You’ve probably seen the headlines. One day a news outlet is sounding the alarm about a "wave" of people reversing their transitions, and the next, a medical journal says everything is fine. It’s exhausting to keep up with. Honestly, if you're looking for a straight answer on the trans surgery regret rate, you have to wade through a lot of political noise to get to the actual data.
But the data is there. And it's surprisingly consistent.
When we talk about "regret" in a medical context, we aren't just talking about a bad mood or a passing thought. We’re talking about a formal clinical measurement. Most people think regret is this huge, looming shadow over gender-affirming care, but the numbers tell a different story.
The Numbers Nobody Talks About
Let’s get into the weeds. A massive systematic review published in JAMA Surgery and another in Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery (2021) looked at nearly 8,000 patients who had various gender-affirming procedures.
The result? The trans surgery regret rate was roughly 1%.
To put that in perspective, about 14% of people who get knee replacements regret the decision. Roughly 20% of people regret their tattoos. Even more startling? A 2025 study from the University of Wisconsin School of Medicine found that people regret having children (around 13%) significantly more than they regret gender-affirming surgery.
💡 You might also like: Beard transplant before and after photos: Why they don't always tell the whole story
Why is the number so low? It’s not magic. It’s usually because the "gatekeeping"—a term many in the community use for the long hurdles of therapist letters and years of living in a specific gender role—actually works to ensure people are certain before they go under the knife.
It’s Not Always About "Identity"
When someone does regret a surgery, we often assume it’s because they realized they weren’t actually trans. That happens, sure. But it’s only one piece of the pie.
Researchers like Dr. Harry Barbee from Johns Hopkins have pointed out that "regret" is a messy bucket. If a surgeon botches a procedure and the patient ends up with chronic pain or a result that doesn't look right, that patient might mark "regret" on a survey. But they don't regret transitioning; they regret the surgical outcome.
Then there’s the social stuff.
Imagine having a surgery that makes you feel incredible, but then your parents stop talking to you, you lose your job, and you get harassed at the grocery store. Some people report regret because the social cost of being trans was higher than they anticipated. In a 2022 study of detransitioners, about 82.5% of people who stopped or reversed their transition cited external factors like pressure from family or lack of money—not a change in their gender identity.
📖 Related: Anal sex and farts: Why it happens and how to handle the awkwardness
Understanding the "Detransition" Distinctions
It's kinda vital to separate detransition from the trans surgery regret rate. They aren't the same thing.
Detransition is an action—stopping hormones or living as your birth sex again. Regret is a feeling. You can detransition because you can’t afford testosterone anymore, but still feel like the transition was the right move at the time. Conversely, you can stay transitioned but deeply regret a specific surgery because of complications.
The Real Risks
None of this is to say the risk is zero. It’s not. For that 1% of people, the experience is often devastating.
- Surgical Complications: Issues like loss of sensation or fistula (in the case of bottom surgery) are real risks.
- Mental Health: Surgery isn't a silver bullet. If someone has underlying trauma that isn't related to gender, surgery won't fix it.
- Isolation: Without a solid support system, the recovery period—which is brutal—can lead to a "post-op dip" in mood that some mistake for permanent regret.
Why the Debate is So Loud Right Now
We’re in 2026, and the conversation hasn't cooled down. If the trans surgery regret rate is objectively lower than almost any other major surgery, why is everyone so worried about it?
Basically, it's a "high-stakes" surgery. Unlike a knee replacement, gender-affirming surgery involves identity, fertility, and sexuality. That makes it a lightning rod for cultural anxiety. When a detransitioner speaks out, their story is powerful and often heartbreaking, which makes it go viral. But from a statistical standpoint, those stories represent a very small sliver of the total population.
👉 See also: Am I a Narcissist? What Most People Get Wrong About the Self-Reflection Trap
Experts from the World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH) emphasize in their Standards of Care Version 8 that the goal isn't to reach a 0% regret rate—that's impossible in medicine. The goal is "informed consent."
Actionable Steps for Those Considering Surgery
If you or a loved one are looking at these numbers and trying to make a decision, don't just look at the 1% or the 99%. Look at the process.
- Find a "High-Volume" Surgeon: Statistics show that surgeons who perform hundreds of these procedures a year have lower complication rates, which directly correlates to lower regret.
- Build a "Recovery Nest": Don't just plan for the surgery; plan for the six months after. Who is bringing you soup? Who can you call when you're feeling low?
- Be Brutally Honest with Your Therapist: If you have doubts, voice them. A good therapist isn't there to stop you; they're there to help you be sure.
- Research "Social Transition" First: Many people find that living as their affirmed gender for a year or two before surgery gives them the clarity they need.
The trans surgery regret rate tells us that for the vast majority of people, these procedures are life-saving and deeply satisfying. But the numbers also remind us that this is a major medical decision that requires a solid foundation of physical and emotional support.
If you're moving forward, focus on the quality of your care team and the strength of your community. Those are the factors that turn a "statistically successful" surgery into a genuinely happy life.