks of the lineup had to be canceled or delayed. Flight Facilities couldn't play. Duke Dumont was a no-go. Fans were standing in ankle-deep puddles, shivering, waiting for updates that felt like they were being delivered via carrier pigeon. When James Blake finally took the stage, he played a shortened, haunting set in the pouring rain that honestly felt more like a seance than a concert.
The social media backlash was brutal. People wanted refunds. They wanted heads on pikes. The organizers were stuck between a rock and a very wet hard place. Safety is one thing, but when people pay hundreds of dollars to see their favorite artists and end up with hypothermia and a "sorry about that" tweet, it’s hard to win them back. This wasn't just about the rain; it was about the realization that holding a massive event on a salty, exposed piece of land in the middle of the Bay during the transition to winter was, in hindsight, kind of a gamble.
Moving to Oakland and the Identity Crisis
After the 2016 debacle and the massive redevelopment projects starting on Treasure Island itself, the festival had to move. In 2018, it landed at Middle Harbor Shoreline Park in Oakland.
It wasn't the same.
💡 You might also like: Not the Nine O'Clock News: Why the Satirical Giant Still Matters
Middle Harbor is a cool spot, sure. You’ve got the giant shipping cranes that look like AT-ATs from Star Wars looming over the crowd. It’s gritty and industrial. But it lacked that "island" isolation. The Treasure Island Music Festival without Treasure Island felt like a cover band. It was still good—the 2018 lineup with Tame Impala and A$AP Rocky was objectively stacked—but the soul felt a little frayed.
The logistics changed. The commute changed. The "vibes," as much as I hate using that word, were just... off. When the festival announced a "hiatus" in 2019, most of us knew what that actually meant. It’s the same thing it means when a band says they’re going on an indefinite break to work on solo projects. It means it’s over.
Why the No-Overlapping Sets Rule Changed Everything
Let’s talk about why we actually cared about this festival in the first place. Most festivals today, like Coachella or Outside Lands, are a frantic exercise in FOMO. You have to choose between the legacy rock act and the hot new rapper. You spend half your day walking between stages that are a mile apart.
Treasure Island fixed that.
The schedule was staggered perfectly. When the Bridge stage finished, you had five or ten minutes to wander over to the Tunnel stage. You saw every single artist on the bill. Because of this, the festival acted as a tastemaker. You’d go to see The National or LCD Soundsystem, but you’d end up falling in love with a weird opening act like Geographer or Tycho because you had no choice but to listen to them.
It fostered a communal experience. Everyone was seeing the same thing at the same time. When Vampire Weekend played in 2009, the entire island was bouncing in unison. You don't get that at the mega-fests anymore. It’s too fragmented now.
The Legacy of the Lineups
If you look back at the posters from 2007 to 2013 especially, it’s like a time capsule of the "Blog Rock" era. It was the peak of indie dominance.
📖 Related: New Movies in Theatre: What Most People Get Wrong About This Month's Picks
- 2007: Modest Mouse, Thievery Corporation, M.I.A.
- 2010: LCD Soundsystem, Belle & Sebastian, Die Antwoord (before things got weird with them).
- 2014: Outkast (on their reunion tour), Massive Attack, Alt-J.
The festival was also smart about its split. Saturday was traditionally "Electronic/Dance Day," and Sunday was "Indie/Rock Day." It allowed the crowd to shift demographics overnight. Saturday was all neon, glitter, and glow sticks. Sunday was all flannel, craft beer, and quiet contemplation of lyrics. It was a brilliant way to capture two different markets without making them clash.
What Most People Get Wrong About the Cancellation
There’s a common misconception that the rain in 2016 killed the festival. That’s a bit of a simplification. The reality is more boring and more "San Francisco."
The redevelopment of Treasure Island was the real killer. The city has been planning to turn that island into a massive residential and commercial hub for decades. The "shacks" and old naval buildings that gave the festival its character were slated for demolition. The "Great Lawn" was destined to become a construction site.
Add to that the rising cost of production in the Bay Area. Permits, security, transportation (remember the shuttle buses from Bill Graham Civic Auditorium?), and artist fees have skyrocketed. For a mid-sized festival that capped its attendance around 15,000 to 18,000 people, the margins were razor-thin. You can’t survive a "down year" when your overhead is that high and your location is literally being built over.
Can It Ever Come Back?
Honestly? Probably not in the way we remember it.
The festival landscape in 2026 is vastly different than it was in 2007. We’ve seen the "death of the mid-sized festival" across the country. Fans are gravitating toward either the massive, three-day destination festivals or tiny, hyper-niche warehouse shows. The middle ground is a dangerous place to be.
If Treasure Island Music Festival were to return, it would need a new name or a new "hook." The original hook was the island itself. Without that specific geographic identity, it’s just another field with a stage.
👉 See also: A Simple Favor Blake Lively: Why Emily Nelson Is Still the Ultimate Screen Mystery
Actionable Steps for the Modern Festival Goer
While we may never get to ride that Ferris wheel in a gale-force wind again, the spirit of the festival lives on in how we consume live music in the Bay. If you’re looking for that same feeling, here’s how to find it:
Seek out the "No-Overlap" Lineups
Look for boutique festivals that prioritize a single-stream experience. Events like Portola Music Festival (at Pier 80) have captured some of that industrial, "edge of the world" energy that Treasure Island used to own. Portola has even leaned into the weirdness of the San Francisco waterfront in a way that feels like a spiritual successor.
Check the Noise Pop Calendar
Since Noise Pop was one of the original brains behind Treasure Island, their annual Noise Pop Festival in February is your best bet for seeing that "curated indie" vibe. It’s spread across multiple venues, but the DNA is the same.
Embrace the Oakland Shoreline
Don't sleep on Middle Harbor Shoreline Park or the areas around Jack London Square for smaller events. The views are just as good as Treasure Island, and the wind is (slightly) less likely to ruin your life.
Prepare for the Microclimates
If Treasure Island taught us anything, it’s that the Bay Area does not care about your outfit. Always, and I mean always, bring a base layer of merino wool and a windproof shell. Cotton is your enemy when the fog rolls in at 4:00 PM.
The Treasure Island Music Festival was a beautiful, flawed, cold, and loud moment in time. It represented a version of San Francisco that felt creative and adventurous before the tech monoculture really took hold. We might not get the island back, but we can still demand better, more thoughtful lineups from the festivals that took its place.
Support the independent promoters. Go see the bands you’ve never heard of. And maybe, just for old time's sake, wear a hoodie under your denim jacket.