Comparing golfers across different eras is a nightmare. Honestly. How do you stack a guy who played with hickory shafts and gutta-percha balls against a modern athlete with a launch monitor and a titanium driver? You kinda can’t, but we do it anyway. It’s the ultimate bar room argument.
Most people just look at the major count and call it a day. Jack has 18, Tiger has 15, so Jack is better, right? Well, maybe. But then you look at Tiger’s winning percentage or the fact that Bobby Jones retired at 28. It gets complicated fast.
The Immortal Two: Nicklaus and Woods
If you’re talking about the top ten golfers of all time, the conversation starts and ends with Jack Nicklaus and Tiger Woods. It’s like debating Beatles vs. Stones.
Jack Nicklaus is the gold standard for longevity. 18 majors. That’s the number everyone chases. But here’s the stat that actually blows my mind: Jack had 19 runner-up finishes in majors. Nineteen! He was basically a coin flip away from having 30-plus majors. He stayed competitive at the highest level for a quarter-century, winning his final Masters in 1986 at the age of 46.
Then there’s Tiger.
Tiger Woods didn't just play golf; he solved it. From 1997 to 2008, he played a version of the game no one had ever seen. He won 15 majors and tied Sam Snead’s record of 82 PGA Tour wins. His "Tiger Slam" (holding all four major trophies at once) is arguably the single greatest feat in sports history. While Nicklaus had the better "career," Tiger had the higher "peak." If both were at their absolute best on a Sunday at Augusta, most experts—even the old-school ones—would put their money on the guy in the red shirt.
3. Ben Hogan: The Man Who "Invernted" Practice
Ben Hogan was different. He wasn't particularly warm or fuzzy. Players called him "The Hawk" because he just stared people down. After a horrific car accident in 1949 that nearly killed him, doctors said he might never walk again.
💡 You might also like: Por qué los partidos de Primera B de Chile son más entretenidos que la división de honor
He won the U.S. Open 16 months later.
Hogan’s 1953 season is the stuff of myth. He entered three majors—the Masters, the U.S. Open, and the Open Championship—and won all three. He couldn't play the PGA Championship that year because the dates overlapped with the British Open. He probably would’ve won that too. He finished with nine majors, but most purists consider him the greatest ball-striker to ever live.
4. Bobby Jones: The Perpetual Amateur
Imagine being so good at golf that you just... quit. Bobby Jones never turned pro. He was a lawyer who played golf as a hobby. Yet, in 1930, he won the original Grand Slam (U.S. Open, U.S. Amateur, British Open, British Amateur).
He played in 31 majors and won 13 of them. That’s a 42% winning clip.
Then he retired at 28. He went on to found Augusta National and the Masters, just for good measure. Because he retired so young, we’ll never know how many trophies he would’ve racked up, but his dominance in the 1920s was absolute.
The International Legends and The King
5. Gary Player: The Black Knight
Gary Player is the most well-traveled athlete in history. He’s logged over 15 million miles in the air. He was also the first truly global golf star. Player won nine majors and is one of only five men to achieve the career Grand Slam. He was obsessive about fitness way before it was cool, doing finger-tip pushups and squats in hotel rooms. That discipline allowed him to win on the Champions Tour well into his 70s.
📖 Related: South Carolina women's basketball schedule: What Most People Get Wrong
6. Arnold Palmer: "The King"
If this list were about "most important" golfers, Arnie might be number one. He didn't have the major count of Nicklaus (he finished with seven), but he had the "it" factor. He arrived just as television was taking off.
With his hitched-up trousers and go-for-broke style, he made golf cool for the working class. He never won a PGA Championship, which kept him from the career Grand Slam, but his impact on the game’s popularity is immeasurable.
7. Sam Snead: The Sweetest Swing
"Slammin' Sammy" Snead had a swing that looked like it was made of liquid. He won 82 times on the PGA Tour, a record that stood alone for decades until Tiger caught him. Snead won seven majors, but like Palmer, he had a "white whale." He never won the U.S. Open, finishing second four different times.
Rounding Out the Elite
8. Tom Watson: The Links Master
Tom Watson was the only guy who consistently looked Jack Nicklaus in the eye and didn't blink. Their "Duel in the Sun" at Turnberry in 1977 is legendary. Watson won eight majors, including five Open Championships. He almost won a sixth Open at the age of 59 in 2009, losing in a playoff. It would have been the greatest story in sports history.
9. Walter Hagen: Golf’s First Superstar
Before Hagen, pro golfers weren't even allowed in the clubhouse. They were seen as "hired help." Hagen changed that by showing up in a chauffeured limo and dressing like a movie star. He won 11 majors, mostly in the 1920s. He was the king of match play, winning five PGA Championships back when it was a bracket-style tournament.
10. Gene Sarazen: The Squire
Sarazen is the man who invented the modern sand wedge. Think about that next time you splash out of a bunker. He won seven majors and was the first player to complete the modern career Grand Slam. He’s also famous for the "shot heard 'round the world"—a double-eagle on the 15th at Augusta in 1935 that put the Masters on the map.
👉 See also: Scores of the NBA games tonight: Why the London Game changed everything
What Most People Get Wrong About the Rankings
The biggest mistake fans make is comparing major wins without looking at the field depth. In Walter Hagen’s day, half the best players couldn't afford to travel to the British Open. In Tiger’s day, the 100th-ranked player in the world had a sports psychologist and a nutritionist.
Does that make Tiger’s wins more impressive? Probably.
But you also have to credit the pioneers who played with equipment that would make a modern pro weep. If you gave Ben Hogan a modern 460cc driver, he might never have missed a fairway.
The Verdict on Greatness
So, who is the goat? Honestly, it depends on what you value.
If you value the total body of work and consistent excellence over decades, it’s Jack Nicklaus. If you value absolute, terrifying dominance and the lowest scoring averages ever recorded, it’s Tiger Woods.
If you're looking to improve your own game by watching these legends, here are a few actionable takeaways:
- Study Hogan’s Ball Striking: Look at his lead wrist at the top of the swing. It’s bowed, not cupped. That’s the secret to the power fade.
- Emulate Watson’s Short Game: Watson was a wizard around the greens. His "no-nonsense" chipping stroke is much easier to repeat than a modern "flop" shot.
- Adopt Nicklaus’s Strategy: Jack didn't always hit the hero shot. He played to the "fat" part of the green and let others make mistakes.
To really understand these players, don't just look at the stats. Watch the old film. Look at the way they moved. The records tell you what they did, but the film tells you how they changed the world.
The next time you're on the range, try "the secret in the dirt" like Hogan, or visualize the flight like Jack. Golf is a game of ghosts, and these ten are the ones who still haunt the fairways.