You’d think putting a bunch of reality TV legends in a Scottish castle would be enough drama. But no. The Traitors Season 2 took things to a level of pettiness and strategy that most of us weren't actually ready for. Between the "Peter Pals" and the Bravo-fication of the roundtable, the traitors season 2 elimination order became a chaotic mess of ego and intuition. Honestly, watching Johnny Bananas get taken out first was the ultimate "welcome to the game" moment. It set the tone: nobody is safe. Not the legends, not the loudmouths, and definitely not the ones who think they’re the smartest person in the room.
The Early Bloodbath: Who Went First?
The first few episodes felt like a fever dream. We had the iconic Alan Cumming in his finest capes, while the "gamers" and the "Real Housewives" basically sized each other up like it was the first day of high school.
- Johnny "Bananas" Devenanzio (Faithful): Murdered in Episode 2. This was a statement move by Dan Gheesling. Bananas is a professional winner. You don't let a guy like that hang around. He was out before he could even unpack his bags.
- Peppermint (Faithful): Banished in Episode 2. This one hurt. It was basically a huge misunderstanding over a facial expression. Trishelle Cannatella spearheaded this, and the group followed like sheep.
- Marcus Jordan (Faithful): Murdered in Episode 3. The Traitors knew they had to break up the Larsa/Marcus power couple. Simple as that.
- Maksim Chmerkovskiy (Faithful): Banished in Episode 3. Maks was just too "intense" for the room. He didn't play the social game well, and the Faithfuls got trigger-happy again.
Then there was the Deontay Wilder situation. He didn't get murdered or banished. He just... left. He walked away in Episode 4. The emotional weight of the game—accusing friends of lying—was too much for the champ. It’s a side of the game most people don't talk about. It’s mentally exhausting.
Mid-Season Mayhem and the First Traitor Fall
By the middle of the season, the divide between the "Peter Pals" (led by Bachelor Peter Weber) and the "Leftovers" was a canyon. The traitors season 2 elimination order started to reflect this civil war.
🔗 Read more: The Reality of Sex Movies From Africa: Censorship, Nollywood, and the Digital Underground
- Ekin-Su Cülcüloğlu (Faithful): Murdered in Episode 4. This was the "Slow Death" via the poison chalice. Parvati Shallow pulled it off in plain sight. Brutal.
- Larsa Pippen (Faithful): Banished in Episode 4. Without Marcus, she was a sitting duck. The gamers wanted her gone, and they got their wish.
- Tamra Judge (Faithful): Murdered in Episode 5. Phaedra Parks had to take out one of her own "Bravo sisters" to look less suspicious. It didn't really work.
- Janelle Pierzina (Faithful): Banished in Episode 5. Janelle was the only one brave enough to go for Dan Gheesling directly. She missed, and she paid for it.
The Fall of Dan Gheesling
Episode 6 was the turning point. Dan Gheesling (Traitor) was finally caught. He fell for Peter’s "Shield Trap"—where Peter lied about having a shield to see if the Traitors would try to murder him. Dan took the bait, tried to kill Bergie, and failed. At the roundtable, he tried to throw Phaedra under the bus to save himself. It was a desperate move that ultimately failed. He was banished, and the Faithfuls finally had a win.
The Endgame: Traitors Crumble
Once Dan was gone, the heat stayed on the remaining Traitors. Parvati and Phaedra were basically fighting for their lives every single night.
- Carsten "Bergie" Bergersen (Faithful): Murdered in Episode 8. They finally got him. After he survived the first attempt thanks to the shield, his luck ran out.
- Parvati Shallow (Traitor): Banished in Episode 8. The "Ice Queen" of Survivor couldn't outrun the "Peter Pals" forever. She went down fighting, but she went down.
- Kevin Kreider (Faithful): Murdered in Episode 9. After Parvati left, Phaedra recruited Kate Chastain as a Traitor. Their first move? Getting rid of Kevin.
- Peter Weber (Faithful): Banished in Episode 10. This was the most frustrating exit for many fans. Peter was right about everyone, but his arrogance turned the house against him. Phaedra survived this vote by the skin of her teeth.
- John Bercow (Faithful): Murdered in Episode 10. The Traitors took out the most eloquent man in the room.
Phaedra’s Final Stand
Phaedra Parks (Traitor) was eventually banished in Episode 10. She was a legendary Traitor, mostly because she was so likable that people didn't want to believe she was "the one." But when she couldn't explain why she didn't murder certain people, the jig was up.
💡 You might also like: Alfonso Cuarón: Why the Harry Potter 3 Director Changed the Wizarding World Forever
The Finale: A "Challenge" Reunion
The finale was essentially an episode of The Challenge. Shereé Whitfield was murdered at the start of Episode 11, leaving the final group to battle it out at the Fire of Truth.
- Sandra Diaz-Twine (Faithful): Banished in Episode 11. She played a "stay in the middle" game that worked until the very last second.
- Kate Chastain (Traitor): Banished in Episode 11. She was the last Traitor standing, but she couldn't convince CT and Trishelle to trust her.
- Mercedes "MJ" Javid (Faithful): Banished in Episode 11. This was the most heartbreaking part. CT and Trishelle decided they didn't want to split the money with her. They voted her out at the very end to keep the pot for themselves.
The Winners: Chris "CT" Tamburello and Trishelle Cannatella. The two Challenge vets stuck together, played the game like a sport, and walked away with the entire prize pot as Faithfuls.
What We Can Learn From the Season 2 Order
If you're looking at the traitors season 2 elimination order, the pattern is clear: being right isn't enough. Peter was right, but he was banished. Janelle was right, but she was banished. To win, you have to be right and liked—or at least, you have to be the one holding the most power at the final fire.
📖 Related: Why the Cast of Hold Your Breath 2024 Makes This Dust Bowl Horror Actually Work
If you're planning your own watch party or trying to predict Season 3, keep an eye on the "social shield." It's more important than the physical one. The people who made it to the end weren't necessarily the ones who found the most clues; they were the ones who managed their relationships the best.
Next Steps for Fans:
- Check out the UK or Australian versions of the show; the strategies are wildly different.
- Follow the cast on social media to see the post-game beef, especially between MJ and the winners.
- Rewatch Episode 6 to see the exact moment Dan's game fell apart—it's a masterclass in what not to do as a Traitor.