You know that feeling when you're reading a thriller and you think you’ve got it all figured out by chapter three? That smug little "oh, I see what the author is doing" moment? Carola Lovering’s Too Good to Be True: A Novel basically takes that feeling and sets it on fire. Honestly, it’s one of those books that makes you question your own judgment. It’s messy. It’s manipulative. And it’s exactly why people are still obsessed with it years after its release.
The premise seems almost cliché at first glance. We meet Skye Starling, a wealthy, somewhat vulnerable young woman living in a gorgeous Manhattan apartment. She’s got OCD, she’s lonely, and then suddenly, Burke Michaels appears. He’s older, he’s charming, and he seems like the perfect antidote to her isolation. But if you’ve read any domestic noir in the last decade, you know the "perfect man" is usually a walking red flag.
The Three-Way Narrative Trap
What makes Too Good to Be True: A Novel stand out isn't just the "is he a liar?" trope. It’s the way Lovering structures the deception. We get three points of view: Skye in the present, Burke in the present, and a woman named Heather in the past (specifically 2002).
At first, the timelines feel disconnected. You’re reading Skye’s chapters and feeling bad for her. She’s genuinely falling in love. Then you jump to Burke’s perspective, and it’s like a cold shower. He’s calculated. He’s clearly running a con. But then there’s Heather. Her story starts years earlier in a small town, and the slow-burn realization of how she connects to Burke and Skye is where the real "wait, what?" moments happen.
💡 You might also like: Why The Real Housewives of Potomac Season 8 Felt So Different
It isn't a fast-paced action movie. It’s a psychological grind. Lovering spends a lot of time on the why. Why is Skye so susceptible? Why is Burke doing this? The book explores the idea that everyone has a "price" for their morality. Sometimes that price is money, but often, it's just the desire to be seen by someone else.
Why Too Good to Be True: A Novel Hits Differently Than Other Thrillers
Most thrillers rely on a single "big reveal" at the 80% mark. You know the one—the dead body isn't actually dead, or the narrator was the killer all along. Lovering doesn't play that game. She gives you several smaller, devastating reveals throughout the middle of the book.
By the time you reach the halfway point of Too Good to Be True: A Novel, you already know Burke is a fraud. The suspense isn't about if he’s lying; it’s about the specific cruelty of the lie and whether Skye will survive the fallout. It’s more of a "how will this train wreck end?" than a "who dunnit?"
Character Flaws as Plot Devices
Skye isn't your typical "strong female lead." She’s fragile. She’s been through trauma. Some readers find her frustrating because she ignores glaring warning signs. But that’s kind of the point. Lovering is tapping into the reality of emotional manipulation. When you want something to be true—like the idea that a handsome stranger has fallen for you despite your insecurities—you’ll jump through mental hoops to make the logic work.
Burke is equally complex. He’s not a mustache-twirling villain. He’s a guy who made a series of increasingly terrible decisions until he found himself backed into a corner. His marriage to his wife, his financial struggles, and his secret life create a character who is pathetic and dangerous at the same time.
Then we have the setting. The contrast between the glitzy, high-stakes world of New York's elite and the gritty, desperate background of the characters' pasts creates a constant tension. It reminds me of the vibe in Tell Me Lies—Lovering’s other hit—where toxic relationships are dissected with surgical precision.
Addressing the Common Criticisms
Not everyone loves this book. If you go on Goodreads or StoryGraph, you’ll see plenty of three-star reviews. People often complain about the pacing. It’s true: the middle section can feel like it’s treading water while you wait for the timelines to finally merge.
Some readers also find the ending polarizing. Without giving away the spoilers, it’s not exactly a "happily ever after" wrapped in a neat bow. It’s more of a "this is the mess we made" type of conclusion. But honestly? That feels more authentic to the themes of the story. Real-life deception doesn't usually end with a clean slate. It ends with scars.
The Core Themes You Might Have Missed
While it's marketed as a thriller, Too Good to Be True: A Novel is secretly a study on class and privilege. Skye’s wealth acts as both a shield and a target. It protects her from the mundane struggles of life, but it also makes her an object to be acquired rather than a person to be loved.
- The Weight of Secrets: Every character is carrying something heavy. Whether it’s a childhood trauma or a financial debt, these secrets drive every interaction.
- The Illusion of Choice: Burke often feels like he has to do what he’s doing. Lovering explores whether we actually have agency or if our past mistakes lock us into a specific path.
- The Female Experience of Gaslighting: The book does a terrifyingly good job of showing how a manipulator can make a woman doubt her own senses, especially when she’s already dealing with mental health challenges like Skye's OCD.
Lovering wrote this with a very specific cadence. She isn't trying to be Agatha Christie. She’s trying to be a fly on the wall of a very dysfunctional dinner party.
Real-World Inspiration and Context
While the book is fiction, the mechanics of the "long con" are based on very real psychological tactics. Experts in domestic abuse and financial fraud often talk about the "love bombing" phase, which is exactly what Burke does to Skye. He overwhelms her with affection and attention early on to bypass her natural defenses.
👉 See also: Your Worst Nightmare Season 4: Why These True Crime Stories Still Haunt Us
Carola Lovering has mentioned in interviews that she is fascinated by why people stay in bad situations. This book is a direct extension of that curiosity. It’s not just about the crime; it’s about the psychology of the victim and the perpetrator.
Actionable Insights for Readers and Writers
If you’re looking to dive into this book or if you’ve already finished it and want something similar, here are a few ways to process the experience:
For the Readers:
Don't rush the first 100 pages. The setup is dense, but it's necessary for the payoff. If you’re struggling with Skye’s naivety, try to view it through the lens of her specific mental health struggles. It makes her more empathetic. If you liked the "multiple timelines that eventually crash into each other" style, you should definitely check out The Two Lives of Lydia Bird or The Only One Left by Riley Sager.
For the Aspiring Writers:
Pay attention to how Lovering handles the "villain" POV. She doesn't make Burke completely unlikable from page one. He has moments of genuine guilt. That ambiguity is what keeps the reader turning the page. If he were just a monster, we’d get bored. Because he’s a human who is making monstrous choices, we’re hooked.
For those into Psychological Deep Dives:
Look into the concept of "Cognitive Dissonance" in relationships. It’s the mental discomfort of holding two conflicting beliefs—like "I love this man" and "this man is stealing from me." This novel is essentially a 300-page case study on that exact phenomenon.
Final Thoughts on the Narrative Arc
The title Too Good to Be True: A Novel is a warning. It’s a meta-commentary on the genre itself. We want the romance to be real. We want the girl to get the guy. But in Lovering’s world, those desires are exactly what get you into trouble.
It’s a dark, twisty, and sometimes uncomfortable read. It doesn’t offer easy answers. But if you’re looking for a book that will stay in your head long after you’ve closed the back cover, this is it. It’s a reminder that the most dangerous lies are the ones we tell ourselves so we can sleep at night.
To get the most out of your reading experience, try to track the dates at the beginning of the chapters. The 2002 timeline is the key to everything. If you lose track of the years, you’ll lose the thread of the mystery. Pay attention to the small details in Heather’s childhood—they mirror Skye’s adulthood in ways that are both subtle and brilliant.
The book is available in most major bookstores and on all digital platforms. If you haven't picked it up yet, go in with an open mind and don't trust anyone—especially the narrator.