Football fans love a good argument. It’s basically the lifeblood of the sport once the whistle blows. But if you want to start a real, table-slamming debate at a sports bar, just bring up the top 10 NFL running backs ever. People get emotional about this. You’ve got the old-school crowd who swears nobody will ever touch Jim Brown, and then you have the younger generation who thinks if you didn't play in the modern era, your stats kind of need an asterisk.
The truth is, comparing eras is a mess. How do you weigh Emmitt Smith’s indestructible longevity against Barry Sanders’ "blink and you missed it" magic? Honestly, it’s not just about the rushing yards. It’s about who changed the game, who carried their team on their back when everyone in the stadium knew the ball was going to them, and who made defenders look absolutely foolish.
The Mount Rushmore Tier
Some guys are just untouchable. You can’t have a serious conversation about the greatest without starting here.
Jim Brown is usually the starting point. Between 1957 and 1965, he wasn't just better than everyone else; he was a different species. He led the league in rushing in eight of his nine seasons. Think about that for a second. He retired at 29, still at the absolute peak of his powers, to go make movies. If he’d played another five years, the record books would probably be closed for good. He averaged 5.2 yards per carry for his entire career. In an era where everyone knew he was getting the ball, that’s just stupidly efficient.
Then there is Walter Payton. They called him "Sweetness," but he played like a tank with a Ferrari engine. He held the all-time rushing record for a long time with 16,726 yards. What made Payton special wasn't just the running; it was the fact that he was the best blocking and receiving back of his time. He didn't run out of bounds. He’d rather lower his shoulder and punish a linebacker. He was the heart of that legendary 1985 Bears team.
✨ Don't miss: What Time Did the Cubs Game End Today? The Truth About the Off-Season
Barry Sanders is the one who breaks people's brains. If you look at his highlight reel, half of his runs start with him losing three yards and end with a 40-yard touchdown. He’s the only player to have 1,500 yards in five different seasons. He walked away with 15,269 yards, and he did it without ever having a truly elite offensive line or a consistent passing threat to take the pressure off. Barry was the ultimate "what if" because he retired while he was still the best in the world.
The Production Kings
If we’re talking strictly about getting the job done over a long period, Emmitt Smith is the guy. People love to knock him because he had a Hall of Fame offensive line, but you don't get 18,355 rushing yards by accident. He was the most durable human being to ever play the position. 164 rushing touchdowns. Three Super Bowls. He was the steady heartbeat of the Cowboys dynasty. You knew he was getting 4 yards, and there wasn't a thing you could do about it.
LaDainian Tomlinson basically redefined what a "dual-threat" back looked like in the 2000s. In 2006, he had 28 rushing touchdowns and 31 total. That’s a video game stat. He could run inside, bounce it outside, and catch 100 passes a year. LT was the smoothest player on the field every single Sunday.
The Pure Power and Speed Freaks
It’s easy to forget how terrifying Eric Dickerson was. He still holds the single-season record with 2,105 yards in 1984. He was 6'3" and ran with these long, gliding strides that made it look like he was jogging, but he was actually outrunning everyone's secondary.
🔗 Read more: Jake Ehlinger Sign: The Real Story Behind the College GameDay Controversy
Adrian Peterson was the last of a dying breed—the true bell-cow back in a passing league. Coming back from a shredded ACL to rush for 2,097 yards in 2012 and win MVP is arguably the greatest individual season by a back in the 21st century. He ran with a violence that you just don't see anymore. He finished his career with 14,918 yards, sitting 5th all-time as of 2026.
Rounding Out the Elite
The final spots are where it gets really tricky. You’ve got Marshall Faulk, who was essentially a Hall of Fame wide receiver playing running back. He was the engine for the "Greatest Show on Turf" Rams. Without him, that offense doesn't work. He’s one of the few members of the 1,000/1,000 club (yards rushing and receiving in a single season).
Then there’s Earl Campbell. He didn't play long—only eight seasons—but for a three-year stretch from 1978 to 1980, he was the most dominant force in football. He won three straight Offensive Player of the Year awards. He was a human wrecking ball.
Lastly, we have to talk about Gale Sayers. Like Campbell, his career was short due to injuries. But "The Kansas Comet" was so transcendent that he made the Hall of Fame despite only playing 68 games. He was the most elusive returner and runner the league had ever seen.
💡 You might also like: What Really Happened With Nick Chubb: The Injury, The Recovery, and The Houston Twist
The 2026 Context: Where Does Derrick Henry Fit?
As we look at the landscape in 2026, Derrick Henry has forced his way into these conversations. With over 13,000 yards and a pile of touchdowns, he’s the modern Jim Brown. He’s a throwback who proved that a 245-pound man can still dominate the NFL if he’s fast enough. While he might not be top 5 yet for some purists, his peak was as high as anyone's.
Why Rankings Are Mostly Subjective
You can argue for Tony Dorsett, Marcus Allen, or even Frank Gore—the king of staying healthy. Gore finished with 16,000 yards, which is insane. But does volume alone make you "greater" than a guy like Gale Sayers? Probably not. It depends on what you value:
- Peak Dominance: Jim Brown, Terrell Davis, Earl Campbell.
- Longevity and Reliability: Emmitt Smith, Frank Gore, Walter Payton.
- Versatility: Marshall Faulk, LaDainian Tomlinson.
- Pure Talent: Barry Sanders, Gale Sayers.
What You Should Do Next
If you really want to understand the history of the position, stop looking at the spreadsheets. Go to YouTube and watch 15 minutes of Barry Sanders. Then watch 15 minutes of Earl Campbell. You’ll see two completely different ways to be the best in the world.
To dive deeper into the stats that actually matter beyond just "total yards," check out Pro Football Reference's "Era Adjusted" metrics. They do a great job of showing how a guy like Jim Brown would look in today's game. You can also look into Derrick Henry's final career splits to see how he stacks up against the legends now that his career is winding down.
Actionable Insight: If you're building an all-time fantasy roster or just debating friends, remember that "Greatness" is a mix of three things: Availability, Peak Performance, and Impact on Winning. A player like Marshall Faulk might have fewer rushing yards than Curtis Martin, but his 136 total touchdowns and Super Bowl ring carry more weight in the "Greatest" conversation.