Lana sees everything. But does she see color? It’s the question that ripples through Twitter every single time a new season of Netflix’s horniest social experiment drops. When we talk about the too hot to handle race dynamics, we aren't just talking about who gets the most "likes" on Instagram after the finale. We’re talking about a very specific, often predictable pattern of who gets picked first, who gets left on the sidelines, and how the show’s rigid beauty standards interact with racial identity.
It's messy.
If you’ve watched even one season, you know the drill. A group of impossibly fit 20-somethings arrive at a villa, thinking they're on a show called Parties in Paradise. Then, a cone-shaped AI named Lana tells them they can't touch each other. The stakes? A hundred grand that shrinks every time someone loses self-control. But while the "no-touching" rule applies to everyone, the romantic playing field has never felt particularly level.
The "Day One" Curse and Casting Archetypes
Let’s be real. There is a "type."
For years, fans have pointed out that Black women, in particular, often face a steeper hill to climb in the villa. Take Melinda Melrose from Season 2. She was a breakout star, vibrant and chaotic in the best way possible, yet she initially struggled to find a solid connection while her white counterparts were being pursued by multiple men. This isn't just a vibe; it's a recurring theme across reality TV, from Love Island to The Bachelor.
The too hot to handle race conversation usually peaks during the first episode. Why? Because that's when the "ranking" happens. In Season 4, we saw Jawahir Khalifa, a Somali-Dutch model, eventually win the whole thing. That was a huge moment. It broke the pattern. But even then, her journey was framed through a lens of being "chosen" or "not chosen" against a specific aesthetic.
Reality TV casting directors often hunt for "archetypes." You’ve got the "Lothario," the "Girl Next Door," and the "Heartbreaker." The problem is that these archetypes are historically coded as white. When you drop a diverse cast into a vacuum where the only goal is "instant physical attraction," you aren't just testing their celibacy. You’re testing their biases.
Does the Data Back This Up?
The numbers are actually quite telling if you look at the finalists and winners over the first five seasons.
- Season 1: Winners were Bryce Hirschberg (White) and Marvin Anthony (Black).
- Season 2: Marvin Anthony (Black) took the solo prize.
- Season 3: Harry Johnson and Beau Raymond (both White) split the pot.
- Season 4: Jawahir Khalifa (Black/Somali) and Nick Kici (White) won.
- Season 5: Elys Hutchinson (White) won.
On the surface, the winner's circle looks somewhat diverse. Marvin and Jawahir are proof that the "prize" isn't reserved for one group. However, winning the money is different from winning the screen time.
If you look at the "background characters"—the ones who get sent home early because they "didn't make a connection"—there is a disproportionate number of People of Color. Think about it. If the initial "hotness" metric is skewed toward Eurocentric features, the contestants who don't fit that mold have to work twice as hard to stay relevant. They have to have "more personality" just to get the same attention that a blonde guy gets by just standing there.
The Tropical Tan Paradox
It's kind of ironic. The show is obsessed with a "bronzed" look. Everyone is tanned. Everyone is glowing. But the too hot to handle race issue stems from the fact that the show celebrates "vacation tan" while often overlooking the people who have that skin tone year-round.
Social media sleuths always dive into the contestants' pasts. They look at who they followed on Instagram before the show. They look at their "type." Honestly, it’s a bit cringey when a contestant says, "I don't usually go for [insert race]," as if it's a food preference. But that’s the raw reality of the show. It exposes the dating preferences that people usually keep quiet in polite society.
The "Black Girl Magic" movement on TikTok has been a fierce critic of the series. Creators like @theccshow have broken down how editing plays a role. If a Black woman is pursued, is she shown as a romantic lead or just a "sexualized challenge"? When Rhonda Paul was on Season 1, her relationship with Sharron Townsend was the emotional core of the season. It felt real. It felt nuanced. But since then, that level of depth for non-white couples has felt a bit more sparse.
The Casting Shift in Later Seasons
Give Netflix some credit—they seem to be listening, or at least trying to look like they are.
By the time we hit Season 5 and 6, the casting started feeling less like a 2004 Abercrombie catalog. We saw more international diversity. We saw different hair textures. We saw people like Nigel Jones and Dominique Defoe bringing different energies to the villa.
But diversity in casting is only half the battle. The other half is the "environment." If you put ten people in a room and eight of them have the same "type," the other two are going to have a bad time.
The too hot to handle race issue isn't just about who is in front of the camera. It’s about the subconscious bias of the "dating market" the show creates. When the show casts people who primarily date within their own race, they are essentially setting up certain contestants for failure. It’s like playing a game of musical chairs where some people’s chairs are bolted to the floor.
📖 Related: Why Every Cartoon Character With a Big Head Actually Looks Like That
What the Contestants Say
I’ve looked into interviews from former cast members. They rarely come out and call the show "racist" because, well, NDAs are terrifying. But they do hint at the isolation.
Dominique Defoe from Season 4 has been vocal on TikTok about her experience. She’s talked about how the editing didn't always reflect the friendships and connections she actually made. She’s touched on the "Invisible Girl" trope, where POC contestants are used to fill out the background of scenes but aren't given the "main character" romantic arcs.
It’s a tough spot to be in. You’re on the biggest show in the world, you’re gorgeous, you’re in the Caribbean, and yet you feel like you’re invisible because the "standard" has been set elsewhere.
Is "Lana" the Problem?
Lana is an AI (well, a smart speaker with a production team behind her). She doesn't care about race. She cares about rules.
But the rules of Too Hot to Handle are built on a foundation of "temptation." And temptation is subjective. If the "temptations" (the grenades or newcomers) are always cast to appeal to a specific demographic, the game is rigged.
To fix the too hot to handle race problem, the show needs to stop casting "types" and start casting "interests." If they cast people who have a history of diverse dating, the villa becomes a much more dynamic place. We saw a glimpse of this with the international versions, like Too Hot to Handle: Brazil and Too Hot to Handle: Germany. These versions often felt more organic because the cultural dating norms were different from the UK/US "Instagram model" circuit.
Actionable Insights for the Savvy Viewer
If you want to look at the show through a more critical, informed lens, keep these things in mind during your next binge-watch:
- Watch the "Initial Pairing" carefully. Notice who is picked last. It’s rarely about personality at that stage; it’s about the immediate visual hierarchy.
- Track the "Screen Time vs. Survival" ratio. Some contestants stay in the villa for the whole season but only get about five minutes of actual dialogue. Check who they are.
- Look at the "Grenades." When the producers send in a new person to break up a couple, who is that person designed to attract? This reveals what the producers think the "standard" of beauty is.
- Follow the contestants post-show. The real "race" happens on social media. White contestants often see a much faster spike in followers and brand deals compared to POC contestants with the same amount of screen time.
The show is a guilty pleasure. It's meant to be trashy and fun. But even in a show about people losing money because they can't stop kissing, there's a reflection of how our society values certain people over others. Lana might be the one watching, but we’re the ones who decide who becomes a star.
Next time a new season drops, don't just look at the rule-breakers. Look at who never even got the chance to break a rule. That’s where the real story is.