Drafting the right team is honestly a nightmare if you’re still looking at total points from last year. Most people just scroll down a list and pick the name they recognize. That’s a mistake. If you want to actually win, you need to stop looking at what happened and start looking at what’s about to happen.
The reality of finding the top players for fantasy football isn't about finding the "best" athletes in a vacuum. It’s about volume, scheme changes, and luck. Mostly volume.
Christian McCaffrey is the obvious king, but even kings get tired. You've probably seen his usage rates under Kyle Shanahan. They are absurd. But when we talk about the elite tier, we’re looking for guys who don’t just score points—they provide a "floor" that keeps you from losing your week when things go sideways.
The Tier 1 Dilemma: Running Backs vs. Wide Receivers
There used to be this rule: draft a running back first. Period. No questions asked.
That rule is dead.
In 2024 and 2025, we saw a massive shift toward "Hero RB" or "Zero RB" strategies because the wide receiver position has become so much more predictable. When you look at the top players for fantasy football, guys like Justin Jefferson and CeeDee Lamb are arguably safer bets than any running back not named McCaffrey. Why? Because a receiver doesn't get tackled by 300-pound linemen 25 times a game.
Look at Tyreek Hill. He’s basically a track star playing football. Even as he gets older, his "top speed" remains higher than 90% of the league’s cornerbacks. If Mike McDaniel is calling the plays, Tyreek is getting the ball. It’s that simple.
But then you have the Breece Hall and Bijan Robinson types. These are the "dual-threat" backs. If you aren't drafting a back who catches at least 50 passes a season, you’re playing a losing game. In PPR (Point Per Receptacle) leagues, a five-yard catch is worth more than a nine-yard run. It’s a math problem, not a football problem.
Why Volume Trumps Talent
We love talent. We love watching highlight reels of George Pickens making one-handed grabs. But in fantasy, talent without targets is just a bench warmer.
Amon-Ra St. Brown is the perfect example. Is he the most physically gifted receiver in the NFL? Probably not. But Jared Goff trusts him like a sibling. He’s going to get 10 targets a game. That volume makes him one of the top players for fantasy football regardless of whether he’s "better" than a guy like A.J. Brown.
💡 You might also like: What Channel is Champions League on: Where to Watch Every Game in 2026
You want the "boring" players who get consistent work.
The Quarterback Revolution: Running is the Cheat Code
If your quarterback doesn't run, he better throw for 5,000 yards.
Seriously.
The gap between a "pocket passer" like Kirk Cousins and a "dual-threat" like Josh Allen is massive. Think about it this way: a passing touchdown is usually worth 4 points. A rushing touchdown is worth 6. Every 10 yards rushing is 1 point, whereas you usually need 25 yards passing to get that same point.
Lamar Jackson isn't just a quarterback; he's a high-end RB1 who also happens to throw the ball. When you’re hunting for top players for fantasy football, you have to prioritize the legs.
- Josh Allen: The undisputed goal-line back for the Bills.
- Jalen Hurts: The "Tush Push" might be controversial, but it’s a fantasy goldmine.
- Jayden Daniels: The new wave. High rushing floor.
If you miss out on the elite rushing QBs, don’t panic. Just wait. There is almost no difference between the QB8 and the QB14 in most years. Don't reach for Patrick Mahomes just because of the name—he’s a better real-life player than a fantasy one these days because the Chiefs have become a defensive-minded, ball-control team.
Don't Get Fooled by "Strength of Schedule"
People obsess over who plays who in September. It's a waste of time.
NFL defenses change too much from year to year. A "tough" matchup in May might be a "cake-walk" by October because of injuries or coaching failures. Instead of looking at who they play, look at the offensive line.
A great running back behind a bad line is just a guy getting hit in the backfield. Joe Mixon moved to Houston and suddenly looked rejuvenated. Was it because he got younger? No. It was the scheme and the threat of C.J. Stroud keeping safeties out of the box.
