Basketball is weird right now. If you're looking at the top 25 ncaa basketball rankings and thinking everything makes sense, you aren't paying attention. Arizona is sitting at No. 1 with 60 first-place votes, but they aren't actually the best team in the country. At least, not according to the math.
We’ve hit that mid-January sweet spot. It’s the part of the season where conference play starts exposing the "pretenders" who feasted on cupcakes in November. This week's AP Poll, released on January 12, 2026, tells one story. The analytics tell another.
The Arizona Mirage and the Michigan Problem
Arizona is 17-0. They’re perfect on paper. Tommy Lloyd has them playing a fast, lethal style of ball that has earned them the top spot in the AP Top 25 for weeks. But here’s the kicker: Michigan—the same Michigan team that just lost to Wisconsin—is still No. 1 in almost every predictive metric.
KenPom loves the Wolverines. Bart Torvik loves the Wolverines. Evan Miyakawa's data suggests they’d beat Arizona on a neutral court tomorrow. Why? Because Michigan has been absolutely vaporizing opponents. Their efficiency ratings are through the roof.
Yet, the human voters dropped them to No. 4 because they finally tripped up. It’s the classic "reward the undefeated" mentality that often clouds what’s actually happening on the hardwood. Honestly, it’s kinda frustrating. If you want to win a bracket in March, you bet on the efficiency of Michigan over the unblemished record of Arizona every single time.
✨ Don't miss: The Division 2 National Championship Game: How Ferris State Just Redrew the Record Books
Why Nebraska is the Story Nobody Expected
If you told me in October that Nebraska would be No. 8 in the country and 17-0 by mid-January, I would’ve asked for a hit of whatever you were smoking.
Fred Hoiberg has finally caught lightning in a bottle. They just jumped two spots after beating Oregon, and they've matched a program-high ranking that hasn't been seen since 1966. They aren't just "lucky," either. They have a narrow win over Michigan State and a statement victory against Illinois. They play gritty, ugly, Big Ten basketball, and it’s working.
Vanderbilt and the "No-Name" Elite
Vanderbilt is currently No. 10. Read that again. The Commodores haven't touched the top ten since the 2011-12 preseason. They are 16-1, and while people are waiting for the floor to fall out, it hasn't happened.
They’re led by guys like Tyler Nickel and Tyler Tanner, names that weren't exactly on the preseason All-American shortlists. They just beat LSU and moved up another spot. They represent the biggest shift in the top 25 ncaa basketball landscape this year: the middle-class uprising.
🔗 Read more: Por qué los partidos de Primera B de Chile son más entretenidos que la división de honor
The Fall of the Blue Bloods
Look at Kansas. The Jayhawks fell out of the poll entirely this week. They were preseason No. 19, fell out in November, clawed back, and then got bounced again after losing to West Virginia.
It’s a bloodbath at the top.
- Kentucky: Unranked in the AP Poll.
- Kansas: Out.
- Duke: Holding steady at No. 6, but they look vulnerable.
- UConn: No. 3, but their loss to Arizona earlier in the year still lingers.
The SEC is arguably the deepest conference, boasting six teams in the rankings, but the Big 12 and Big Ten are the ones with the real quality at the top. Every single Big 12 and Big Ten team in the Top 25 is currently inside the top 15. That is insane.
How to Actually Read the Rankings
Voters are reactionary. They see a "1" in the loss column and they panic. If you're trying to figure out who is actually a Final Four threat, ignore the "Trend" column in the AP Poll.
💡 You might also like: South Carolina women's basketball schedule: What Most People Get Wrong
Virginia is the week's biggest riser, jumping seven spots to No. 16. Ryan Odom has them playing a modernized version of the "Pack Line" defense that actually scores points. They are a "buy low" team right now. On the flip side, Alabama is a "sell high." They dropped five spots to No. 18 after losing to Vanderbilt and Texas. Their defense is, frankly, a sieve right now. They allow way too many high-percentage looks at the rim.
The Mid-Major Sneak Attack
Utah State is sitting at No. 23. They’re 15-1. People usually ignore the Mountain West until the first round of the tournament when a No. 12 seed busts everyone’s bracket. Don’t be that person. Utah State is top-25 in offensive efficiency and they don't turn the ball over.
Actionable Insights for the 2026 Season
If you want to stay ahead of the curve as conference play heats up, stop looking at the AP Poll as a "power ranking" and start looking at it as a "resume ranking."
- Watch the "Others Receiving Votes" list: Saint Louis and Miami (Ohio) are both looming. Miami (Ohio) is 18-0. If they keep winning, the committee won't be able to keep them out of a high seed, regardless of their strength of schedule.
- Factor in the "Portal Chemistry": Teams like Michigan and Arkansas are heavily reliant on transfers. We’re seeing those units finally gel. Arkansas (No. 17) is a much better team today than they were in November.
- Check the NET Rankings: The NCAA selection committee uses the NET, not the AP Poll. As of January 14, Michigan is still No. 1 there. Arizona is No. 2. If there's a huge gap between a team's AP rank and their NET rank, trust the NET.
The most important thing to remember is that the top 25 ncaa basketball list is a living document. By Saturday night, half of these teams will have played games that could flip the script entirely. Arizona goes to UCF. Iowa State travels to Cincinnati. These aren't "gimme" games anymore.
Pay attention to the turnover margins and the Quad 1 win counts. That’s where the real champions are hidden, far away from the hype of a first-place vote.