If you spent the last fourteen years watching Danny Reagan lose his cool at the dinner table, you basically watched Tony and Andrew Terraciano grow up in real-time. It’s a trip. One minute they’re little kids barely reaching the mashed potatoes, and the next, they’re grown men with deep voices and actual career paths that have nothing to do with Hollywood.
Most child stars end up in a weird spiral or trying to cling to fame until it gets awkward. Not these two. Honestly, the story of what happened to the Terraciano brothers is way more interesting than the "where are they now" fluff you usually see. They didn’t just leave a hit show; they chose a completely different life.
Tony and Andrew Terraciano: Life After the Reagan Dinner Table
Let’s get the big question out of the way. People keep asking why Tony and Andrew Terraciano aren't in the new spinoff, Boston Blue. If you haven't heard, Boston Blue premiered in late 2025, following Danny Reagan (Donnie Wahlberg) to Massachusetts. But when Sean Reagan appeared on screen, it wasn't Andrew. It was Mika Amonsen.
Fans were kind of crushed. You’ve got to understand, Andrew played Sean for 14 seasons. He was the heart of that house after Linda died. Seeing a new face in that role felt wrong to a lot of people.
But here’s the thing: it wasn't some dramatic firing. Andrew actually graduated from New York University in May 2025. While fans were hoping he’d suit up as a cop in Boston, he was busy finishing a degree in History with a minor in Italian literature. He’s currently working on his Master’s degree. When he talked to Us Weekly recently, he was super chill about it. He basically said he’s been so busy with grad school that he hasn't even had time to watch the new show yet.
Where is Tony Terraciano?
Tony, the older brother who played Jack Reagan, made his exit even earlier. He’s been a ghost on the show since around Season 10, only popping in for a quick cameo when his schedule allowed.
✨ Don't miss: Brooklyn and Bailey Nose Job: What Really Happened with Those Plastic Surgery Rumors
Why? Because he’s literally becoming a doctor.
Tony went to Vanderbilt University, studied neuroscience, and is now finishing up his MD at the Albert Einstein College of Medicine in the Bronx. He’s set to graduate in 2026. While his character Jack Reagan was off at "college" in the show, Tony was actually in the library grinding through one of the hardest career paths possible.
The Recasting Controversy of 2025
The Boston Blue recasting of Sean Reagan caused a massive stir on Reddit and Twitter. People felt like Andrew was "robbed." But the showrunners, Brandon Margolis and Brandon Sonnier, explained that they wanted to tell a "new chapter." Since Sean is now a patrolman in Boston, they wanted an actor who could bring a different physical energy to the "cop" version of the character.
Andrew’s reaction? Total class.
He told People that he actually got a call from Donnie Wahlberg before the news went public. He’s not bitter. He said he "got the joy of playing Sean" and now he’s happy to let someone else take the reins while he focuses on his studies. You don't see that kind of maturity from 22-year-olds in Hollywood very often.
🔗 Read more: Bobby Sherman Health Update: What Really Happened to the Teen Idol
A Career Built on Reality
What most people get wrong about Tony and Andrew Terraciano is the idea that they were "actors" first. In a lot of ways, they were just kids who happened to have a very famous Friday night dinner.
- Tony Terraciano was only eight when the pilot filmed.
- Andrew Terraciano was six.
- They stayed on the show for nearly 300 episodes.
They didn't go to some fancy performing arts school. They went to normal schools in Westchester, played lacrosse, and did homework in their trailers. Their dad is an ophthalmologist (Dr. Anthony J. Terraciano), so the move toward medicine for Tony wasn't a random pivot—it was the family business.
The Vanderbilt and NYU Years
During the later seasons of Blue Bloods, the writers had to get creative. Tony was in Nashville at Vanderbilt, so Jack Reagan was written as being away at college. Andrew stayed closer to home at NYU, which is why Sean was able to stay at the Sunday dinners until the very final episode of the original series in 2024.
It’s kind of wild to think that while Andrew was filming scenes about Sean’s teenage rebellion or his interest in the NYPD, he was actually writing papers on Italian literature.
Why They Probably Won't Return
Look, everyone wants a cameo. And Andrew has said that if Donnie Wahlberg calls and asks him for anything, he’ll be there. They’re "family first," according to him.
💡 You might also like: Blair Underwood First Wife: What Really Happened with Desiree DaCosta
But realistically? Tony is about to start a residency. If you know anything about the medical field, you know that residents don't have time to sleep, let alone fly to a film set to play a guest role. He’s focused on neurosurgery and stroke research. He’s moved on.
Andrew seems a bit more open to the arts—he even wrote and acted in a short film called A First Step Into Darkness back in 2022—but his Master’s degree is the priority right now.
Actionable Insights for Fans
If you're missing the original Reagan boys, here is how you can actually support them and stay updated without falling for fake "comeback" rumors:
- Follow their real milestones: Andrew is active on Instagram and shared his graduation photos recently. It's the best place to see what he’s actually doing.
- Support the spinoff: Even if you're mad about the recasting, the Blue Bloods universe continues. Mika Amonsen has been vocal about his respect for what Andrew built.
- Respect the pivot: Tony has clearly chosen a life of service in medicine. He doesn't seem to have any interest in the "fame" side of things anymore.
The Terraciano brothers are the rare success story of child actors who didn't let the industry define them. They took the money they made from 14 years on a hit show and used it to pay for some of the best educations in the country. That’s a win in any book.
To keep up with their latest moves, keep an eye on alumni updates from NYU and the Albert Einstein College of Medicine, as both brothers are leaning heavily into their academic and professional careers rather than the red carpet circuit.