I remember the first time I saw a tube of Tom's of Maine Propolis and Myrrh toothpaste. It looked like something from an old-school apothecary shop, not a modern bathroom. Honestly, the idea of brushing your teeth with bee glue and ancient incense sounds kinda sketchy. But then you try it. You realize that while most big-name brands are basically just mint-flavored detergent, this stuff is doing something entirely different. It’s gritty. It’s earthy. It’s incredibly effective if you’re prone to "angry" gums.
People usually find this specific toothpaste because they’re desperate. They've tried the neon-blue gels and the charcoal fads, but their gums still bleed or feel sensitive. That’s where the Tom's Propolis Myrrh toothpaste comes in. It’s not just "natural" for the sake of being trendy; it’s a formulation based on ingredients that have been used for literally thousands of years. We aren't just talking about a hippie brand from Maine anymore. This is about chemistry that actually respects the oral microbiome.
What’s actually inside the tube?
Most people assume "natural" means "weak." That is a massive mistake. Propolis is basically the immune system of a beehive. Bees collect resins from trees and mix them with enzymes to seal their hives. It’s an antifungal and antibacterial powerhouse. When you put that in a toothpaste, you’re introducing a biological shield into your mouth. Then you have myrrh. If you grew up hearing about the Three Wise Men, you know the name, but you probably didn't know it’s a potent resin from the Commiphora tree.
Myrrh is a vasoconstrictor. It helps soothe inflamed tissue. If your gums are puffy or red, myrrh acts like a quiet, herbal fire extinguisher.
The texture is another story. Tom’s uses calcium carbonate as the abrasive. It’s basically refined chalk. It doesn't foam like a bubble bath because it lacks Sodium Lauryl Sulfate (SLS). For many, SLS is the secret villain behind canker sores. If you get those painful little ulcers frequently, switching to an SLS-free paste like this one is often the "aha!" moment you’ve been looking for.
📖 Related: Why PMS Food Cravings Are So Intense and What You Can Actually Do About Them
The fluoride debate: Where does Tom’s stand?
It’s confusing. Tom’s of Maine makes several versions of this paste. Some have fluoride, and some don’t. You have to check the box carefully. The "Anti-Plaque" version is usually the fluoride-free one, relying on the mechanical action of brushing and the antibacterial properties of the resins to keep things clean.
Dentists generally want you to have fluoride to rematerialize enamel. However, many people choose the Tom's Propolis Myrrh toothpaste specifically to avoid it. If you’re opting for the fluoride-free version, you have to be more diligent with your flossing. You can’t just "lazy brush" and expect the resins to do 100% of the work. It’s a partnership between the ingredients and your technique.
Why your gums might stop bleeding
Gingivitis is basically just a constant low-level war in your mouth. Bacteria build up, your immune system freaks out, and blood follows. Propolis has been studied—real, peer-reviewed studies—for its ability to inhibit Porphyromonas gingivalis. That’s the nasty stuff responsible for gum disease.
A study published in the Journal of Clinical Diagnostic Research found that propolis-based mouthwashes and pastes significantly reduced plaque scores. It’s not magic. It’s just making the environment in your mouth less hospitable for "bad" bacteria while being gentle on the soft tissue.
👉 See also: 100 percent power of will: Why Most People Fail to Find It
Honestly, the taste is the biggest hurdle. It’s not "sweet mint." It’s "medicinal fennel." It’s an acquired taste, sort of like black coffee or peaty scotch. But once you get used to that clean, non-coated feeling in your mouth, going back to sugary, syrupy toothpaste feels gross. Your teeth feel "squeaky" in a way that suggests the biofilm has actually been disrupted, not just covered up with artificial flavoring.
Breaking down the "Clean" label
Tom’s was bought by Colgate-Palmolive years ago, which made a lot of die-hard fans nervous. They thought the quality would tank. Surprisingly, the Propolis and Myrrh formula has stayed remarkably consistent. They still don't use artificial colors, flavors, or preservatives.
- No animal testing.
- No artificial sweeteners (they use xylitol or stevia, depending on the specific batch/run).
- Recyclable tubes (though you have to check if your local facility accepts them).
The presence of Myrrh is particularly interesting for those with "dentures sores" or irritation from braces. It creates a sort of soothing film. It’s not a numbing agent like benzocaine, but it definitely takes the edge off of localized irritation.
The Reality Check: It’s not for everyone
We have to be real here. If you have a bee allergy, stay away. Propolis is a bee product. While rare, an allergic reaction in the mouth is the last thing you want.
✨ Don't miss: Children’s Hospital London Ontario: What Every Parent Actually Needs to Know
Also, if you are looking for "high-wattage" whitening, look elsewhere. This paste is about health, not vanity. It will remove surface stains from coffee or tea because of the calcium carbonate, but it won’t bleach your teeth three shades whiter in a week. It doesn't contain peroxides. It's a maintenance tool, not a cosmetic treatment.
Some users complain that the paste is "too thick" or that it separates in the tube if it gets too warm. That's the trade-off for not using a bunch of synthetic emulsifiers. Give the tube a little squeeze or shake before you open it. Problem solved.
How to get the most out of it
Don't rinse immediately. This is the pro tip most people miss. Because propolis and myrrh are resinous, they benefit from a little "dwell time" on the gums. Brush thoroughly for two minutes, spit out the excess, and wait about five or ten minutes before chugging a glass of water. Let those natural resins sit on the gum line.
If you're dealing with a specific "hot spot" or a sore on your gum, you can even dab a tiny bit of the paste directly on the area before bed. It’s a trick old-timers have used for decades.
Practical Steps for a Healthier Mouth
If you’re ready to switch to a more botanical approach to oral care, don't just buy the first tube you see.
- Check the label for SLS: If you want to avoid canker sores, ensure it says "SLS-Free."
- Decide on Fluoride: Decide if you want the "Anti-Plaque" (usually fluoride-free) or the "Whole Care" version.
- Commit for 2 weeks: Your taste buds need time to adjust to the fennel/herbal profile. Don't quit after one brush.
- Watch your gum line: Take a "before" photo of your gums. After 14 days of using propolis and myrrh, check if the redness has subsided.
- Pair with a soft brush: High-abrasion pastes (even natural ones) work best with soft-bristled brushes to avoid wearing down enamel.
The shift toward ingredients like propolis and myrrh isn't just a "back to nature" fad. It's a recognition that the chemical-heavy approach of the 1990s might have been overkill for daily maintenance. By using resins that trees and bees use to protect themselves, we're essentially outsourcing our defense to the experts of the natural world. It’s earthy, it’s a bit strange, and it works.