Football fans love a good fight. Mention the "GOAT" at a bar, and you'll probably get three different names yelled back at you before you can even take a sip of your drink. It’s chaotic. It's subjective. And honestly, it’s why we love the game.
When people talk about the top 100 NFL's greatest players, they usually point to that massive list the league put together for its 100th anniversary. But even that list feels like it’s missing something now. The game has changed so much since the leather-helmet era, and even since the pass-happy 2010s. Trying to rank a guy who played "two-way" ironman football in 1940 against a modern specimen like Patrick Mahomes is basically impossible.
But we do it anyway.
The Unfathomable Dominance of Jerry Rice
Jerry Rice is a freak. I don't mean that in a bad way—I mean his stats look like they were typed in by a kid playing Madden on "Rookie" mode. If you took away every single touchdown he ever scored, he’d still have enough receiving yards to be a Hall of Famer. Think about that.
He played 20 seasons. Most wide receivers are lucky if their knees hold up for eight. Rice finished with 22,895 receiving yards. The guy in second place, Larry Fitzgerald, is more than 5,000 yards behind him. That’s a distance of nearly three miles.
The most impressive part? He did it when defenders were actually allowed to hit you. Today, if a defensive back breathes too hard on a receiver, there’s a yellow flag on the field. Rice played in an era where over-the-middle catches were essentially a suicide mission.
Tom Brady and the Super Bowl Problem
For a long time, Joe Montana was the gold standard. He was 4-0 in Super Bowls. He never threw an interception on the biggest stage. He was "Joe Cool."
Then came the kid from Michigan.
👉 See also: Ohio State Football All White Uniforms: Why the Icy Look Always Sparks a Debate
Tom Brady didn't just break the records; he turned the top 100 NFL's greatest players conversation into a math problem. Seven rings. More than any single franchise in the history of the league. People used to say he was a "system quarterback," but then he went to Tampa Bay at age 43 and won another one just to prove a point.
Honestly, the "Montana vs. Brady" debate is mostly dead at this point. Brady’s longevity is just too stupid to ignore. He’s the all-time leader in passing yards ($89,214$) and touchdowns ($649$). He played until he was 45. Most people his age are struggling to get out of bed without their back popping, and he was out there carving up 22-year-old cornerbacks.
The Defenders Who Changed the Math
We spend way too much time talking about quarterbacks. If you want to talk about players who actually fundamentally changed how the game is played, you have to look at Lawrence Taylor.
Before "LT" arrived in 1981, outside linebackers weren't really expected to be the most terrifying pass rushers on the planet. He changed that. He forced offenses to invent the "one-back" set and move their best blockers to the left tackle spot just to keep their quarterbacks alive.
Taylor is one of only two defensive players to ever win the NFL MVP award. In 1986, he had $20.5$ sacks. He did it with a blend of speed and violence that we haven't really seen since. He didn't just tackle people; he erased them.
Then there’s Reggie White. "The Minister of Defense." He had this move called the "hump move" where he would basically just toss a 300-pound offensive lineman aside like a bag of laundry. He finished with $198$ sacks, and that doesn't even count the years he spent in the USFL.
Why the Old-Timers Still Matter
It's easy to look at a grainy clip of Don Hutson from the 1940s and think, "I could do that." You couldn't.
✨ Don't miss: Who Won the Golf Tournament This Weekend: Richard T. Lee and the 2026 Season Kickoff
Don Hutson was playing a different sport than everyone else. In 1942, he had 1,211 receiving yards. The guy who finished second that year had 584. He literally doubled the production of the next best player in the world. He invented the routes receivers run today—the post, the slant, the out. He was a scientist on the field.
And Jim Brown? Forget about it.
Jim Brown played nine seasons and led the league in rushing in eight of them. He averaged $5.2$ yards per carry for his entire career. He never missed a game. He retired at the absolute peak of his powers to go be a movie star. If he had played five more years, the rushing records would probably still be untouchable today.
The Top 10: A Consensus Guesstimate
If you were to poll 100 experts today, the top of the list usually looks something like this (give or take a few spots):
- Tom Brady (QB): The rings speak for themselves.
- Jerry Rice (WR): The statistical GOAT.
- Lawrence Taylor (LB): The most disruptive force in history.
- Jim Brown (RB): Pure, unadulterated dominance.
- Joe Montana (QB): The original king of the Super Bowl.
- Walter Payton (RB): "Sweetness" could do everything—run, block, catch, and even throw.
- Reggie White (DE): The most technically proficient pass rusher ever.
- Peyton Manning (QB): The smartest man to ever take a snap.
- Don Hutson (WR): The man who invented the modern passing game.
- Dick Butkus (LB): The literal embodiment of "Monsters of the Midway."
What Most People Get Wrong About Rankings
The biggest mistake people make is trying to compare stats across eras. You can't.
In the 70s, a quarterback throwing for 3,000 yards was a superstar. Today, if you throw for 3,000 yards, you’re probably getting benched. The rules have been legislated to favor the offense, specifically the passing game.
That’s why a guy like Johnny Unitas is so impressive. He was throwing for massive numbers when defensive backs were allowed to essentially tackle receivers before the ball got there. "The Golden Arm" was the first modern quarterback.
🔗 Read more: The Truth About the Memphis Grizzlies Record 2025: Why the Standings Don't Tell the Whole Story
The Active Players Climbing the Ranks
We’re currently watching history. Patrick Mahomes is already in the conversation for the top 100 NFL's greatest players, and he's not even 31 yet. If he stays healthy, he’s the only one with a realistic shot at catching Brady’s legacy.
Then you have guys like Aaron Donald, who just recently walked away. He was a defensive tackle who produced like an edge rusher. Triple-teams didn't work. Holding didn't work. He was a 280-pound ball of muscle that lived in the opposing backfield.
How to Judge Greatness for Yourself
If you want to build your own list, don't just look at the back of a football card.
Look at "dominance vs. peers." How much better was this guy than the other 31 people playing his position at the same time? That's the real metric. Also, did they change the game? Did the league have to change the rules because of them?
Mel Blount was so good at jamming receivers at the line that the NFL literally made a "Mel Blount Rule" to stop him from mugging people. That’s greatness.
Next Steps for the Die-Hard Fan:
- Watch the Tape: Go to YouTube and look up "Don Hutson highlights" or "Lawrence Taylor 1986." Seeing the speed difference between them and their peers is eye-opening.
- Check the Pro Football Hall of Fame Monitor: If you like data, Pro-Football-Reference has a "HOF Monitor" that uses a weighted scale to rank players based on All-Pros, Pro Bowls, and stats. It’s a great reality check for "homer" takes.
- Compare Eras fairly: Always look at a player’s stats relative to the league average that year. A $90$ passer rating in 1992 is worth way more than a $90$ rating in 2026.