📖 Related: Eastern Conference Finals 2024: What Most People Get Wrong
The "Sophomore Slump" is a Myth
We often hear about players regressing in their second year. Statistics actually suggest the opposite. Year two is usually when the "mental" part of the game clicks.
Garrett Wilson spent his second year catching passes from a rotating door of quarterbacks and still produced. Imagine him with consistent play. When searching for the top players for fantasy football, look for the guys entering year two or three who finally have a stable situation.
Tight Ends: The Wasteland
Let’s be honest. Tight end is a miserable position to manage.
Unless you get Travis Kelce (even with the age concerns), Sam LaPorta, or Trey McBride, you’re basically guessing. You’re praying for a touchdown. Most weeks, your tight end will give you 4 points and you’ll just have to live with it.
The smart move? Either pay the "tax" and draft an elite one early, or wait until the very last rounds and grab a high-upside flyer like Dalton Kincaid. Do not draft a "middle-tier" tight end. They have the same floor as the late-round guys but cost you a much better wide receiver in the draft.
Advanced Metrics That Actually Matter
If you want to sound smart at your draft, stop talking about "yards per carry." It’s a noisy, useless stat.
Look at Target Share.
Look at Air Yards.
Look at Red Zone Touches.
A player who gets 30% of his team's targets is a lock for production. A player who has a high "Air Yards" total but low production is a "buy-low" candidate—it means the opportunities are there, but the connection hasn't happened yet. Eventually, the math evens out.
Take a guy like Chris Olave. The air yards are always there. He’s constantly running deep routes. If the quarterback play improves even 10%, he explodes into the top tier of receivers.
👉 See also: Texas vs Oklahoma Football Game: Why the Red River Rivalry is Getting Even Weirder
Injuries and the "Injury Prone" Label
"I’m not drafting Saquon Barkley, he’s injury-prone."
Every football player is injury-prone. It’s a violent sport.
Labeling someone as "injury-prone" is often just a way for fantasy managers to feel like they have control over a chaotic game. Christian McCaffrey was "injury-prone" until he wasn't. Then he won people championships.
Value the talent. If a player falls in your draft because of an "injury-prone" tag, that’s usually where the value is. You're buying a dollar for seventy-five cents.
Actionable Steps for Your Draft
Success in finding the top players for fantasy football requires a mix of cold logic and a willingness to be wrong. You aren't going to hit on every pick. The goal is to build a roster that can survive the misses.
- Focus on the First Three Rounds: These are your anchors. Do not get "cute" here. Take the guys with the highest projected volume. If you're in a PPR league, prioritize elite WRs or McCaffrey/Hall/Bijan.
- Wait on Quarterback (Mostly): Unless Josh Allen or Lamar Jackson falls past their ADP (Average Draft Position), wait. You can get someone like Jordan Love or Kyler Murray several rounds later and get 80% of the production.
- Stacking is Real: In many formats, pairing your QB with his top WR (e.g., Burrow and Chase) increases your "ceiling." When they have a big game, you essentially get double points for every touchdown.
- The Waiver Wire is the Real Draft: Your team on draft day will not be your team in December. Save your "FAAB" (Free Agent Acquisition Budget) for the first two weeks. That’s when the "league-winners" usually emerge—the backup RB who suddenly gets the starting job or the rookie WR who becomes the primary target.
- Ignore the "Experts" (Sorta): Most rankings are just copies of each other. Use them as a baseline, but if you have a gut feeling about a player's situation—like a new offensive coordinator who loves to throw to the tight end—trust it.
The biggest mistake people make is playing not to lose. They pick safe players with low ceilings. You want the players who can win you the week single-handedly. You want the explosive, high-volume stars who are the focal point of their offenses.
Draft for upside. Manage for consistency.
Keep an eye on training camp reports regarding offensive line injuries and "X" (formerly Twitter) beat writers. They often see who is getting the first-team reps long before the national media catches on. That’s where you find your sleepers. That’s how you win.