When people talk about the "Top Gun" female lead, they're usually looking for one of two names: Kelly McGillis or Jennifer Connelly. It depends on which decade you’re stuck in. But there's a weirdly deep rabbit hole here. The roles they played—Charlotte "Charlie" Blackwood and Penny Benjamin—aren't just romantic interests or window dressing for Tom Cruise’s ego. They’re the emotional scaffolding of the entire franchise. Honestly, without them, Maverick is just a guy with a fast plane and a death wish.
Charlie Blackwood was never just a girlfriend
In 1986, Tony Scott gave us Kelly McGillis as Charlie. She wasn't a "damsel." She was a PhD. She was a civilian contractor and a flight instructor with more technical knowledge than the hotshots she was teaching. Think about that for a second. In the mid-80s, putting a woman in a position of intellectual authority over a room full of alpha-male fighter pilots was a massive swing.
She was based on a real person, too. Christine Fox. Fox was a mathematician and a naval analyst at the Center for Naval Analyses. She eventually became the Acting Deputy Secretary of Defense, which is basically the highest-ranking woman in the history of the Department of Defense. When you watch Charlie dress down Maverick for his "reckless" maneuvers, you aren’t just watching a script; you're seeing a reflection of the actual power dynamics in high-level military strategy.
Kelly McGillis brought a certain gravity to the role. She’s tall, she’s got that husky voice, and she doesn't giggle. She challenges Maverick. She pushes him to be a better pilot, not just a better man. It’s kinda fascinating that she wasn’t brought back for the sequel, a move that sparked a lot of conversation about ageism in Hollywood. McGillis herself was pretty blunt about it, saying she was "old and fat" and looked age-appropriate for her years, which didn't fit the blockbuster aesthetic. It's a tough pill to swallow, but it’s the reality of how the industry handled the transition between the two films.
Enter Jennifer Connelly and the legend of Penny Benjamin
Fast forward to Top Gun: Maverick. We get Jennifer Connelly as Penny Benjamin. If you’re a die-hard fan of the original, that name sounded familiar. Why? Because she’s mentioned in the 1986 film. Go back and listen to Goose and Stinger. They rib Maverick about his "history" with the Admiral’s daughter. That was Penny.
✨ Don't miss: Why the Cast of Hold Your Breath 2024 Makes This Dust Bowl Horror Actually Work
Connelly doesn't play a pilot. She’s a bar owner, a single mom, and a sailor. But she’s the only person in the world who can look Pete Mitchell in the eye and tell him to grow up. She’s his equal in a different way. While Charlie was his intellectual superior in the classroom, Penny is his emotional anchor on the ground. She’s got this "been there, done that" energy that perfectly balances out Maverick’s mid-life crisis.
The chemistry is different this time. It’s more lived-in. More mature. It’s less about the "Take My Breath Away" synth-pop romance and more about two people who have survived the wreckage of their younger selves. Connelly’s performance is subtle, but it works because she doesn't take Maverick's bait. She knows his tricks. She knows he’s going to fly off and do something dangerous, and she refuses to be the woman waiting by the phone with a handkerchief. She’s got her own life.
Monica Barbaro and the shifting cockpit
We can’t talk about the Top Gun female lead without mentioning Natasha "Phoenix" Trace. Played by Monica Barbaro, Phoenix is the first female pilot we see in the inner circle of the Top Gun elite. This was a huge deal for the 2022 film. The production didn't just throw her in for diversity points; they made her arguably the most competent pilot in the squad.
Barbaro actually went through the intense flight training. She was pulling Gs in the back of an F/A-18 Super Hornet just like the guys. There’s a specific grit to her performance. She isn't "the girl pilot." She’s a pilot who happens to be a woman, and that distinction matters. In the final mission, she’s the one Maverick trusts to keep the pace. She’s steady. She’s focused. She’s the professional that Maverick was always too impulsive to be.
🔗 Read more: Is Steven Weber Leaving Chicago Med? What Really Happened With Dean Archer
Phoenix represents the evolution of the Navy. In 1986, women weren't even allowed to fly combat missions. That didn't happen until 1993. So, Phoenix is the literal payoff of the doors that real-life women like Christine Fox helped kick open decades ago.
The controversy of the "missing" lead
There’s no getting around the elephant in the room: the absence of Kelly McGillis in the sequel. Fans were divided. Some felt that replacing the original lead with a "younger" version (Connelly is about 13 years younger than McGillis) was a classic Hollywood trope. Others argued that the story had moved on and that the Penny Benjamin callback was a clever way to bridge the gap between Maverick’s past and present.
Director Joseph Kosinski explained that they didn't want the movie to be a series of "look back" moments. They wanted new characters and a new direction. Whether you buy that or not, it changed the DNA of the franchise. It shifted the focus from a mentor-student romance to a "second chances" narrative.
Why these roles matter for the genre
Action movies used to be notorious for "The Smurfette Principle"—one woman in a group of men, usually there to be rescued or to provide a romantic subplot. Top Gun and its sequel managed to dodge the worst of these clichés. Charlie was a boss. Penny is an independent entrepreneur who doesn't need Maverick’s money or his fame. Phoenix is a literal warrior.
💡 You might also like: Is Heroes and Villains Legit? What You Need to Know Before Buying
They provide the stakes. If Maverick doesn't have a home to return to, or a person who understands his brilliance, the flying is just noise. These women provide the "why." They are the reason Maverick bothers to come back down to earth.
Real-world impact of the female roles
- Recruitment: After the first movie, Navy recruitment went up by 500%. While the pilots got the glory, the depiction of Charlie as a high-level analyst encouraged a generation of women to look at civilian roles within the military.
- Representation: Monica Barbaro’s Phoenix has become a touchstone for young women entering aviation. She’s often cited in interviews by real-life female aviators as a rare example of a Hollywood pilot who "gets it right."
- Cultural Dialogue: The conversation around Kelly McGillis’s absence forced a very public discussion about how Hollywood treats aging women compared to aging men (like Tom Cruise, who seemingly doesn't age).
Navigating the Top Gun legacy
If you're looking to really understand the impact of the female lead in this world, stop looking at them as "the love interest." Start looking at them as the mirror. Every time Maverick is at a crossroads, it’s a woman who points him in the right direction. Charlie tells him he’s a great pilot but a bad team player. Penny tells him he needs to be a father figure to Rooster. Phoenix shows him that the next generation is actually ready to lead.
To appreciate the full scope of these characters, you should:
- Watch the 1986 original with a focus on Charlie’s briefings. Notice how she commands the room without ever raising her voice.
- Re-watch the sequel and pay attention to Penny’s boat. It’s a metaphor for Maverick being out of his element. She’s the captain there. He’s just a passenger.
- Research Christine Fox. Understanding the real woman who inspired Charlie adds a layer of respect to the character that a simple movie watch doesn't provide.
- Follow the careers of the newer cast. Monica Barbaro has been very vocal about the technical challenges of the role, providing a "behind the curtain" look at what it takes to represent female aviators accurately.
The Top Gun universe isn't just about afterburners and aviator sunglasses. It's a study in how leadership and legacy are shaped by the people standing just outside the cockpit. Without the strength and intellect of its female leads, Maverick would just be a lonely guy in a very expensive plane.