Honestly, if you only look at the surface, Tommy Miller seems like the "easy" one. He’s the younger brother who managed to find a wife, a community, and a working electricity grid while the rest of the world was eating itself alive. But if you've actually spent time with tommy the last of us, you know that’s basically a lie. He’s not the "nice" version of Joel. He’s arguably just as dangerous, twice as stubborn, and by the end of Part II, he’s the most tragic figure in the entire franchise.
Most people talk about Ellie’s descent into darkness or Joel’s moral grayness. They sort of overlook the guy who actually held the family together—or tried to—for twenty years.
The Texas Years and the "Falling Out"
Before the world ended, Tommy was a soldier. That’s a detail from the HBO show that helps explain his precision with a rifle, but even in the games, the military background is felt in how he carries himself. When the Cordyceps hit, he was the one driving the car. He was the one who stayed behind to hold off the infected so Joel could carry Sarah. He’s always been the protector, even when Joel was the "strong" one.
But then things got ugly.
The brothers spent years surviving by any means necessary. Joel implies they did things that gave him nightmares, but for Tommy, it was worse. He couldn't live with the "hunter" lifestyle. He told Joel he didn't want to see his "god damn face ever again" and joined the Fireflies. He was looking for hope, or maybe just a way to wash the blood off his hands.
It didn't work. He eventually left the Fireflies too, realizing they were just another group of people with guns and a different set of excuses.
Why the Jackson Reunion Matters So Much
When we finally see tommy the last of us again at the dam in Wyoming, he’s a changed man. He’s got Maria. He’s got a town. He’s trying to build something that isn't just "survival."
🔗 Read more: Magic Thread: What Most People Get Wrong in Fisch
The tension in that scene is thick because Tommy has what Joel wants: a life. When Joel tries to dump Ellie on him, Tommy initially says no. Not because he’s a jerk, but because he knows the cost of that world. He has a wife to think about. He has a community that relies on him.
The moment he changes his mind—after Ellie runs away and he sees how much Joel actually cares—is the last time we see "Good Guy Tommy." From there, it's a slow slide back into the man he tried to leave behind in Texas.
The Sniper of Seattle: A Different Beast
If you want to see what tommy the last of us is actually capable of, you have to look at the Marina sequence in The Last of Us Part II.
For half the game, you hear about this "lone sniper" picking off WLF soldiers. You see the bodies. You hear the fear in the WLF radio chatter. Then, you play as Abby and you're the one in the crosshairs.
It is terrifying.
- He’s not just a good shot; he’s a ghost.
- He uses the environment to funnel you into kill zones.
- He kills Manny—one of the WLF's best—without a second thought.
When you finally corner him and realize it's Tommy, it’s a massive "oh crap" moment. This isn't the guy who was handing out jerky and fixing the gate in Jackson. This is the man who survived the early days of the outbreak by being more ruthless than the monsters. He went to Seattle alone, ahead of Ellie, because he wanted to keep her safe—but also because he knew he was the only one who could actually pull off a one-man war.
💡 You might also like: Is the PlayStation 5 Slim Console Digital Edition Actually Worth It?
What Really Happened in the Theater?
The ending of the Seattle arc is where everything falls apart for Tommy. He gets shot in the leg, then he gets shot in the face.
Most characters would die there.
Tommy survives, but "survival" is a generous word for what’s left. He loses an eye. He walks with a permanent, painful limp. His marriage with Maria is basically over—they're "on a break," which in the apocalypse is essentially a divorce.
The most controversial part of his character happens at the farm. He shows up and guilt-trips Ellie into going to Santa Barbara.
"You have a lead. You're gonna just let her go?"
It’s a hard scene to watch. He’s bitter. He’s broken. He’s using Joel’s memory like a weapon against a girl who is clearly suffering from PTSD. But you have to understand where he’s coming from. He lost his brother. He lost his health. He lost his wife. Abby took everything from him and he’s physically unable to go finish the job himself. He’s a shell of a man living on nothing but spite.
📖 Related: How to Solve 6x6 Rubik's Cube Without Losing Your Mind
Game vs. Show: The Dad Factor
In the HBO series, they added a massive twist: Maria is pregnant.
This changes the stakes for tommy the last of us significantly. In the game, he goes to Seattle out of a mix of love for Joel and a sense of duty. In the show, he’s leaving behind a child. It makes his decision to hunt Abby even more reckless and shows how deep the Miller brothers' trauma goes. They can't just be happy. They can't just let things go.
Gabriel Luna plays this version of Tommy with a sort of quiet intensity that matches Jeffrey Pierce’s original performance but adds a layer of "I'm trying so hard to be a good man" that makes the eventual fall even more painful.
Actionable Insights for Fans and Players
If you're revisiting the games or watching the show for the first time, keep an eye on how Tommy reflects Joel. They are two sides of the same coin. Joel is the wall; Tommy is the bridge. But once the bridge breaks, there’s no way back.
- Pay attention to the weapons: Tommy uses a customized M14. It’s a precision tool, unlike Joel’s "hit it with a pipe" approach. It tells you everything about how he thinks.
- Re-watch the "Kin" episode: Look at Tommy's face when Joel confesses he’s scared. It’s the first time the younger brother has to be the elder.
- Don't skip the notes in Seattle: The artifacts you find as Ellie and Abby tell the story of Tommy’s trail of destruction. It’s a masterclass in environmental storytelling.
Tommy isn't just a sidekick. He’s the personification of the cost of the "Jackson Dream." He tried to build a world where he could be soft again, but the world wouldn't let him. By the time the credits roll on Part II, he’s the living proof that revenge doesn't just kill the target—it rots the person holding the gun.
If there is a Part III, Tommy is the biggest wildcard left on the board. He’s a man with nothing left to lose and a very long memory. That’s a dangerous combination in a world where the only thing cheaper than life is a bullet.