The offseason is always a wild ride. Fans spend months refreshing Twitter (or X, whatever you call it now) hoping for that one notification that changes a franchise. This winter, the name on everyone’s lips in Ontario was Pete Alonso. The Toronto Blue Jays had the money, they had the need for a massive right-handed bat, and honestly, the fit seemed almost too perfect.
But as we sit here in January 2026, the reality is a bit of a gut punch for the Jays faithful. Pete Alonso didn't pick the Rogers Centre. He headed south to the Baltimore Orioles on a massive five-year, $155 million deal.
It’s one of those moves that changes the entire landscape of the AL East. For the Blue Jays, it’s a "what if" that’s going to haunt them every time the Polar Bear steps into the box at Camden Yards.
The Toronto Blue Jays Pete Alonso Connection: What Really Happened
Let’s be real: the Jays were absolutely in on him. After Bo Bichette declined his qualifying offer and hit the open market, Ross Atkins and the front office were staring at a giant, power-hitting hole in the middle of their lineup.
Reports from insiders like ESPN’s Jorge Castillo suggested that Toronto saw Alonso as the ultimate "Plan B" if they couldn't bring Bo back. The idea was simple. Move George Springer back to the outfield full-time, put Vladimir Guerrero Jr. at first, and let Pete Alonso live in that DH spot or swap with Vladdy occasionally.
Toronto actually expressed interest in Alonso as far back as the 2024-2025 offseason, but that was a weird time. Vladdy’s future wasn't settled yet. Once the Jays locked up Guerrero Jr. to that monster 14-year, $500 million extension in April 2025, the vision for the roster changed.
✨ Don't miss: Lee Roy Selmon Oklahoma Legacy: Why the Gentle Giant Still Matters
Why the Deal Fell Through
Money wasn't the only factor. While the Blue Jays have shown they aren't afraid to spend—look at the $210 million they dropped to land Dylan Cease—the positional fit for Alonso was... well, clunky.
Pete is a first baseman. He can DH, but he’s spent his whole career with the Mets being the guy at the cold corner. In Toronto, that’s Vladdy’s house.
Baltimore, on the other hand, offered him a clear path and a team that is aggressively trying to go from "scary young talent" to "World Series favorite." The Orioles gave him $31 million a year with no opt-outs. It's the highest average annual value (AAV) ever given to a first baseman.
🔗 Read more: Williamsport PA Little League World Series: What Most People Get Wrong
The Stats That Made Toronto Drool
If you look at what Pete did in 2025, you can see why the Jays were willing to ignore the positional logjam.
- Games Played: 162 (The guy is an iron man)
- Home Runs: 38
- RBIs: 126
- OPS: .871
- Batting Average: .272
He’s not just a "three true outcomes" hitter anymore. He actually improved his contact rate last season. For a Blue Jays team that has struggled to drive in runners in scoring position during high-leverage moments, Alonso was the dream.
The AL East Power Shift
By landing in Baltimore, Alonso didn't just stay away from Toronto; he became their problem. The Orioles are basically building a "Monsters of the Midway" style lineup.
The Blue Jays now have to face a division rival that has Alonso, Gunnar Henderson, and Adley Rutschman. That’s terrifying.
Toronto’s strategy has pivoted toward pitching and defense, highlighted by the Dylan Cease acquisition, but the lack of a "cleanup" hitter to protect Vladdy is still the elephant in the room. They’re banking on a resurgent George Springer and internal growth, while the Orioles just went out and bought 40 home runs.
What the Blue Jays Do Now
So, Pete’s gone. He’s already got a bobblehead night scheduled in Baltimore for August 2026. What’s the move for Toronto?
Honestly, the focus has to shift to the bullpen and finding a different kind of right-handed bat. The trade market might be the only way left to find that "difference maker" Atkins keeps talking about. Names like Taylor Ward were floating around, but the Orioles grabbed him too.
The Jays are in a tough spot. They’re a good team—they made a deep run in 2025—but in this division, "good" usually gets you a third-place finish and a Wild Card exit.
Actionable Takeaways for Fans
If you're tracking the Blue Jays' next steps this winter, watch these three areas:
- The Payroll Clearing: Keep an eye on Jose Berrios. There’s a lot of chatter about moving his $67 million remaining contract to free up space for one more big free agent splash.
- The Bullpen Market: With Pete Fairbanks being one of the few high-end arms left, expect the Jays to be aggressive there. They need someone to support Jeff Hoffman.
- The Bo Bichette Factor: If Bo doesn't return, the "Alonso money" has to go somewhere. Whether it's a trade for a shortstop or a high-end outfielder, that cash won't stay in the owner's pocket for long.
The Toronto Blue Jays Pete Alonso saga is officially over, and while it didn't end with a jersey at a press conference in Toronto, it set the stage for one of the most competitive AL East battles we've seen in a decade.